52 pages • 1 hour read
Anita Rau BadamiA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
It is the middle of July. At 5:00 am in Torturpuram, India, Sripathi Rao receives a phone call while out on the balcony of Big House. He is busy and doesn’t answer, nor does anyone else in the house. He yells for his son, Arun, to get the phone and curses the boy’s indolence. It might be their daughter, Maya, calling, though it would be unusual for her to call on water day. Sripathi goes back to writing a letter to the editor of The Hindu, something he enjoys doing, though secretively. He always signs his letters with a pseudonym, Pro Bono Publico. From his perch on the balcony, he can look down at Brahmin street and the neighborhood. His family is Brahmin, but not everyone else living on the street is. That stopped being so a long time ago.
Sripathi‘s wife, Nirmala, brings him coffee. They speak with one another, but the tone is not loving. Sripathi is very sarcastic. They argue a bit about answering the phone and duties needing done for water collection. The phone rings again and Sripathi goes to answer it. Nirmala goes off to tend to more of her morning chores. When Sripathi answers the phone and no one responds, he goes back to the balcony. Sripathi thinks back on the day he met Nirmala and how their life has devolved into one without laughter. He places his letter to the editor in his briefcase and remembers how he used to carry two letters with him to work, one for the editor, and the other for his daughter Maya. He shakes the memory away, however. “Had he not banished his daughter from their lives?” (16).
The scene moves to Canada. Nandana wonders why her parents haven‘t come to pick her up yet. She had asked Uncle Sunny how much longer, and he had said just one more day, but it’s been a day and a half now. She has her pink-and-purple backpack, the one she got from her father for her seventh birthday, and looks out the window hoping to see her parents pull up soon. She is worried. She tried calling home earlier but only got the answering machine.
Downstairs in Big House, the maid, Koti, is washing dishes. Putti, Sripathi’s younger sister by 16 years, is listening to her over the din of the splashing water. She is 42 and still unmarried. Her mother has disapproved of every suitor who has ever sought her out. Putti is always up early to get the milk brought to them by their neighbor, Gopala Munnuswamy. Gopala’s father began a milking business years ago, saved and invested his money wisely, and now runs several businesses around town, even some illegitimate ones. Ammayya (Putti and Sripathi’s mother), hates the Munnuswamys because they are of a lower caste. Putti has to take care of her aging mother, which consumes the majority of her time. Ammayya is old and crotchety, and a bit of a hypochondriac.
Sripathi continues to observe the neighbors from the balcony, especially the more eccentric ones like Mrs. Poorna, who is insane and awaits the return of her daughter who disappeared years ago, or the feisty Burmese wife. Sripathi puts away his writing utensils. He hates water day. The town has a shortage of drinking water, so “the municipal corporation regulate[s] the supply by releasing limited quantities on alternate days” (25). This means that the family stocks water in several cisterns around the house. Sripathi goes to get Arun up to help with the gathering of the water. Sripathi is frustrated and annoyed by Arun, whom he sees as wasting his life and not living up to his duties. Arun has been working on a doctorate in social work for five years and is involved with several activist organizations. Arun doesn’t earn any money, though, which makes life hard on the family because Sripathi’s job doesn’t pay enough anymore. Arun is 28 years old. The phone rings again and Sripathi leaves to answer it.
Nandana wonders why her parents have left her for three days with Aunty Kiran. She attempts to walk home. Aunty Kiran catches up to her. She tells Nandana how afraid she was when she saw that she was missing. Kiran holds Nandana close and says she needs to tell her something.
Sripathi picks up the phone and speaks with a Dr. Sunderraj from Vancouver. He is a family friend, and Maya had asked that he contact Sripathi in case of an emergency. He regrettably informs Sripathi that his daughter and her husband, Alan Baker, have died in a car accident. Because Sripathi is the legal guardian of their daughter, he will need to fly to Vancouver to get her. Dr. Sunderraj expresses his deepest condolences. Sripathi is in shock and hangs up suddenly, unable to bear anymore. He hears the family downstairs preparing to receive the water, but he cannot react, cannot help. Nirmala is looking for him. She finds him sitting on the floor in front of the phone. He weakly gives her the news about their daughter. Nirmala wails and beats her fists against him. She curses him for having driven Maya away. Sripathi tells her to behave herself. “I am tired of behaving myself” (35), she yells and hits him again. Sripathi slaps her across the face, something he has never done. The slap shocks Nirmala nearly as much as the news about Maya. The rest of the family saw him do it, drawn as they were to Nirmala’s weeping and wailing. Arun asks what is going on. Sripathi remembers Maya as a child before answering. A part of him wants to yell at his son, but he holds back from saying something unforgivable like, “Why your sister and not you?” (38). Sripathi wants to blame Alan for Maya’s death. He wants to sue Alan’s family. Nirmala rebukes him, which makes him lash out at her. The family leaves Sripathi alone on the landing with the phone as guilt grows within him.
