94 pages • 3 hours read
J. R. R. TolkienA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Character Analysis
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
When Fëanor burns his ships, the Orcs spot the flames, as do the “watchers of Morgoth” (50). Fëanor and his people pass into the land of Hithlum and arrive at a lake, Mithrim, where they make camp. Melkor’s forces attack before the encampment is set up but are defeated by the Noldor. Fëanor chases down the enemy back to Angband but is consumed by “the flame of his own wrath” (50) and finds himself separated from his forces; the Balrogs notice and attack. Fëanor is surrounded and, though he fights well, is struck down by Gothmog, Lord of Balrogs. At the last moment, Fëanor’s sons arrive and chase away the Balrogs. The injured Fëanor is carried to Mithrim but tells them to stop; he knows he is going to die. Looking over all of Middle-earth, he calls on his sons to avenge their father. Fëanor dies, his body turning straight to ash.
The Noldor meet with the local Grey Elves and learn of the power of Thingol. An emissary of Melkor offers them a peace deal that includes the return of one Silmaril. Maedhros, Fëanor’s son, convinces his brothers to accept the deal and to betray Melkor when convenient. They arrive at the meeting with a huge army, but Melkor has sent more. Maedhros’ men are killed, and Maedhros is captured alive and taken to Angband. The remaining brothers know they cannot make a deal with Melkor and are sworn to avenge their father, so Melkor strings Maedhros by the wrist and hangs him from a high precipice.
Fingolfin and his people march into Mithrim as the sun rises for the first time and pass through unchallenged to Angband. They hear Maedhros call for help. Fingolfin is wary and turns his people back to Mithrim. He makes camp near the sons of Fëanor; there is still resentment between the groups, though Fingolfin has far greater numbers. Fingolfin camps on the northern shore, Fëanor’s sons on the south. Melkor laughs at the division of his enemies and spreads a thick black smoke over the land. Fingolfin’s son Fingon makes peace with the other Noldor by rescuing Maedhros with the help of Manwë and a giant eagle, cutting off Maedhros’ hand to free him from Melkor’s binding.
Thingol will not allow the reunited Noldor into his kingdom but tells them where they might make their home. The Noldor are unimpressed by Thingol but do as he says, making their homes near Hithlum, Dorthonion, and the empty lands east of Doriath, meeting the Dwarves along the way.
Twenty years later, Fingolfin hosts a great feast. It is a time of peace, though darkness “brooded in the north” (54). As more decades pass, Turgon and Finrod wander the lands, and Ulmo infuses them with the idea that they must build fortresses to protect themselves in case Melkor ever bursts from Angband. Fingolfin seeks advice from Thingol and the Dwarves and builds Nargothrond, while Turgon searches for many years until he finds a hidden vale in the Encircling Mountains and plans to build a great city there.
Melkor watches the Elves from afar and launches an attack after a few decades of peace. His Orcs are defeated again, and the Noldor and the other Elves resolve to fortify their defenses. They even consider attacking Angband but lack the strength, though they do lay siege to Angband for 400 years. A hundred years later, Melkor tries again. This time, the Orcs sneak around and try and attack the Elves’ rear, but the Elves beat the Orcs again. After another hundred years, Melkor creates a dragon named Glaurung and sets it loose. The young dragon scares many Elves but is eventually beaten by Fingon. After that, 200 years of peace follows, and Beleriand becomes very prosperous. The Noldor and the Sindar become almost as one people.
Melkor lives in the north; Utumno, his fortress in Angband, is flanked on either side by the Iron Mountains. He builds numerous fortresses (including Thangorodrim) around his land and lives in the “endless dungeons” (56) beneath the earth, also known as the Hells of Iron. To the west of Thangorodrim is the Land of Mist.
Fingolfin and Fingon live in Mithrim, near the lake. Turgon lives in Nevrast, and to the south is Dorthonion (where Dorthonion Angrod and Aegnor, sons of Finarfin, live). Further south, Finrod holds the Pass of Sirion and its huge watchtower, Minas Tirith. Further south still is Finrod, overseen by Fingolfin and then Fingon. It is the greatest realm of the Noldor. To the south of that is Thingol’s kingdoms, including Beleriand. Fëanor’s sons, led by Maedhros, take over East Beleriand.
Turgon continues to investigate the land at Tumladen and discovers an underground entrance. He decides to build a huge city on the site, a secret process that takes many years. The city is named Gondolin. Turgon moves there and is warned by Ulmo that he has not escaped the curse placed on the Noldor and that, one day, Melkor will attack and that true salvation “lieth in the West and cometh from the Sea” (60). Turgon and his people live in Gondolin for centuries; Turgon has a daughter named Celebrindal.
Galadriel, sister of Finrod, lives in Thingol’s realm, in Doriath. She befriends Melian and the two talk often about Valinor, though Galadriel never discusses anything beyond the death of the Trees. Melian figures out that the Noldor were exiled (rather than blessed by the Valar), and Galadriel tells her about the Silmarils, which she then shares with Thingol. Melian believes that the Silmarils will bring destruction, but Thingol views the Noldor as essential allies in the fight against Melkor.
Thingol later confronts the sons of Finarfin and says he has learned of the “evil deeds of the Noldor” (61), but Finrod calms him. Angrod blames the sons of Fëanor. Thingol demands that no Sindar ever “speak with the tongue of the Noldor” (62) ever again and sends away the Noldor, though he will not formally banish them.
After contributing so much to the story, the death of Fëanor raises many questions in the audience’s mind. Is death a deserved punishment for Fëanor? What did he achieve in dying? What is Fëanor’s legacy? As ever with Fëanor, they are difficult questions to answer. He is responsible for the creation of the Silmarils and for leading the Noldor out of Valinor, both self-centered acts that have caused a great deal of suffering. Most importantly of all, in the moment of Fëanor’s death, he compels his children to swear an oath, making them promise to continue a quest that has already appeared doomed. In doing so, he has brought a great suffering not just on himself or his people but on generations to come. If Fëanor was a tragic hero during his life, his death and the oath complicates and muddies his legacy.
The above chapters also demonstrate the importance of geography in Tolkien’s work. With such a big, sprawling world, he is forced to take the time to assure the reader of the location of everything. Land is not just defined by its scenery or location but by who exercises power and control over it. Different Elves rule of different parts of the world, coexisting in a complicated social network that is made all the more complicated by the fact that they are immortal. Sons in need of their own seat of power must seek out and build their own kingdoms or wait for their father to be killed. Tolkien begins to address this, and the creation of Gondolin is Turgon’s response to this issue.
This is an issue that Melkor further exacerbates: Everything he rules over becomes poisonous and corrupted. Melkor has the clearest physical impact on the land he rules, though the geography of his power is no less important. His home is sandwiched between two mountains that are seemingly impassable, though he can exit out of the rear when he wishes to move forth into the world. As much as the Elves are focused on their own kingdoms, the presence of Angband is a constant reminder that their way of life is under threat. While hundreds of years pass, the looming threat of Melkor endangers their dominion over the physical geography of Middle-earth.
By J. R. R. Tolkien