logo

47 pages 1 hour read

B.A. Paris

The Breakdown

Fiction | Novel | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 16-21Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 16 Summary: “Wednesday, August 12th”

After sleeping through Tuesday under the influence of her pills, Cass sees a news update indicating that the police think Jane picked up her killer before stopping on Blackwater Lane. The next morning, Matthew sleeps through his alarm and is still home when the silent call comes. He puts it on speaker and hears the silence but thinks little of it. Cass says something is different this time. Usually, they’re more menacing and she can sense someone there. Matthew convinces her it’s just a foreign call center repeatedly trying to get through. His conviction helps her ignore the rest of the calls coming through that day without needing any pills. That night, Cass and Matthew have a pleasant dinner and talk about having a baby.

Chapter 17 Summary: “Thursday, August 13th”

On Thursday, Cass begins hanging up on the silent caller immediately after answering. He calls repeatedly until she gives up and listens to the silence long enough to satisfy him. When she tells Matthew about it, he seems fed up and dismisses her concerns. The sound of a car peeling out in front of the house makes Cass think it had been sitting there, watching. She leaves in fear and goes shopping in Castle Wells, where she runs into her friend Connie. When Cass apologizes for missing Connie’s party at the beginning of the summer (the night of Jane’s murder) Connie mentions that John wasn’t there either.

When she’s ready to go home, Cass can’t find her car in the parking garage. She’s sure she parked on level four, but she checks levels two, three, and five just to be certain. She tells the attendant her car was stolen, but he doesn’t believe her. When she tries to show him, she finds her car where she left it. The continued toll of questioning her sanity leaves Cass shaken and extremely depressed.

Chapter 18 Summary: “Friday, August 14th”

Cass receives a letter from Jane’s husband, Alex, thanking her for the kind card she sent. She decides to tell Matthew her theory about Jane’s killer being her tormentor. If he believes it’s possible, she’ll tell the police. While waiting for Matthew to finish work, Cass runs into John, and they have lunch together. He says he’s been having a rough time since his girlfriend “disappeared off the scene” (155). Cass confides in John about her fears of having dementia. He’s understanding and kind.

After lunch, on a whim, Cass drives to the village where Jane lived. She sits on a bench at the park and realizes that Jane’s husband is there with their twin daughters. He talks to her a bit, but she doesn’t reveal who she is or that she knew Jane. Cass gets home at 5 o’clock that evening but is too afraid to go inside, so she waits in the car until Matthew gets home at 6:30 pm. Matthew talks about meeting their new neighbor, a retired pilot whose wife recently left him. Matthew suggests that they have him over for dinner sometime.

Chapter 19 Summary: “Saturday, August 15th”

Cass calls Rachel, who’s on vacation in Siena, and they arrange to have lunch the day after she gets back, which is the day before school starts. Cass still has an enormous amount of work left to prepare for the term. Matthew books them a couples’ spa appointment for the afternoon, but they’re running late, so he takes the Blackwater Lane shortcut. Cass panics and tries to get out of the car while it’s going 40 kph. Matthew stops the car right where Jane died, pushing Cass to hysterics. Matthew takes her home and has Dr. Deakin come by. The doctor says Cass should be taking the pills he prescribed consistently, rather than only as needed. When she finally calms down, Cass tells Matthew she’s stressed about school starting and not sure she can get prepared in time. He suggests that she ask to work part-time.

Chapter 20 Summary: “Friday, August 28th”

Since Dr. Deakin’s visit, Cass has been taking two pills every night and two every morning. They make her so sluggish that she spends her days drifting between wake and sleep. She’s unable to drive, has no appetite, and is no longer returning calls or emails from her friends and coworkers. She can’t remember how to work the microwave. Things she doesn’t remember ordering from the shopping channel keep arriving. She forgets to attend the teacher’s planning meeting but tells Matthew she skipped it because she decided not to go back to work. Cass’s boss, Mary, comes by the house, and Matthew learns that Cass hasn’t returned any of Mary’s, Connie’s, or John’s calls. Cass blames the pills but says she doesn’t want to reduce the dose.

Chapter 21 Summary: “Tuesday, September 1st”

Cass doesn’t take her pills during the day on weekends because she doesn’t want Matthew to see how doped-up they make her. She forgets her lunch date with Rachel, who comes by to check on her. Rachel’s concern increases when she sees how Cass looks. She urges Cass to accompany her on her work trip to New York, but Cass can’t handle the thought of getting on a plane or even leaving the house. That night, Cass admits to Matthew she can’t remember how to work the washing machine. He shows her a letter from Dr. Deakin saying she may have early-onset dementia and needs to schedule testing. This news makes Cass feel like she’s lost her last bit of hope.

Chapters 16-21 Analysis

Like most thrillers, The Breakdown incorporates misleading clues, also known as red herrings. These false trails are especially effective in these chapters. One example occurs when Matthew answers the silent call himself, and Cass insists that the calls are usually more menacing, though she can’t articulate what’s different. This casts doubt on her rationality, giving readers cause to question her reliability as a narrator. Cass’s interaction with Connie and her lunch with John in Chapters 17 and 18 provide even more compelling (though ultimately misleading) clues about the identity of Cass’s tormentor. Connie implied that John skipped the party because Cass wasn’t going, meaning that she expected him to be there until the last minute. His absence from the party subtly suggests that he could have been on Blackwater Lane instead, murdering Jane. John’s words to Cass at lunch reinforce this possibility: “I’ve been at a bit of a loose end since my girlfriend disappeared off the scene” (155). His odd word choice—“disappeared off the scene”—and the timing of his breakup imply that Jane may have been that girlfriend and that John could have been Jane’s secret lover and her killer.

In a recurring plot device, Matthew and Rachel equate Cass’s silent calls to calls from overzealous telemarketers. Matthew insists, “It’s just some call center trying to get through, that’s all” (134). Earlier, Rachel comments, “A few calls from a withheld number? Cass, I get loads of those! Usually, it’s someone trying to sell me something or wanting feedback on something I’ve bought” (85). Cass doesn’t argue that a call center would have no reason to call repeatedly, day after day, for months or comment on the fact that repetitive, silent calls are quite different from sales calls and surveys. The fact that Matthew and Rachel convince Cass of this illogical explanation speaks to the powerful influence of gaslighting. Cass’s faith in her ability to reason and her sense of reality have been so upended that she’s unable to recognize their explanation’s lack of merit or the implications of their repeatedly promoting it. As a result, Cass becomes powerless. She feels she can’t even confide in the people closest to her because “[a]ll it will sound like is more hysteria, more paranoia on my part” (149). The author pairs Cass’s harassing calls with Matthew and Rachel’s unreasonable explanation to reveal the effects on Cass’s psyche, thereby further developing the book’s thematic exploration of How Gaslighting Weaponizes the Fragility of Memory and Perception.

In Cass’s relationship to the pills from Dr. Deakin, she encounters a new facet of her internal and external conflicts. Taking the pills results in sedation and a lack of control and autonomy. Not taking the pills leaves her vulnerable to chronic fear and outbursts that, at best, put a strain on her marriage. Her choice to take the pills or not take them uses the pills’ symbolism to establish the current state of her character arc. From an initial hesitance to take them at all, she goes to taking them some of the time and eventually to taking them consistently, day and night. At this point in the story, Cass chooses sedation and a lack of fear over alertness and control because she trusts Matthew and her doctor to look out for her best interests when she can’t. Another reason she makes this choice is that fear and self-doubt have taken a heavy toll on her, thematically illustrating The Impact of Guilt and Fear on Mental Health.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text

Related Titles

By B.A. Paris