Dr. Sunderraj and Kiran give Nandana the news about her parents. Lots of people come over to the house, even two people from Social Services. Nandana doesn’t really react to the news, and Kiran wonders if she understands what has happened. Nandana remembers seeing a dead butterfly once and how her mom had taught her that all living things die. But her mom had also said that she wouldn’t die herself until she was 100 years old, so she can’t possibly be dead like the butterfly. Kiran tells Nandana that her grandfather will be coming to take her back with him to India. Nandana doesn’t say anything.
The first dead person Sripathi ever saw was his grandmother, Shantamma, who was 82. She once told him the story of Savitri who had made a deal with Lord Yama, the Lord of Death, for the life of her husband. Sripathi was devastated when she died. She used to protect him from the burden of expectance placed upon him by his parents, Ammayya and Narasimha. They had had such high hopes for him. His father used to train him by making him memorize passages from the Encyclopedia Britannica and when Sripathi failed, he flew into a rage and called him an idiot. Narasimha would even take Sripathi violently by the ear and lead him to where the beggars dwelled. Narasimha would show Sripathi what his future would be like if he didn’t work hard and get smarter.
Nirmala comes upstairs and asks Sripathi what they are going to do. Sripathi argues with her some more. Sripathi eventually tells her that he will be bringing Nandana to India, which excites Nirmala. Sripathi is worried about the costs. Nirmala scolds him for worrying about money when he should be concentrating on Maya, and now, Nandana.
Sripathi remembers his Brahmin initiation ceremony and the advice he received from Varadarajan Judge-sahib:
Now that you have received your sacred thread, now that you have entered the world of knowledge, you will appreciate this gift of time. A valuable gift that goes as soon as it arrives. So learn to use it wisely, and you will be content (58).
Another aspect of his initiation ceremony also remains etched into his memory. His father’s mistress showed up and presented Sripathi with a gift. His mother was furious by the woman’s presence, destroyed the gift, and threatened the woman. His father then stood up and led his mistress out. Ammayya was angry, hurt, and dishonored. Sripathi vowed never to lax in his duties or bring shame to his family. Sripathi felt disgusted by the fact that his mother was pregnant when he was 16. His father died that year, leaving the family penniless. His father’s wealth was in borrowed money. He and Ammayya struggled, but they made it through.
Ammayya placed a lot of hope in Sripathi becoming a doctor. Sripathi made it to medical school, but hated it and left. He lied about why he left for a long time, but the truth came out eventually. Ammayya never forgave him for his betrayal of her hopes. Sripathi eventually got a job with an advertising agency, the job he still holds. When he was 24, he married Nirmala. He also applied and was offered a job as a news reporter in Delhi, but Ammayya did not want to move north, so he didn’t take the job. He never tried changing professions again after that.
Nandana does not look forward to her grandfather coming. She calls him the Old Man. Her mother had shown her pictures of Big House in India. Her mother used to speak to her sometimes in Kannada, which Maya’s mother spoke when she wasn’t speaking English. Nandana remembers wearing a sari to school once when her school held International Day. She had been reluctant to wear the sari, but it was a hit with all her friends and fellow students. Nandana does not like the Old Man because “He made her mother cry” (71).
Each chapter title corresponds symbolically to subsequent events. The title for Chapter 1 is “By the Sea,” and Chapter 1 establishes the sea as a central symbol of the narrative. Furthermore, the fictional city of Torturpuram, India, which is the main setting, is a coastal city. The sea is a major symbol throughout the novel and will reappear in different ways. Even though Torturpuram is fictional, it is near the real city of Madras; and as the author herself admits, Torturpuram is heavily based on that city (the Reader’s Guide at the back of the novel). Additionally, “Morning in Big House,” i.e. Chapter 2, establishes Big House as a further representation of the Rao family. Chapter 3, “The Storm,” uses storm imagery in several ways. Most significantly, the storm symbolizes Maya’s death and its subsequent consequences on the other characters. Chapter 4’s title, “Histories,” gives a brief backstory on Ammayya and her late husband, Narasimha Rao, all told from Sripathi’s point-of-view. This insight into their past will provide a cause-and-effect analysis not only of Ammayya’s behavior, but also Sripathi’s, Putti’s, and even Nirmala’s.
One of the most important aspects of Sripathi’s personality, including his paradoxical nature, takes place with his enjoyment in criticizing the world around him through “letters to the editor.” Sripathi first discovered the cathartic nature of writing letters when he was young. He used the letters to vent his frustrations and emotions which he otherwise kept to himself and refused to express otherwise. Sripathi feels on obvious sense of pride in seeing his words printed in the newspapers (8), yet he prefers to remain anonymous, signing his letters Pro Bono Publico, which in simplified Latin means “for the good of the public.” Sripathi views his letter writing as something heroic, akin to the stories of the Scarlet Pimpernel, Zorro, and Jhanda Singh the Invisible, but he fights with the pen rather than the sword. These references to comic-book heroes underscore the novel’s title, and the first notion of heroism comes up here, though it’s not at all answered. The theme of what it means to be a hero reveals itself slowly as the story progresses and will unfold in stages.
