logo

56 pages 1 hour read

Sharon Creech

The Great Unexpected

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 2012

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 41-50Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 41 Summary: “News”

Mr. Dingle arrives at Nula’s house, and Naomi escapes out the back. When Naomi returns, Nula tells her Sybil has died, and they must go to Ireland for the funeral. Naomi is apprehensive because Ireland is supposed to be full of fairies, elves, ogres, and giants.

Chapter 42 Summary: “Lar-de-dar”

Before Nula can explain further, Lizzie arrives. She babbles about good news, not realizing Naomi hasn’t heard. Finally, Lizzie says she’s excited that they are all going to Ireland. Naomi is shocked to learn Lizzie is going too.

Chapter 43 Summary: “Across the Ocean: Ireland”

Nula, Naomi, and Lizzie arrive in Ireland and are met at the airport by a driver. After driving for three hours, Nula is sure he’s brought them to the wrong place. The girls see the iron rooks on the gate, and Naomi is amazed by the sign that says, “Rooks Orchard.” Nula expects a much humbler home, but the driver reassures her.

Chapter 44 Summary: “Pilpenny”

Nula feels the place is familiar, but she’s still sure there’s been a mistake. However, Miss Pilpenny rushes outside, introducing herself and correctly naming each of the three shocked people in the car. Before they left for Ireland, Naomi learned that Lizzie had also been summoned, but not by the same person who summoned Nula and Naomi. Lizzie was sent for by her aunt, her mother’s sister, Miss Pilpenny, who was Sybil’s companion. When the girls see the inside of the large house, they assume it is a hotel. Naomi lies down and doesn’t wake up until the next day.

Chapter 45 Summary: “The Bridge and the Orchard”

Lizzie confirms that Miss Pilpenny is her mother’s sister and Sybil was Nula’s sister, meaning that Naomi, alone, is not related by blood to any of them. Naomi says that this doesn’t matter. The women feel the tension rising and suggest a walk. Miss Pilpenny and Lizzie are already comfortable with each other, and Nula notes Naomi’s irritation. Naomi is happy for Lizzie, but she worries someone might come to take her away too. Nula is surprised, saying she’s always worried that someone would come for Naomi. Nula calls her a wonderful “unexpected surprise,” saying it took a long time for her and Joe to “accept that good fortune” (182).

Nula pulls a packet of Joe’s ashes from her pocket and reminds Naomi that, even though Nula and Joe weren’t related, they were a good match. Nula scatters some of the ashes on the flowers nearby and says that she, Joe, and Naomi were a good match, too. Miss Pilpenny tells the girls they can roam wherever they like except for the fairy ring in the orchard; they should avoid it. They find the Crooked Bridge, recalling that Finn described just such a one, and they see the rooks. They find the fairy ring made of mushrooms, and Lizzie recalls her mother talking about fairy rings and how “terrible fates” await anybody who disturbs one. When Lizzie suggests that a person responsible for such a violation might die, go blind, or simply disappear, Naomi nudges a mushroom. Despite Lizzie’s protests, Naomi dips a foot into the ring. Just then, they are called away, and Lizzie says it’ll be Naomi’s fault if something bad happens.

Chapter 46 Summary: “Across the Ocean: A Storm”

In Blackbird Tree, a storm rages. An electrical wire snaps, and everyone’s lights go out.

Chapter 47 Summary: “Real or Not Real?”

Lizzie asks if this is the only hotel nearby, and Miss Pilpenny informs her that this isn’t a hotel and that it belonged to Sybil. Nula is flabbergasted. Mr. Dingle arrives, and Lizzie is sure he brings bad news because Naomi disturbed the fairy ring. Lizzie asks Naomi if this is real or not, and Naomi asks her, “What is ‘real’?” (190). When they left the orchard, Naomi thought she saw Finn in the shadows, and she saw a rock carved with the initials “F.M.” and a broken heart. She didn’t tell Lizzie, though, because she thought maybe the boy and the rock weren’t real.

Chapter 48 Summary: “Across the Ocean: Wind and Fire”

The storm in Blackbird Tree lasts for three days. Lightning strikes Nula’s barn and house, and both burn to the ground.

Chapter 49 Summary: “From Donkeys’ Ears”

News of the storm reaches Naomi and Nula. Lizzie cries for them because they are now homeless. Naomi feels that bad things keep pouring out of the donkey’s ears.

Chapter 50 Summary: “Across the Ocean: The Witch Visits”

Witch Wiggins visits one-armed Farley, and she gives him the two iron rooks she salvaged from Nula’s barn. He puts them with the other two, and she is happy to reunite them. He pulls out a piece of folded blue paper and hands it to Hazel.

Chapters 41-50 Analysis

Unexpected bad news comes, one piece after another, and the tension these create, along with the tension generated by the shorter chapters, indicates the rapidly approaching climax. After Joe’s unanticipated death, Nula learns of her sister’s recent death, though she assumed Sybil was already dead. After this, she and Naomi learn their home has been destroyed in a freak accident. Bad things seem to keep happening out of the blue, reinforcing Naomi’s view that things that happen unexpectedly are always bad. In fact, the plural possessive “Donkeys’” in the title of Chapter 49, “From Donkeys’ Ears,” suggests that there are now multiple donkeys bringing bad news rather than just the one donkey that existed in Joe’s story. In addition, the chapters in this section become significantly shorter, except for Chapter 45, and the quick leaps back and forth between Ireland and America increase the pace of the narrative as well as the tension produced by the plot itself, as though the story is racing toward an as-yet-unknown conclusion: namely, what is Sybil’s revenge, and whom will it affect?

Nula’s claim, on the other hand, that getting Naomi was a “great, unexpected surprise” (182) for her and Joe initiates the opposite idea: that unexpected events can be wonderful, that Unexpected Good Fortune is possible. Nula says that they might have maintained too much distance between themselves and Naomi only because they had difficulty accepting that their “good fortune” was real and that no one was coming to take Naomi away from them. Therefore, though Naomi may have been responsible for the dog’s attack—its aggression and the infection that killed her father being elements of unexpected bad fortune—it led to her being raised by a loving couple with no children of their own and turned out to have been such a happy thing for Nula and Joe that they could scarcely trust it. Thus, unexpected bad fortune actually resulted in unexpected good fortune. It is, perhaps, such a realization that prompts Naomi to tempt fate again and disturb the fairy ring.

Moreover, the existence of and belief in such a thing as a fairy ring and Naomi’s uncertainty about what is “real” emphasize the Compatibility of Reality and Fantasy. The crooked bridge Finn spoke of is real, it turns out, as is Rooks Orchard. Naomi stepped into a fairy ring, which she thought was fantastic before so many people confirmed its reality, and she thinks of the donkey’s ears every time someone delivers—or even speaks of—bad news. So aware has Naomi become that there is such a small distinction between the real and the fantastic that she can’t be sure whether she really saw Finn or the broken heart rock in the orchard. She questions her senses and her knowledge of what can and cannot be because things that should not be somehow are.

In this section, Lizzie’s connection to Miss Pilpenny is fully revealed, highlighting yet again The Interconnected of Lives. In an unexpected twist, Lizzie can now boast a blood relative, while Naomi comes to understand that no blood relatives await her in Ireland. Even so, Nula teaches the young girl how interconnectedness in her life does not depend on a blood tie but rather on being well-matched to others, as she was to Nula and Joe. By exploring these elements of connectedness, Creech helps her readers understand the blessings of biological and non-biological family connections.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text