logo

84 pages 2 hours read

Howard Pyle

The Story of King Arthur and His Knights

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 1903

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Book 1, Part 2Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Book 1, Part 2: “The Winning of a Sword”

Book 1, Part 2, Introduction Summary

The narrator introduces the next tale, in which Arthur will face a Sable Knight and receive the legendary sword Excalibur by meeting a Lady at a Lake of Enchantment.

Book 1, Part 2, Chapter 1 Summary

In spring, Arthur and his Court travel through the Forests of Usk and stop to rest in the shade. At this time, his Court includes Kay, Gawaine, Ewaine, Pellias, and seven other knights. A wounded knight in white and azure—later named as Sir Myles of the White Fountain—approaches the group on horseback with his page. Arthur orders his knights to help the injured man. After he is treated, the injured knight is brought to Arthur’s pavilion with his page.

The page and Sir Myles came from the north seeking adventure. Myles defeated six other knights in a fortnight (14 days). That morning, they discovered three damsels tossing a ball in front of a castle. When they learned he was in search of adventure, one damsel gave him directions to a bridge. Myles and his page followed the directions and found a castle beyond the bridge. On the bridge was a black shield with a brass hammer, and a sign indicating that whoever hits the shield does so at his peril. Myles hit the shield with the hammer, and a knight in sable emerged from the castle on horseback. He challenged Myles, and they fought with spears. The Sable Knight wounded Myles, took his shield, and hung it on an apple tree with other shields.

Arthur is offended by the Sable Knight’s lack of courtesy, specifically, not checking on the severity of Myles’s injuries and stealing his shield. Arthur’s knights agree, and Griflet, a squire, asks Arthur to knight him and allow him to go after the Sable Knight. Arthur hesitates because Griflet is young and inexperienced, but reluctantly agrees. Griflet watches over his armor in a chapel of the forest all night and is knighted by Arthur after taking the Sacrament in the morning. As Griflet rides off to face the Sable Knight, Sir Myles dies.

Later that evening, Griflet returns with severe injuries and no shield. As his wounds are treated in Arthur’s tent, he tells Arthur about his adventure. Griflet met the same damsels and found the same bridge as Myles. The Sable Knight tried to talk the young Griflet out of fighting, but Griflet could not be persuaded. After the Sable Knight pierced Griflet in the side with his spear, he took Griflet’s shield, and helped him onto his horse so he could get help.

King Arthur, furious, decides to fight the Sable Knight himself the next day. He cannot be talked out of his decision and stays up all night pacing in his pavilion. In the morning, he rides his white war-horse towards the bridge. The beautiful spring day cheers up Arthur. He admires the landscape of the Valley of Delight and sees the damsels, who invite him to feast with them for a few days. He refuses, saying he is going after the Sable Knight. The damsels tell him that two knights in two days have been beaten by the Sable Knight, and that he should eat before going into battle. They send for pages who bring food and drink.

Arthur picnics with the damsels, keeping his identity a secret. Afterwards, they show him the path to the Sable Knight. He encounters three men with knives chasing an old, bearded man. When Arthur rides towards them, they drop their weapons and flee. The old man turns out to be Merlin. Merlin foresees Arthur suffering in this adventure and asks to come along. Arthur agrees, and they ride off together.

Book 1, Part 2, Chapter 2 Summary

Arthur and Merlin reach the bridge of the Sable Knight. Arthur remarks on the huge number of shields in the apple-tree. Merlin foresees Arthur’s shield will not end up in the tree today. Arthur hits the shield on the bridge, summoning the Sable Knight, who demands his shield. Arthur refuses to hand it over and challenges the knight.

They fight on horseback, and both break their spears in the first pass. Arthur acknowledges his opponent’s skill and asks to move to battle on foot with swords. The Sable Knight refuses, and his two squires bring new spears. Again, both spears break in the joust. Again, Arthur asks to fight with swords, and the Sable Knight has two more spears brought out. In the third joust, Arthur’s spear breaks, but the Sable Knight’s does not. Arthur’s horse falls over, but Arthur lands on his feet. Arthur demands the knight fight him with a sword on foot, and the Sable Knight refuses, demanding Arthur’s shield. Arthur pushes the Sable Knight’s horse over, so the knight ends up on foot.

