49 pages • 1 hour read
Vanessa ChanA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
One of the most significant elements of Chan’s novel is the decision to focus on a character who fosters the Japanese occupation of Malaya. This hardly paints Cecily Alcantara as a hero, especially as much of the novel temporally distances itself from her actions by presenting those actions in flashback. The consequences of her actions, on the other hand, form part of the narrative present. It is likewise telling that much of Chan’s novel is not only set during the Japanese occupation, but also during its nadir. With the bombing of Nagasaki, the world sees a turn in the tide of the Pacific theater of war. The closing of a years-long conflict is in sight, along with the end of Japan’s dominance of the region. In this sense, The Storm We Made is essentially a novel of resolutions, each one showing that the protagonist had chosen a flawed course of action that led to tragic results. But Cecily’s motivations are also complex, and one might even argue that the logic behind her actions is deeply sympathetic.
Cecily operates from a desire to liberate Malaya from British influence. The colonial power of the Western empire ensures that Cecily and her family members are treated abusively in their own homeland. Cecily’s entire life, from childhood to motherhood, has been shaped by the condescension and the violence of the British. To make matters worse, the Malayan people not only defer to British customs, but also they aspire to British ideals. This is represented best by her husband, Gordon, whose careerist attitude as a civil servant forces him to constantly seek the approval of his European peers. Cecily is disgusted with the way Malaya has been reduced to a serf state for their lords in the British Empire, which is why she immediately resonates with Fujiwara’s promise of an Asia for Asians.
Fujiwara enters Cecily’s life while posing as a merchant. His disguise mirrors the kind of life that Cecily despises, courting favor with the upper crust of British Malayan society by showing his keen knowledge of European fashions and opening himself up to self-deprecation. But this disguise is purposeful as it allows him to undermine the British colony in Malaya. When Cecily begins her own double life as an informant, she finds herself playing the role of her a domestic housewife much better. Everything she does in her secret life, she reasons, is for the greater good of her people. She is consequently thrilled by every result that her sabotage affects, culminating in her suggestion to invade Malaya from the north. By this point, Fujiwara sees her as an equal, which has always been her greatest aspiration. After Fujiwara leaves to manage Japan’s campaign in China, Cecily does not hesitate to abandon Lina’s baby to destiny, implying her belief that the liberated Malaya will have the mechanisms needed to ensure that children like Yuki will be cared for despite her absent parents.
Her expectations could not be farther from the truth, however, as the Japanese turn out to be just as bad as Malaya’s previous colonial masters. During the novel’s inciting incident, in which Cecily’s son Abel is kidnapped by the Japanese military, Cecily is shocked into silence, recognizing the way her misfortune feels like a kind of retribution. She acknowledges that the four years of Japanese military rule have brought nothing but fear and despair to her own people. She also criticizes Fujiwara for leaving his wife and child behind, abandoning them for the sake of legacy. The deaths of Jasmin and Yuki are the final consequence of her actions, destroying part of the generation she hoped her actions would protect. In this way, Chan shows that despite Cecily’s best intentions, she had subscribed to an empty promise, effectively replacing one colonizer with another.
In a time when women were largely expected to fulfill domestic roles, bearing children and looking after the household while men shaped society as workers and leaders, Cecily Alcantara yearns to make an impact on Malaya, subverting the limitations of the prevailing social structure to free her state from British control. In some senses, she transcends her gender-defined roles through a sense of purpose and solidarity with those who share her political views, namely Takahashi and later, Lina.
Cecily bristles at her role as a housewife, developing violent fantasies that upend the normalized domesticity of her home. Her anger, however, is not aimed at her family members per se, but at the expectation that despite her colonial education, her only purpose in life is to manage her household and support her husband Gordon’s professional growth. All around her, there is little respite from these tasks. At dinner parties, she is forced to join the women while the men break out into groups to discuss administrative business. Her husband likewise tells her whom she should befriend and whom she should avoid to position him favorably in his superiors’ eyes. It is difficult for Cecily to think that any alternative exists until she meets Fujiwara. On one hand, her partnership with Fujiwara steadily develops until she can stand on equal footing with him. But this relationship simply fosters a new colonial regime. Chan thus suggests that having the same aspirations as one’s male counterparts is not enough to affect a more progressive society. Instead, the relationship that is more relevant to this theme is the one she develops with Lina.
