logo

60 pages 2 hours read

Marie Benedict

The Only Woman in the Room

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2019

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Symbols & Motifs

Subtle Politics

As a piece of historical fiction, the historical elements of the text are frequently present and incredibly significant. To parallel the workings of real political movements, the machinations of WW2 are initially nuanced in the text; so much so, that Hedy does not realize that she is living under a dictatorship until her father breaks down the workings of power in Western Europe. Hedy’s naivete on this matter is not used against her but instead intentionally designed to demonstrate the ways the path towards war and authoritarian regimes often occur without the general public realizing it at first; these deals are made well beyond the vision of the public eye, and the changes that take hold are gradual and subtle at first. By the time Hedy and the country understand the true impact of Hitler and Mussolini’s rise to power, it is too late to prevent it.

This motif serves two purposes. The first being the prescriptions of the genre; imbuing the text with the events of WW2 is essential to the narrative and upholds the expectations of the historical fiction genre. The second being that wartime politics work to accelerate the thematic elements of the text; crises habitually heighten existing social tensions, thus emphasizing the existent antisemitism and gender inequality that obstructs Hedy’s goals. Wars perpetuate patriarchal gender norms by creating an environment in which traditional masculinity—and its entanglements with violence—are prized, while traditional femininity—and its entanglements with docility—is only valued in its ability to support its counterpart.

Therefore, the obstacles Hedy faces on the basis of her sex are greater because of the war; her attempts to cross gender conventions by directly contributing to the war effort are rejected because her efforts aren’t perceived as valuable as the men’s efforts. When the council says, “stick to your films,” they really mean, “leave the work to the men” (236). This motif increases the sense of urgency for action, making Hedy’s rejection more tragic—and even ridiculous. As the narrative emphasizes the death and destruction borne of the war, it reveals that the systems in place that keep women from meaningfully contributing to the war effort only prolong suffering.

The Cartier Jewels

The Cartier jewels are a symbol in which meaning transforms as Hedy’s story progresses. After wedding dress shopping in Paris, Hedy passes a window in which a set of earrings, necklace, and bracelet glitter against the sun. They are made of diamonds, rubies, sapphires, and emeralds, and cost more than most family fortunes. As Hedy eyes the jewels, Fritz whispers that they are not “nearly as beautiful as [her]” (52). Later that night, after Hedy has agreed to convert to Christianity, Fritz delivers the jewels to her room.

After this exchange, the jewels represent the cost of Hedy’s sacrifices; giving up her career, her heritage, and her freedom is giving an exact price, and even then Hedy suspects it won’t be worth it. To Fritz, the jewels represent Hedy as Mrs. Mandl; they are exquisite, elegant, and expensive. Most importantly, he owns them as he expects to own Hedy. However, Hedy reclaims the gift’s significance by using them to buy her escape. She chooses the jewels to wear on the night of her escape with practicality—they are the most expensive jewels she owns, and she can live off of them for a while. Symbolically, though, they are the last things Fritz bought for her while she was still Hedy Kiesler. By taking them, she rejects her role as Mrs. Mandl, using the jewels as her ransom against Fritz. 

Empress Elizabeth of Bavaria

The symbol of Empress Elizabeth is introduced in the very first line and carried throughout most of the narrative. As Hedy opens her eyes to the audience on the opening night of Sissy, the role demonstrates Hedy’s acting prowess. Hedy becomes the empress, channeling her “steeliness” and looking “out at [her] subjects” (3). The role relates Hedy’s power on stage to that of a ruler. It’s a power she is aware of and relishes in, enjoying keeping everyone in her “thrall” (16). However, the symbol also relates to Hedy in the negative aspects of Elizabeth’s life; in the last years of the empress’s life, “the golden tether of the emperor’s displeasure became a yoke around her neck” (7). In her marriage to Fritz, Hedy’s life parallels the tragic end of Elizabeth; both powerful and independent women become smaller beneath the thumbs of their oppressive husbands. Both women seek “liberty and purpose” (73) but are caged within their castles. The novel abandons the symbol as soon as Hedy escapes Fritz, positing that she has escaped the empress’s fate of a lifelong imprisonment. However, the comparison between the two women stands; even in America, Hedy struggles to achieve the purpose she desires. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text