56 pages • 1 hour read
Anne TylerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Muriel tells Macon about the man she was seeing before him. She helped that man get his life together, and he left her to elope with another woman shortly after. Macon finds his thoughts wandering to Sarah from time to time in little moments while taking Edward out or while listening to Claire rant about her relationships.
Macon and Muriel walk to the thrift stores and encounter Dominick’s mother, who asks if they’ve seen him. She worries about him staying out all night and talks about how he doesn’t drive safely when he has Muriel’s car. While thrifting, Muriel brings up going to France with Macon, which is his next trip after Canada. Macon hesitates because of the cost. When he mentions she’d need to take time off, Muriel reveals that she left her job at the vet. Macon becomes upset with Muriel, who justifies her decision because Macon has taken on a lot of financial responsibility for them anyway. Muriel eventually assures Macon that she can take care of herself.
Muriel continues to hint at the France trip, but Macon tries to ignore it. While heading home from the grocery store, a young teen tries to rob them, but Muriel smacks the boy with her purse and tells him to go home. Macon is surprised at her reaction, feeling she was careless but also ashamed of himself for not defending her.
Macon brings up Alexander’s education, concerned that he cannot subtract correctly. He suggests a private school and adds that he’ll pay for it, which upsets Muriel. She wants Macon to say he’s committed to her long-term and warns him not to make promises that involve Alexander if he cannot picture them getting married one day. Muriel is tense for the rest of the night but eventually relaxes around Macon again.
The next day, the mailman delivers a calendar for the current year. Muriel asks Macon to open it. Confused, Macon flips through the pages until he finds a date in June marked for a wedding. Muriel tells him that he’ll be free to get married by then and that she always wanted a June wedding. Macon tells her he’s unsure about marriage and doesn’t believe it should be commonplace. He thinks only perfect couples should marry, which upsets Muriel. She asks if he and Sarah were perfect.
Rose and Julian return from their honeymoon and invite their family to their new apartment for dinner. Macon buys an expensive wine as a gift, which entices Muriel. Later, he finds the wine opened because Muriel couldn’t resist trying some. Instead of confronting her, Macon goes to buy another bottle before dinner begins. While they get ready for dinner, Macon spots the date on Muriel’s childhood photo, acknowledging that he and Sarah were already engaged when Muriel was a toddler. Macon thinks about Sarah again at Rose and Julian’s apartment as Rose presents them with pâté made from Sarah’s recipe. That night, in bed, Muriel asks Macon if he’d ever leave her. He promises her he won’t. She asks him if he takes her seriously. He doesn’t answer.
While Macon is staying in Manitoba, Sarah calls his hotel room, asking if she can move back into their house because her lease is ending. Sarah suggests an arrangement where she’ll pay for any repairs the insurance doesn’t cover instead of paying rent. Macon agrees. Sarah tells Macon the final divorce papers arrived, adding that she wasn’t prepared for the emotion it brought up in her. Macon gets off the phone quickly.
Porter’s children are staying with Porter and Charles now, and as a result, Rose has moved back home with her brothers to help care for them, though she still brings casseroles to Julian in their apartment.
While flying to Edmonton, Macon reassures the woman flying with him about the plane's safety. She is terrified, and Macon puts on a cool front to comfort her. When he gets off the plane, he wonders if maybe he has become the relaxed person he pretended to be for his seatmate.
In Edmonton, Sarah calls again. They discuss the house, and Sarah questions why some of the sheets are sewn in half and why the popcorn maker is in the bedroom. Macon can hardly remember that period of his life anymore. They talk about the weather, and Sarah says she wishes she was with him to watch the distant rain together. Macon feels like he is breaking into pieces.
In Vancouver, they talk about the weather again. Macon realizes that just like before, he’s “won [Sarah’s] attention only by withdrawing” (289). She asks him if he plans to stay with Muriel forever. Macon says he’s not sure and realizes how unfamiliar Muriel’s name sounds.
When he arrives back in Baltimore, Macon retrieves his car and drives to Singleton Street. However, once he arrives, he hesitates and doesn’t turn down the street. Instead, he drives back to his old neighborhood, to his house. He can see the lights on upstairs, indicating Sarah is there. He feels he has come home.
Macon and Sarah fall back into their lives together. They go couch shopping since most of their furniture was ruined by the burst pipe. Macon has moved Edward back into their house. Macon recalls the awkwardness as he gathered his things from Muriel’s, having told her that he was moving back in with Sarah. Muriel asked him if he was “really doing this” and if he “can just use a person up and then move on” (297).
After picking out a couch, Macon and Sarah visit Rose to pick up fertilizer. Despite Porter’s children moving back with their mother, Rose has elected to stay at Grandfather Leary’s house with Charles and Porter because they had fallen apart without her, staying in their pajamas all day to reduce laundry and making weird, efficient dinners instead of balanced meals.