Then, they fight furiously with swords. Arthur’s sword breaks as he lands a powerful hit. When the Sable Knight recovers his wits, he hits Arthur, damaging his shield and severely wounding his head. Arthur refuses to yield and wrestles him to the ground, causing the Sable Knight to lose consciousness. Arthur takes off his helmet and discovers the knight is King Pellinore, who waged war against Arthur twice.

Arthur puts a dagger at Pellinore’s throat as he comes to, but Pellinore is able to push it away easily because Arthur is beginning to faint due to blood loss. Pellinore flips Arthur, gaining the upper hand. Merlin intervenes, telling Pellinore that he is about to kill King Arthur, but this revelation makes Pellinore more determined to kill Arthur.

Merlin uses his staff to cast a spell and Pellinore falls to the ground, asleep. Merlin helps Arthur get on his horse and leads it into the forest. They travel to a hermit’s sanctuary, where the hermit and Merlin treat Arthur’s wounds. Arthur convalesces, near death, for two days.

On the second day, Lady Guinevere and her court come to the hermit’s sanctuary, hoping he can cure her sick page. She sees Arthur, but Merlin does not reveal his identity. Guinevere orders her doctor to treat Arthur, and Arthur begins to heal. In three days, after Guinevere and her court leave the sanctuary, Arthur is completely recovered. He continues to think about Guinevere, desiring to serve her as a knight.

Book 1, Part 2, Chapter 3 Summary

Four days after being cured by Guinevere’s doctor, Arthur tells Merlin he wants a rematch with Pellinore. Merlin tells Arthur about Arroy, also called the Forest of Adventure, and a lake of enchantment where a woman’s arm emerges holding the sword Excalibur. No knight has ever been able to reach the woman’s arm in the lake. Arthur desires Excalibur, and Merlin guides him to Arroy. When they arrive later that day, they follow a white doe with a golden collar. It leads them to a table full of food under a bower, and a page invites King Arthur, by name, to eat. Merlin assures Arthur that the food is safe, foreseeing his success in this adventure, and they feast. Afterwards, they ride through the forest to a plain filled with flowers. The enchanted lake lies in the middle of this plain. As Arthur ponders how to get the sword, the Lady of the Lake approaches. Arthur greets her, identifying her as Fay, a kind of immortal magical being, and she tells him her name is Nymue. Nymue reveals that the lake is an illusion hiding a castle and welcomes Arthur.

Arthur explains that he broke his sword in the battle with Pellinore, and now seeks Excalibur. Nymue warns him of the danger but supports his quest by calling for a boat with a whistle. Arthur boards the boat, which takes to the arm holding the sword. He grabs the sword and scabbard, and the arm goes under the water. The boat returns to the shore, Arthur thanks Nymue, and rides off with Merlin and Excalibur.

After lodging with the hermit for another night, Arthur and Merlin ride back to the Sable Knight, Pellinore. Arthur forbids Merlin from working magic and challenges Pellinore again. Pellinore agrees, and pages bring them spears. The spears shatter in their joust, and they fight on foot with swords. Arthur uses Excalibur to defeat Pellinore without sustaining any injuries. When Pellinore asks for Arthur to spare his life, Arthur offers to restore Pellinore’s title and lands in exchange for his two sons. The narrator notes that these sons, Sir Aglaval and Sir Lamorack, become knights of the Round Table. Pellinore’s wounds are treated and he hosts Arthur and Merlin for the night.

In the morning, Arthur and Merlin have a pleasant ride through the beautiful forest. Arthur thinks about his success, and the narrator sends good wishes to the reader—that they might also find success and joy. Merlin asks Arthur if he prefers the sword or scabbard, and Arthur replies that he prefers Excalibur’s blade. Merlin explains that the scabbard keeps the wearer from being wounded, such as in his fight with Pellinore. Being protected by magic angers Arthur and he threatens to return Excalibur. However, Merlin persuades him to keep the sword by explaining he needs to protect himself because, as king, his life belongs to the people.

