logo

65 pages 2 hours read

Mark Sullivan

The Last Green Valley

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 18-22Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3: “Thrown to the Wind and the Wolves”

Part 3, Chapter 18 Summary

The Martel and Losing families spend most of June 1944 in the refugee camp. Walt and Will are enrolled in school while the adults, except Lydia and Karoline, receive work assignments. Adeline works in the kitchen, where she hears that Rome fell to the Allies. Emil is excited by the news, telling Adeline that the Allies are their chance to head west. Adeline expresses hesitation about the dangers of the plan.

In late June, the refugees are told that quarantine is over. The Martel and Losing families are given ration cards and keys to their new housing in Wielun. Before they leave the camp, Major Haussmann pulls Emil aside and takes him into a field. Major Haussmann draws his gun, claiming that Emil is the first “true coward” he ever faced. He claims that he should have shot Emil the night they met in Dubossary.

Major Haussmann shoots at Emil twice, intentionally missing both times. Before Emil rejoins his family, Major Haussmann warns Emil that his family will continue to be punished for Emil’s “cowardice.”

Part 3, Chapter 19 Summary

The Martels and Losings arrive in Wielun, the first Polish town Hitler attacked in 1939. Adeline notices the empty farmlands surrounding the town and grows concerned about their food supply. Soon they arrive at their new home, a “gray, dilapidated, three-story, wood-framed building” (192). Emil’s parents and Marie and her twins take apartments on the second floor; Emil’s family and Lydia and Malia take apartments on the third floor. Emil believes their housing represents a portion of Major Haussmann’s promised punishment.

The first night in Wielun, Adeline makes the family give thanks to God for escaping the Soviets as well as for their food and shelter. Emil does not share her sentiments. When Emil requests new living quarters, he is denied and told he is being ungrateful that his family was saved from the Judeo-Bolsheviks.

Adeline is put to work in the town bakery while Emil does farm work. Emil vows to work diligently and remain unnoticed. In August 1944, the farm overseer, a Wehrmacht sergeant named Claude Wahl, invites Emil to his house for a drink. When Wahl questions Emil about his plans, Emil admits that he intends to head west, ideally across the ocean. Wahl advises Emil not to tell anyone.

Several days later, Wahl invites Emil back to his house. Wahl shows Emil to a locked room where he pulls out a shortwave radio. Emil is nervous; he never owned a radio because they were forbidden by both Stalin and the Nazis.

Part 3, Chapter 20 Summary

Wahl tunes the radio to the BBC German Service. They hear about Romania’s surrender to the Soviets and the Allies’ advances against the German armies. Wahl admits that Germany is losing the war; he tells Emil that they must be prepared for Berlin to fall.

Emil rushes home to tell Adeline, but she expresses doubt about his news. Emil insists that they must be ready to go to the Allies, and Adeline finally agrees. Adeline then tells Emil that she found a Jewish Bible under the floorboards in their kitchen. When Adeline asked a German-speaking Polish woman about it, the woman explained that their apartment and their clothes belonged to Jewish people who were murdered by the Nazis.

Rese reunites with the family in Wielun at the end of September 1944; to Adeline, she appears “glassy-eyed and much older” since her stay in the military hospital (208). Adeline tries to help Marie with the twins and tries to get Rese out of the house. Rese experiences frequent mood swings. Adeline also worries about their food rations, which dwindle each week.

Emil goes to Wahl’s house multiple times to listen to the shortwave radio. On October 21, 1944, he hears that Aachen has become the first German city to fall to the Allies. Emil tells Adeline to prepare to leave, but the German forces resist the Allies. At the end of November, Rese falls ill. Marie figures out that Rese is addicted to painkillers. In December, Emil becomes sick.

Part 3, Chapter 21 Summary

A sick Emil dreams about meeting Major Haussmann in 1941. Emil traveled to Dubossary to buy roofing supplies for their house in Friedenstal. As he left Dubossary, he was stopped at a German checkpoint and questioned about whether he was in the Selbstschutz. When he said no, the German soldier detained him.

Emil was told to join a group of civilian men waiting nearby. Major Haussmann introduced himself and explained that the men would demonstrate their loyalty to Germany and Hitler. They were led into open country, where Emil heard shooting and screams. He considered running away but knew he would be killed. Major Haussmann drove the men to an area where Jewish people were being shot by Nazi soldiers.

