41 pages • 1 hour read
Amy TanA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Tan grows in confidence and pride in her birding abilities. She begins to understand the cycles of birds more intimately and is attuned when something is out of the ordinary. When pine siskins arrive after fighting off disease, a red-tailed hawk appears in Tan’s yard, threatening the returned birds. Tan reminds herself to avoid rooting for one or the other. She designs new ways to observe birds more closely, such as building a small, caged feeder and placing it against a glass door so that she can crouch next to it and wait.
This section also shows evidence of the pandemic and other external contexts on Tan’s birding and interpretations of patterns. Wildfires send new species to her yard: a Western meadowlark, a black-headed grosbeak, and a hermit warbler—a species considered rare. Observing birds helps Tan to feel as though she is not cooped up. She gathers with friends on her verandah, each person ten feet away from the others. Together, they observe the birds moving around in Tan’s backyard. One of her friends can hear two woodpeckers knocking to one another, and it reminds Tan that she needs to invest in getting a hearing aid. She does not want to miss anything for loss of hearing.
Sounds play an important role in Tan’s development as a birder. She recognizes the cheerful song of the white-throated sparrow, which informs her about the mating and courtship habits of the birds. Sound also alerts Tan to a mother and son pair of great horned owls arriving to her yard and to a new mating pair that would later overtake the territory.
Tan never ceases to be surprised by birds. While watching a towhee attempt to get inside a caged feeder, she notices that it cannot fit its large frame through the holes. However, a white-throated sparrow, roughly the same size as the towhee, slides between the wires with ease to obtain a chunk of suet. The towhee watches the sparrow and, without flinching, makes itself smaller in the same way as the sparrow and fits between the bars. Tan wonders about birds observing others and learning from them.
The writer also continues to experience tragedy in nature. A spotted towhee loses a leg to a cat and dies. Another bird loses a leg and is unable to adapt for migration. A juvenile Cooper’s hawk, possibly impaired from household poison, crashes into her bird feeders. Tan drives the hawk to a wildlife center, where, after a few months, it is determined that the hawk’s condition is not viable. To Tan, this tragedy mirrors her own loss of a close friend named Asa who dies from a heart attack. Tan recalls how Asa used to dress in drag and mimic Tan. Two days after Asa’s death, Tan sees three rare species in her backyard: an American robin, a chipmunk, and a purple finch. She wonders if Asa is behind these unusual sightings.
Tan frequently applies human characteristics to birds. A study of a clumsy crow causes her to wonder whether birds can feel embarrassment. She recalls that monkeys in a zoo will repeat behaviors if they are being laughed at by spectators, as if to indicate they meant to make the original mistake. When male juncos suddenly become polite to females during an off-mating season, Tan wonders if there is more behind their affectionate behavior. Tan challenges her own anthropomorphizing of the birds in her yard but then argues that viewing birds in this way leads to new understanding: “But anthropomorphic paradigms are a start for looking at equivalents from a bird’s perspective. I parse out the traits of human emotions to see if any are found in the behavior of birds” (232). Tan is happy that she is an artist and not a pure scientist—that she can embrace a measure of mysticism in her practice.
The final section shows the culmination of Tan’s growth as a birder and artist within the diary’s six-year time frame. Many of the illustrations in this section show birds in more natural habitats, clinging to branches, with strong attention to detail and color. Unlike early drawings that utilize only a handful of colors to express the shades of different birds, Tan uses all her drawing pencils to highlight the subtle shifts in color in a bird’s feathers. Her attention to detail is also seen in how she describes bird behaviors. She is less quick to anthropomorphize birds; when she does, she turns her lens of scrutiny upon herself, asking how her perception might be impacting the ways she interprets bird behavior. She acknowledges the tendency to anthropomorphize as a problem while maintaining that she is an artist before she is a scientist, suggesting that she finds delight in taking such creative license in her observations. When it comes to art, Tan believes that perception matters: “It’s like what I do with fiction. One character’s intentions and what another wants to believe are the beginning of a story, always subject to change” (193).
By exploring the role of perception in her observation, Tan builds her skills in Embodiment as Creative Practice. To engage with the birds’ experiences requires that she both recognize herself in their lives and separate herself as well. Asking questions that relate bird and human experiences forces her to question what she would ordinarily consider to be normal or innate behaviors. Analyzing her perception then helps her to avoid seeing bird behaviors in a strictly human way. Tan embraces both art and science, unwilling to set her mysticism aside completely for the sake of objective research and observation. The death of her close friend Asa weighs heavily on Tan. When three unusual species appear suddenly in her backyard, all within a single hour, she wonders if this may be a sign from her deceased friend. Birds become symbols to Tan; for instance, the scrub jay represents persistence due to its tenacious search for food.
Tan continues to use Inquiry as a Path to Understanding to connect to her research subjects. By engaging in continuous questioning, Tan grows in her understanding of context. Her drawings support this. Unlike earlier drawings where birds behave in human ways or interact with human materials comically, her later drawings show the interconnectedness of the birds and their human contexts. Drawings of Tan appear more frequently. In a drawing depicting her investigation of a nesting house, Tan draws herself apologizing to its inhabitants. She shows herself looking through binoculars and considers whether the device’s dark, round eyes remind small songbirds of an owl. This shift in her art shows that Tan is thinking about how her life and the lives of the birds are linked. She embraces her ecological self.
Tan remembers someone telling her that a bird feeder is an artificial environment. Bird species that normally would never interact with one another congregate around a feeder, and drama ensues. She reminds herself to look up, to seek birds out in more natural contexts. She begins asking questions about both the birds and her relationship with them. As she questions their behavior, she interrogates her interpretation of their actions. This line of inquiry in The Art of Paying Attention leads Tan to another important discovery: that the birds are aware of her rhythms and cycles. She realizes that the birds watch her through the windows and attempt to signal her to feed them. They have also been keeping notes.
By Amy Tan