Macon and Sarah have lunch at the Old Bay restaurant. While it previously annoyed Sarah that Macon always wanted to eat there, it was her choice this time to go, saying, “There are worse things than boring, I’ve decided” (299). Over lunch, Sarah tells Macon about the man she was seeing while they were separated. She explains that she initially liked things about him, but she soon became annoyed by them and longed for Macon’s habits. Macon thinks about how it annoyed him when Muriel mispronounced “et cetera,” but now he misses it. Sarah says she thinks that, at a certain age, you lose your ability to choose who you spend your life with, saying, “You’re who I’m with. It’s too late for me to change. I’ve used up too much of my life now” (301). Macon adds that they can only choose what to lose, referring to Muriel and the man Sarah had spent time with.
After lunch, Macon is alone in the house while Sarah takes an art class. He longs to speak to someone and calls Muriel to warn her that it’s bee season and Alexander needs his shots. Muriel scolds him for having the audacity to call about Alexander after abandoning them. She angrily tells him that Dominick is dead because he crashed her car on the way home from a party and that she’s on her way to console his mother.
When they get off the phone, Macon recalls having to identify Ethan’s body for the police. Sarah waited outside while Macon took one last look at his dead son. He hoped Ethan would wake up, but he did not. Macon realized how little a person’s body is of a person, that a body could remain, but the person could still be gone. When he came out, Sarah became upset at Macon’s lack of emotion. She accused Macon of not being able to recognize Ethan, theorizing that it probably wasn’t even Ethan’s body. Macon explained that he had just discovered the futility of life while looking at Ethan, upsetting Sarah more.
Julian visits and expresses to Macon that he’s worried Rose has left him. He’s concerned about the amount of time Rose dedicates to serving others. Macon suggests Julian offer Rose a job as his secretary but disguise it as Julian pleading for help from an organized person. Julian expresses that Macon is his best friend.
When Sarah comes home, she and Macon discuss the new couch. Sarah is upset that Macon does not have strong opinions. They end up making love, which Macon describes as “comfortable and soothing” (310). After dinner at their neighbors’ house, which neither was enthused about attending, they go to bed, but Macon struggles to sleep through the night.
Macon flies to France. On the plane, he encounters Muriel, who called Macon’s travel agent to book the same flight and hotel as Macon. She insists Macon needs her. Macon thinks Muriel will know nothing about traveling to France because she wore white for the flight, and she’d have known better if she had read his travel guide. Surprisingly, Muriel has read his guide and uses that knowledge to traverse the city on her own. After multiple attempts to get Macon to spend time with her, Muriel finally convinces Macon to join her for dinner at Burger King.
Macon asks about Alexander, and Muriel rattles off the elaborate guardianship plan she’s orchestrated with her family and neighbors, vividly reminding Macon about Singleton Street. In the elevator, Muriel asks if she can join Macon in his room. He declines, telling her he can’t change now that he’s been married for so long. Macon runs into Muriel again the next afternoon and helps her carry her bags to her room. She’s bought many items she’ll have to worry about getting home and helped herself to the mini-bar despite its high cost.
They go to a nice restaurant, and Muriel motivates Macon to try a new food instead of the same safe salad from his guidebook. Muriel asks where Macon is going tomorrow, and he informs her that he is traveling to a different city. Muriel asks him to take her, but he tells her no. Muriel says she has slept poorly and has dreams that Dominick is mad at her. Macon assures her that Dominick is probably happy wherever he is. At their hotel, Muriel begs Macon to join her in her room to ward off the nightmares. Macon declines, but as he falls asleep, he decides to invite Muriel with him to the next city. As he goes to call her room in the morning, he throws his back out.
Macon lies in bed for a while, pondering how he’ll manage his day trips. Muriel knocks at his door, but he remains silent and goes back to sleep. Later, a chambermaid enters his room. She helps him call Julian, but instead, Rose picks up, explaining that she’s working for Julian now. Macon tells her about his back and his day trips that he’ll need rescheduled, and Rose assures him she’ll take care of everything. Macon stays in bed the rest of the day, moving only to use the restroom and drink some wine.
In the morning, Sarah arrives, informing Macon that Rose sent her. She’ll be helping Macon heal and taking over Macon’s day trips. Macon is surprised to see her and worries that she’ll find out he’s spent time with Muriel. Sarah runs into Muriel in the lobby and tells Macon. He explains that Muriel followed him on her own accord. Sarah gives Macon pain pills, which help his back a little but also impair him mentally. She proposes that they make the trip a second honeymoon, and Macon agrees.