The fact that Sripathi remains anonymous, however, is not due to a desire for humility. Rather, Sripathi remains anonymous out of a sense of shame. He does not want his friends and family to know what he is writing, because he feels that such activities are also a waste of time since it does not earn any money. This idea that actions are only worthwhile if they earn money is one of the core elements of his personality and the main cause of the rift between him and his son, Arun. Furthermore, writing the letters sparks increased feelings of guilt for having failed in becoming a doctor, and his disappointment and frustration with his job. He feels guilty for having quit medical school, and has since been stuck in a dead-end, unfulfilling job working in advertising, writing hackneyed jingles. The fact that Nirmala is aware of Sripathi’s letters is evidence that he fears judgement, at least from his wife, and one can assume also from Arun.
Another important element in the first section involves narration. The narration is from the third-person omniscient perspective. Furthermore, this section introduces two parallel narratives. Sripathi narrates the main narrative mostly, which involves the Rao family, though this perspective also shifts to Nirmala, Putti, and even Ammayaa. The second narrative is from Nandana’s perspective and always appears at the end of a chapter, after the main narrative. The two narratives remain detached until Sripathi arrives in Vancouver and takes Nandana back to India, where the two narratives eventually merge.
Many of the interfamilial conflicts that arise and play a central role in the novel crop up in these first chapters; namely, the strained relationship between Sripathi and Nirmala, Sripathi and Arun, and the fact that Sripathi and Maya’s relationship suffered so greatly that Sripathi refused to speak to or see her anymore. The reason doesn’t come up in these first few chapters, but Maya, in Sripathi’s eyes, dishonors the family by breaking off her engagement to Prakesh and marrying a foreigner, Alan Baker. The idea of familial honor as a cornerstone of Sripathi’s belief system arises in Chapter 1 and reinforced in subsequent chapters, especially in Chapter 4, when Sripathi completely turns against his father for having a mistress and humiliating his mother, Ammayya. What is most important is to realize that even though Sripathi has not spoken to his daughter for nine years, he is, nevertheless, devastated by her death. He begins remembering times before his feud with her, revealing a complex psychology based on his sense of duty and honor and love for his daughter, which for him become mutually exclusive elements when Maya breaks with tradition. This seeming paradox of disappointment/anger and love becomes Sripathi’s central conflict that has driven and controlled most of his actions throughout his life, as will come up in subsequent chapters. Maya’s death illustrates the chaos, mistrust, and antagonism inherent in multiple generations of the Rao family, and her death becomes the catalyst for much-needed change.
The anger and animosity with which Ammayya confronts the members of her family took root in her first betrayal at the hands of her husband, who not only betrayed her physically by having a mistress, but who also betrayed her traditionally by not being a good provider for the family and leaving them as paupers after his death. Sripathi further reinforced this sense of victimhood and betrayal when he quit medical school. Much of Sripathi’s childhood involved training him to become educated enough to achieve a well-paid profession later on. This, of course, in traditional Indian society and culture became even more important to Ammayya after Narasimha’s death, because as a woman Ammayya couldn’t and shouldn’t earn money. The feeling that she cannot rely on anyone drives both her behavior towards her daughter, Putti, whom she will not allow to marry because it would mean Putti would no longer be around to take care of her, and her animosity towards life and family, which she sees as nothing but disappointments. Sripathi, in the role of a disappointment, has already come up, but she also dislikes Nirmala because she came from a poor family as well, meaning she did not bring a dowry that would alleviate her penurious situation.
In Chapter 2, on page 35, Nirmala says something to Sripathi that illustrates the core of her personality, and something that will influence her later behavior in the novel. She says, “I am tired of behaving myself.” Nirmala is a good Hindu wife. She does what others expect of her, including going along with her husband’s wishes. This is the major reason why she did not take it upon herself to end the feud between her daughter and her husband, something she increasingly regrets. From this point on, Nirmala begins to defy Sripathi and Ammayya and do things the way she feels they need to happen, which will be discussed as the events emerge in the subsequent chapters. Suffice it to say, that at the beginning of the book, the Nirmala character is a stereotype, but this open statement of rebellion is a turning point in her life and makes her a dynamic character capable of change rather than being simply Sripathi’s wife.
Syntax appears as an important literary device throughout the narrative. This is the author’s expression of the English spoken in southern India that takes influence by others of the indigenous tongues. Some characters speak Kannada, which is a type of Dravidian language spoken in southern India. It is the native language of the area, along with Tamil, which is also Dravidian. The most notable difference in syntax is the occasional placement of a subordinate clause before the main clause. For example, “In another world you are living, or what?” (20). This usage mostly appears in the less educated characters like Koti, Putti, Ammayya, and Nirmala. Nandana does not display such usage, nor does Sripathi, who holds a university degree. Characters will also use non-standard onomatopoeia, such as “ghash-phash” for the sound blood makes being pumped through veins (22), or reduplication for emphasis or to project a slightly different meaning than the word alone. For example, in the following sentence, a word repeats to emphasize Sripathi using esoteric terms that his uneducated wife does not know the meaning thereof: “That’s all you are capable of—writing big-big words with different colored pens […]” (43). Reduplication is relatively common in the languages of India.