Cecily initially sees Lina, when she goes by Mrs. Yap, as a nuisance, indistinguishable from the British society women who perpetuate the norms that Cecily resists. But as Lina insists on a friendship with Cecily, it becomes clear that her social standing is much more nuanced than Cecily expected. She must entertain the rude and racist dialogues of the society women in order to advance her and her husband’s social position. Cecily becomes sympathetic to her because she realizes that both of them have been victimized by British Malaya in their own ways, Lina more so because of the way Cecily’s actions indirectly caused the British to arrest and execute Lina’s first husband, Kapitan Yap. Cecily’s double life as an informant and as a domestic housewife plays into her relationship with Lina. Cecily feels for Lina when she realizes that Fujiwara must abandon her and their new child. The only consolation she can extend toward Lina is in reassuring her that it is not her fault that Fujiwara has become distant. Even if she and Lina view the sociopolitical atmosphere of Bintang differently, Cecily cherishes Lina’s companionship. On the other hand, she also decides that the Japanese campaign in Malaya is much more important than her friend’s feelings. The most serious sin that Cecily commits is the decision to abandon Lina’s daughter after Lina has died. Their relationship does not obligate her to care for Yuki, and she chooses her own family’s welfare.
The friendship between Jasmin and Yuki can thus be seen as an intergenerational resolution of Cecily’s flaws. Their decision to protect one another and call each other sisters fills Jasmin with the love she had lost for her family. This declaration is especially important given that Yuki has been exploited by the men who come to the comfort station. Yuki has suffered greatly under colonial rule, having been abandoned by nearly all, including her fellow Malayans. Jasmin sees through Yuki’s scars and cherishes the person that nobody else sees. This resonates with Jujube’s sympathy for Takahashi’s daughter, Ichika, which occurs only when Jujube imagines the rich inner life that this other girl must have. The novel thus concludes that more than ensuring that men and women can stand together on equal terms, women must also make the effort to stand in solidarity with those who are victimized by their societies.
Chan’s novel deals with several deeply traumatic events. These events reflect the wider trauma experienced by the countries occupied by the Japanese in the Pacific theater of the war, including territories in Korea, Vietnam, the Philippines, and China. Because much of the current historical fiction that exists around the Second World War recounts the lives of those who lived and fought on the Western fronts in Europe, few speak to the ways that Asians coped with the many atrocities committed by the Japanese across the continent. It is in this way that Chan’s novel tries to fill the gap by showing how the act of memory can be a salve toward the pain of historical trauma.
The importance of memory enters the narrative when Abel discovers that Freddie is drawing sketches of his experiences at the labor camp. Freddie tells him that the sketches are intended to help people understand what happened to them. It is a symbolic choice on Chan’s part that Freddie uses his own blood to draw his sketches. Though the act of remembering his suffering at the labor camp requires him to do something painful, it also sustains him by committing those memories into something apart from himself. Abel’s instinct is to share his own experiences with Freddie, eventually asking him to draw a sketch of Jasmin so that he can remember her.
Jasmin, for her part, is also trying to hold on to her memories of Abel to cope with his disappearance. When Cecily starts disguising Jasmin as a boy, she forces her daughter to wear Abel’s clothes. Jasmin finds relief in this disguise because she can remember the way her brother smelled, overcoming her fear of forgetting him completely. The more she wears his clothes, however, the more that scent fades away, replacing it with her own. Once this happens, Jasmin’s fears of forgetting her brother resume. Similarly, Abel is distraught when he returns home and reviews the sketch of Jasmin, which was based on his descriptions. Abel finds that he can no longer remember what his sister looked like, which is made more tragic by her death.
Memory also enables the victims of history to confront their aggressors and try to resolve their trauma. Yuki functions as the living embodiment of Lina’s memory. When the novel reveals that she is Lina and Fujiwara’s daughter, Cecily and Fujiwara must confront the consequences of their actions. Having been abandoned and abused by multiple men, Yuki is the biggest reminder of the sins that Cecily and Fujiwara have caused against their own people. Though Yuki cannot remember her origins, her friendship with Jasmin hints at the possibility that past transgressions can be overcome through acts of love. Takahashi similarly holds on to the memory of his daughter, Ichika, as a reason to live on in the world. He does not intend to offend Jujube by telling her about Ichika’s survival. He simply means to remind himself that while his daughter is still alive, there is hope for the future.