Arthur treasures the bright sword Excalibur and has a special box made for it, only taking it out for battle. The narrator explains that although Arthur keeps Excalibur for the rest of his life, he loses the scabbard in an adventure that will be included later in the book. The narrator ends the chapter, and Part 2, with a blessing for the reader from God.

Book 1, Part 2 Analysis

The Story of King Arthur and His Knights comprises a series of linked stories, or episodes, rather than one sustained narrative arc. This narrative structure references Sir Thomas Mallory’s Le Morte d’Arthur (1485), the primary literary source for Arthurian legend, which predates the modern novel form and was written during a shift in popular storytelling from verse to prose. Each new adventure reveals a new aspect of King Arthur’s character, as Pyle puts his own authorial twist on well-known legends and generic tropes of chivalric romances, including knightly quests, courtly manners, and acts of heroism.

In Part 2, Pyle develops the motif of arms and armor, using the quest for the magic sword Excalibur to develop Arthur’s character. When the Lady of the Lake tells Arthur “no man may win yonder sword unless he be without fear and without reproach,” Arthur admits that “I do reproach myself” for some actions in his past (87). Since Arthur is still successful in winning Excalibur, Arthur demonstrates that the model king is both courageous and self-aware. In addition to Arthur gaining his famous sword, Part 2 introduces the importance of shields. The crests on shields can be used to identify—or misidentify—knights whose faces are hidden by helmets, and control of one’s shield is a sign of honor. The Sable Knight, Pellinore, has an “apple-tree hung over with a multitude of shields” (55), meaning he dishonored many knights. Arthur has to overcome the Sable Knight to return these shields to their rightful owners, restoring their honor. Through Arthur’s ultimate victory over Pellinore, Pyle emphasizes Arthur’s leadership and responsibility to others: Arthur fights not only for his own glory, but to maintain peace in his kingdom. Similarly, Arthur’s invitation to Pellinore’s sons to join his court indicates Arthur’s moral character, as he seeks reconciliation with his enemies rather than vengeance. Arthur’s anger over the magical protection of Excalibur’s scabbard emphasizes his honor, but Pyle complicates the notion of honor through Merlin’s suggestion that Arthur, as king, is no longer responsible only for himself. Arthur’s kingship carries responsibilities, not just power. The narrator’s foreshadowing that Arthur will eventually lose the magic scabbard increases the dramatic stakes of the following stories, as the reader knows Arthur will one day become more vulnerable to defeat.

Pyle also develops the theme of green, undeveloped spaces versus urban spaces in Part 2. Many adventures, such as Arthur’s quest for Excalibur, begin in the “Forest of Usk” (51), a green space. The green space of the forest also holds healers, like the hermit who lives in a beautiful “part of the forest” and helps Arthur after he is wounded by Pellinore (75). In Part 2, Pyle presents the natural world as a landscape of adventure, magic, and chance meetings. Arthur must venture deeper into nature to find Excalibur and acquire the power to defeat Pellinore at Pellinore’s own castle. Through Arthur’s victory, Pyle contrasts the supernatural powers and potential resources of the natural world with the structured safety and security of civilization.

The hermit’s chapel in the woods is also where Arthur meets Guinevere, which inspires his quest for her love in Part 3. Their meeting is an example of courtly love—Arthur sees her as an “angel who had descended from one of the Lordly Courts of Paradise” (77). Courtly love, a common element of chivalric romances, is defined by chastity and knightly honor, elevating romantic adoration to a kind of religious worship.

Furthermore, in Part 2, Pyle develops the color motif that runs throughout the novel. In addition to Pellinore dressing all in black, causing him to be called the Sable Knight, the damsels who Arthur meets on his way to fight Pellinore are dressed in “flame-colored satin” (60). Red and black are some of the core colors that are repeated in this and many other Arthurian texts. Red is often aligned with love, religion, or passion, and black often indicates a mysterious or supernatural figure. For example, black hair is common among Arthurian fay and the Lady of the Lake, Nymue, is described with black eyes and hair “like silk and as black as it was possible to be” (85). 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text