Sarah asks if Macon was drawn to Muriel because of Alexander. She has come around to the idea of having another child. Macon says it’s too late for them now. Sarah then asks why he didn’t make Muriel leave the plane, adding that he could have “taken steps” to stop her from joining him if he’d wanted to. After settling into bed, Macon realizes he’s never “taken steps” toward anything in his life. His marriage, Ethan, relationship with Muriel, and job have all “simply befallen him” (339).
In the morning, Macon packs his belongings. He’s decided to go back to Muriel. Sarah wakes and asks him what he’s doing. He explains his decision. She tries to dissuade him, talking about their second honeymoon and how he and Muriel will be perceived as a couple. Macon understands that perception isn’t what matters. He and Muriel share a dynamic that works for them. He leaves Sarah to catch a cab, determined to catch his original flight home and find Muriel. Along the way, he abandons his suitcase because it hurts his back. Once he’s in the cab, it loops around to go the opposite way. As it passes his hotel, he spots Muriel waiting to hail a cab and asks the driver to stop for her.
As foreshadowed in chapters 16 and 17, Macon’s return to Sarah in Chapters 18 and 19 is not entirely unexpected, given Macon’s tendency to seek out familiar and convenient choices.
Chapter 17 reveals the cracks in Macon and Muriel’s relationship through their incompatibilities and insecurities. After seeing Sarah at Rose’s wedding, Macon’s thoughts wander back to her as he wonders if she’s seeing anyone and pictures himself telling her all about the people of Singleton Street. After Muriel reveals she left her job at the vet, Macon “couldn’t explain the sudden weight that fell on him” (267). Macon is frustrated that Muriel has assumed that he’ll continue to handle the financial responsibilities he’s taken on for the foreseeable future. This hints at Macon’s lack of commitment to Muriel, which she questions at the end of the chapter, asking, “You wouldn’t ever leave me, would you?” (278). Muriel’s insecurities and pushiness continue to frustrate Macon throughout Chapter 17. She pushes the idea of joining him in France, going as far as to obtain passport photos despite Macon shutting her down. These actions effectively foreshadow Muriel's appearance on the plane at the beginning of Chapter 20. Muriel also tries to set a wedding date with Macon despite not even being engaged. Macon argues, saying he’s “not ready for this! I don’t think I ever will be” (273), to reject the idea. These instances of incompatibility between them and insecurity on Muriel’s part foreshadow Macon’s return to Sarah.
In these final chapters, distance plays an important role in Macon’s switching between relationships. As he gets space between himself and Muriel in Chapter 18, the regular conversations with Sarah begin to feel familiar. Macon recognizes that Sarah also feels this way, saying, “She sounded like her old self,” when he recognizes the relaxed tone of her voice during their first phone call. During their second phone call, Macon realizes what’s happening and feels he is “separating, falling into pieces” (289) as Sarah’s voice becomes more familiar and Muriel sinks further into his memories. During their third phone call, Macon acknowledges that he’s “won [Sarah’s] attention only by withdrawing” (289), which Sarah confirms when she asks if Macon sees himself staying with Muriel. Here, he realizes how unfamiliar Muriel’s name suddenly feels, showing how he’s grown closer to Sarah in Muriel’s absence. The effect of distance is repeated in Chapter 20 when Macon flies to France with Muriel. In a parallel way to Sarah, Muriel noses her way back into Macon’s life during this time. The distance from Sarah helps Macon to rekindle his fondness for Muriel. At the end of the chapter, with both women in the same hotel as him, Macon finally decides that it’s up to him to choose which relationship will make him truly happy, highlighting the theme of passively living versus actively living. Macon realizes he “couldn’t think of a single major act he had managed of his own accord” (339), acknowledging that all his relationships, living situations, and career choices were results of a passive acceptance of what life has given him. Macon decides he will pursue what he wants for the first time, leaving Sarah in the hotel to go after Muriel.
The loss of a child theme persists in these final chapters with Dominick’s death. As foreshadowed in Chapter 17, during Muriel and Macon’s encounter with Dominick’s mother, Dominick crashes Muriel’s car, resulting in his immediate death. When Macon learns this, he flashbacks to the day he verified Ethan’s identity to the police. It becomes clear through this flashback that this was the beginning of the rift that Ethan’s death caused between Macon and Sarah. Macon feels “she grew to hold him responsible, like a bearer of bad tidings—the only one who could say for a fact that Ethan had truly died” (306). The memory of Sarah’s treatment of Macon after this event sets the stage for Macon’s return to Muriel in the final chapter.
By Anne Tyler
American Literature
View Collection
Coping with Death
View Collection
Family
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Marriage
View Collection
National Book Critics Circle Award...
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Pulitzer Prize Fiction Awardees &...
View Collection
Romance
View Collection
Valentine's Day Reads: The Theme of Love
View Collection