44 pages • 1 hour read
Lisa SeeA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
The female divers of Jeju Island represent a cultural anomaly. They are assertive, strong women who follow shamanic goddess-centered religious practices, yet they live in a culture dominated by men. Korea is traditionally patriarchal, but the haenyeo have found a way to maintain their independence from male rule. In their communities, the men do the cooking and raise the children. Jeju’s geographic isolation as an island is part of the reason that they are so successful in resisting outside influences.
At the same time that the haenyeo maintain their lifestyle, they have also made a strange sort of accommodation to the patriarchal norms of the country as a whole. For example, only men are allowed to conduct ancestor worship rituals. This is the sole reason that any haenyeo would rejoice at the birth of a son, since daughters are far more valuable as future sources of family income.
Although the haenyeo have managed to create a matrifocal, and to some extent, matriarchal social order on Jeju Island, outside forces begin to exert a pressure that may render the female divers and their way of life extinct. While the haenyeo continue to support shamanistic religion, they must do so in secret. The combined influences of Confucianism and Christianity throughout Korea make it dangerous to worship goddesses. After the end of World War II, the government intrudes into the practices of the diving collectives. It creates Village Fishery Associations that tell the women where they can dive and for how long. Worse still, the head of this association is always a male.
As tourism becomes a bigger source of income for the island, many young women are lured away to start businesses supporting the tourist trade. In addition, better educational opportunities on the mainland draw other prospective haenyeo into lucrative professions. See uses Young-sook and Joon-lee to illustrate these changing conditions. Rather than follow in her mother’s footsteps as a diver, Joon-lee chooses to leave Jeju and follow an academic path by attending university in Seoul. The reader sees how diving practices change from the time Young-sook is a baby diver until she becomes the head of a collective. An interviewer asks Young-sook, “The government labels the haenyeo a cultural heritage treasure—something dying out that must be preserved, if only in memory. How does it feel to be the last of the last?” (4). She never answers the question.
Young-sook is devastated by what she perceives to be Mi-ja’s betrayal on the day of the Bukchon Massacre. She is traumatized by the slaughter of her family, but her rage at Mi-ja is even more debilitating. She begins to reinterpret Mi-ja’s actions through the filter of her anger. Young-sook becomes convinced that all of Mi-ja’s gestures of friendship over the years were self-serving.
Unfortunately, the more Young-sook tries to repudiate Mi-ja, the more her anger binds her to her friend. As the village shaman tells her, “They did this to me. They did that to me. A woman who thinks that way will never overcome her anger. You are not being punished for your anger. You’re being punished by your anger” (350).
Young-sook is aware of the irony. Even after Mi-ja leaves Hado, she is drawn to her friend’s house and, in the years that follow, continues to clean it and even pays the taxes on the abandoned property. Long after she ceases to perform these duties, Young-sook keeps tabs on the place and knows when it is scheduled for demolition. She says, “I missed having her to blame. When that missing grew too strong, I walked to her house, where I touched her things and sensed her all around me. The house became the scab I could not stop picking” (308).
The more Young-sook tries to dissociate herself from Mi-ja, the stronger their bond becomes. Her daughter marries Mi-ja’s son, which is an event that both hoped would happen someday. When it finally does, Young-sook refuses to attend the wedding or visit the couple before they move to America. By the end of the novel, Young-sook realizes her mistake, but her anger costs her decades of misery until she finally realizes that the person she hurt most was herself.
At one point, Clara quotes the Buddhist aphorism, “To understand all is to forgive all.” For decades, Mi-ja attempts to explain her actions to Young-sook, but the latter refuses to hear her. Perhaps subconsciously, Young-sook fears that if she understood Mi-ja’s reasons for what she did, then she might want to forgive her friend. Young-sook is not ready to take that step.
Young-sook’s grudge against Mi-ja is also symbolic of the collective grudge felt by all Koreans after the partition of their country. Atrocities were committed on all sides—not by foreigners, but by Koreans against their own countryfolk. These hard feelings began even before the war, when the people of Jeju express their hate for the Japanese colonizers. Mi-ja is identified as the enemy from the very start because her father was a collaborator. As a child, she is made to suffer for the sins of her family. Young-sook’s grandmother takes a grim delight in arranging a marriage between the hated child of a collaborator with the family of another collaborator.
The novel carefully draws a parallel between the broken friendship and the broken country by resolving both conflicts on the day when the April 3 Peace Park memorial is opened. Young-sook listens to speeches from government officials calling for a healing of old wounds. They point out that everyone was a victim after the partition, and everyone has reason to remain angry at everyone else, but that conflict needs to cease. However, Young-sook is too cynical to accept the message because of her own personal grudge against Mi-ja.
By Lisa See