Another soldier, Captain Drexel, informed Major Haussmann that they killed 187 Jewish people that night. Many of the men started vomiting, except for a man named Helmut, who expressed excitement at getting to shoot Jewish people. Although Helmut volunteered to shoot first, Major Haussmann handed his gun to Emil. He instructed Emil to shoot a young man and two little girls, and Emil froze.

Part 3, Chapter 22 Summary

After days of being sick, Emil wakes up. Adeline does not tell Emil that their rations have been cut and they are almost out of food. On Christmas Eve 1944, the Martel and Losing families have a small celebration and are joined by Wahl, who is shocked by their living conditions. Wahl tells them that he is going to Lodz for a few weeks but will return earlier if needed.

On New Year’s Eve, an arctic blast hits Europe; soon multiple members of the Martel and Losing families are sick. A few days later, Adeline gets a ride to Lodz, where she intends to sell her family’s wedding rings for food. She stops at multiple black market food shops, but nobody will accept the rings as payment. Adeline wanders in the street and prays to God to help her family.

A few moments later, Adeline runs into a woman whom she recognizes as Esther, who is still going by the name Ilse. Adeline claims that God sent Esther to her. The two walk to Esther’s apartment, where she explains that she is still using forged papers to fake a German identity. Adeline asks if she can sell Esther the rings; instead, Esther hands her a wad of money, saying it is a “debt [she is] glad to repay” (226). Adeline leaves Esther’s apartment to return to the black market. As she walks away, she notices a German officer knock on Esther’s door. Adeline purchases a large amount of food for her family and spends the night at Esther’s apartment.

Part 3, Chapters 18-22 Analysis

The first portion of Part 3 explores the struggle between the desire for a better life and the immediate need for safety and security. While the Martels are quarantined at the Immigration Control Center camp, Adeline overhears that Rome fell to the Allies. While Emil initially insists that the Allies are their ticket west, Adeline’s primary concern is their family’s safety: “I have two young boys, a mother, and a sister to think about, not to mention your parents and my cousin and the twins. And Rese” (187). Emil expresses similar sentiments to Claude Wahl once the family has been relocated to Wielun; when Wahl asks about Emil’s long-term plans, Emil insists that his primary focus must be the immediate survival of his family.

This need to survive demonstrates how The Cruelty of War can directly lead to Moral Ambiguity and Compromise. After several weeks of living in Wielun, Adeline learns that the apartments given to the Volksdeutsche refugees once belonged to Jewish people. Even more disturbing, Adeline learns that the clothes they were given were taken from Jewish people before they were murdered. Emil is distressed by the news. The narrator says, “His head […] now swirled with guilt and regret and hatred. He never asked to wear a dead man’s clothes” (207). Adeline questions how they can live with themselves. Although she tries to focus on work and taking care of her family, she is haunted, the narrator says, by “the ghosts in her clothes and the apartment” (210). Adeline and Emil’s situation raises questions about individual responsibility for the violence perpetrated by the Nazis, demonstrating how innocent people can easily be made complicit in such violence. While Adeline is horrified by the series of events that provided their apartment and clothes, she is equally concerned about providing for her family.

The Martels are not the only characters to experience moral uncertainty. Key secondary characters also demonstrate the variety of morally ambiguous situations during war. For instance, a chance encounter between Adeline and Esther reveals that Esther is living in Lodz, using her forged papers to conceal her Jewish identity.

Esther feels a mix of guilt and defiance. She suffers silently as she witnesses the Jewish population of Lodz murdered; whenever she passes the ghetto, she “[hears] the Jews speaking Yiddish, and [wants] to go to them” (226). Her guilt is compounded by knowing that she also is living in a house and wearing clothes that belonged to a Jewish person. Yet Esther still expresses a sense of pride in her ability to survive: “I kept wondering why I had been saved […] But then I saw it differently, defiantly, you know? I had fooled them, the Nazis” (226).

The first half of Part 3 also provides key details regarding the conflict between Emil and Major Haussmann. Emil recalls his encounter with Major Haussmann in Dubossary in 1941. He came face-to-face with the horrors perpetrated by the Nazi regime as he witnessed soldiers murdering hundreds of Jewish people. He recalls the victims “[jerking] with bullet impacts before crumpling and falling backward into the ravine like so many dolls blown over” (217).

Emil recalls how Major Haussmann instructed him and the other men to shoot Jewish people to demonstrate their loyalty to Hitler and the Nazis. While much of the Martels’ experience reflects complicity by association, Emil’s encounter with Major Haussmann is a moment when a character must choose whether to perpetrate violence. Emil initially refused, but the reader is left with the sense that there is more to the encounter.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By Mark Sullivan