62 pages • 2 hours read
Thomas KeneallyA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Thomas Keneally presents Schindler’s story as a battle of the human potential for good and evil. The good is pragmatic and practical, while the evil is absolute, with no concern for what’s practical or pragmatic. The author situates these differing approaches to life by good and evil through how various characters approach money, black-market dealings, vices, and their relationship to the Nazi regime. Keneally is careful not to make his examples of good and evil larger-than-life; they’re people who are separated from the other side by a thin barrier. This results in a black-and-white battle of good and evil that doesn’t take combatants out of their context as people who lived at one point in history. Keneally’s approach allows him to dramatize a good-versus-evil context from history without stripping the authentic historical figures of their lives as complex people.
Schindler’s pragmatic good doesn’t put him above being a not-so-good person in other regards. Schindler’s virtue is “strange” because he has many vices that would be considered hallmarks of an indecent person. Schindler has an alcohol dependency, which biases against addicts often lead people to think of them as somehow lesser individuals morally. Keneally leans on this anti-addict bias to make Schindler appear a less good person because of alcoholism. He’s a womanizer who frequently abandons his wife Emilie and doesn’t give her as much attention as he gives to his mistresses, whom his wife knows about. In addition, Schindler’s intentions are murky when the narrative begins: Like many other Germans, he comes to Cracow seeking the spoils and profits of war. When Schindler sees the reality of life for minorities under Nazi rule, he uses his position of privilege and power—granted by the party—to engage in pragmatic sabotage without exposing himself to harm that would stop his mission. Schindler is pragmatic in that he doesn’t join a resistance group, nor does he actively sabotage or bomb the SS like others do. Instead, he works slowly from inside the machine while pretending to work for the Nazis. Schindler’s pragmatism works in tandem with the extremism of groups like the ZOB, though at times they butt heads, such as when Schindler is nearly blown up by the ZOB.
Goeth is absolutely evil yet doesn’t look the part. Keneally often mentions how average Goeth looks. When Pfefferberg first encounters Goeth during the ghetto liquidation, he notes that “[Goeth] did not look like a murderer; there was a sensitivity to the large face and a subtle line to the mouth” (187). Whenever Goeth is engaged in the most heinous crimes, Keneally emphasizes that he doesn’t look the part. Goeth is a human and not a storybook character; Keneally’s constant humanization of Goeth’s physical features is a rhetorical device to show that human evil isn’t visible on the surface. Keneally notes that Goeth is particularly kind and tender with his own children yet later reveals that he physically abused his wives. Keneally suggests that evil, like good, is an invisible quality that lurks behind everyday behavior.
The “big silence” surrounding World War II that settled on Germany postwar resulted from a murky situation around notions of complicity and guilt. It was unclear who was complicit with the Nazi war machine and what counted as complicity, as well as where the line was between trying to feed one’s family and being guilty. Many couldn’t answer these questions, so the subject went dormant because families were ashamed of their pasts until the Schindler’s List film debuted in Germany. Keneally’s presentation of Schindler’s story highlights this struggle between complicity, guilt, and survival under the Nazi regime.
Schindler frequently wrestles with his complicity in the Nazi war machine while he works to save the DEF prisoners. For comfort, he relies on the marginalized people whom the Nazis are terrorizing. Despite people like Stern bearing the brunt of Nazi terror, Schindler is affected too much by his proximity to the Nazi war machine and its genocidal endeavors. When Schindler hoses down the cattle cars full of people in front of other Nazis, he openly defies the party in order to give a small comfort to people doomed to execution. Goeth observes that Schindler’s actions are futile and that he can’t hose down every cattle car full of prisoners. Despite Schindler’s efforts to comfort the prisoners, he’s still somewhat complicit in their fates like the other Nazis present in the scene. The viciousness of the Nazi party allows room for only small acts of pragmatic good on Schindler’s part, stopping him from freeing the people in the cattle car; had he actually freed them, he and the prisoners would all have ended up in Auschwitz.
Paradoxically, Schindler’s desire to do pragmatic good and save as many people as he can requires that he participate in the Nazi’s schemes. While DEF exists in Cracow, Schindler must run a small munitions press in his factory to be considered an essential wartime factory. The munitions press makes the factory—and thus its workers—essential but only because it contributes weaponry to the Nazi war machine. Schindler is immensely relieved when the factory moves to Brinnlitz and he has the power to manufacture complete duds with his munition presses. When Schindler receives a telegram stating that his tank shells are unusable, he says, “It’s the best birthday present I could have got. Because I know now that no poor bastard has been killed by my product” (342). The contradiction between Schindler’s desire to do good and the necessity of being complicit with the system wears down his mental health throughout the novel. Keneally’s depiction of Schindler’s mental health juxtaposed against his Nazi party membership and politicking to save his workers suggests that complicity and guilt are unavoidable evils for a pragmatist to work within an unjust system.
The state-sponsored, bureaucratic extermination program of the Nazis murdered at minimum 15 million people. The Nazis first terrorized—and exterminated en masse—people with disabilities, communists, and LGBTQ+ people, before setting their sights on racial, ethnic, and religious minorities. The vast majority of those murdered during the Holocaust were Jewish people, accounting for roughly six million of the total victims. Schindler’s List portrays characters who lived in the moment of the Holocaust, slowly coming to terms with the atrocity as the Nazis’ plans are revealed. The Nazis tried to hide their crimes, both from privileged “Aryan” citizens and from the Soviets, who were ideologically opposed to the Nazis and, after the war, broadcast the Nazis’ crimes globally. Keneally set out to write the novel in order to shed light on the Holocaust and the people who lived through it; Spielberg’s film continued this mission.
The people persecuted by the Nazis demonstrated resilience by continuing life as normally as they could despite their oppression. The Jewish people of DEF and Płaszów engaged in marriages, religious ceremonies, and other communal activities that defied their status as property of the state. The rate of death by suicide was high among Holocaust survivors, both during and after the war, as depicted in the novel by Clara Sternberg’s attempts to throw herself on Auschwitz’s electric fence. The traumas of the Nazi genocide left people scarred and often dead, but survivors kept some semblance of normalcy through communal activities, which the Nazis prohibited; for example, in the novel, Schindler must give his people illegal wine for their Sabbaths, and marriage is illegal in the camps. These activities were forbidden because they directly correlated to resilience: Community kept people alive. The Nazis worked to destroy semblances of community so that they could implement their plans without resistance. For example, the OD were turned against their fellow Jewish community members with the promise that they and their families would be guaranteed safety for their betrayal. In the novel, the backstabbing behavior of Symche Spira and his men generates suspicion between people in the ghetto because the Nazis wish to fracture the community; Spira and his fellow OD members are executed when they’re no longer useful—that is, when they’ve served their purpose of fracturing the Jewish community. Community was both the source of resilience in the face of the Holocaust’s horrors and the first point of attack in the Nazis’ schemes.
The Holocaust’s perpetrators didn’t escape their atrocities unscathed, however. Keneally notes that “Every SS officer had friends who had committed suicide” (174). The higher Goeth climbs in the SS ranks, the more he has insomnia and drinks alcohol. Henry Rosner moves an unnamed SS guest of Goeth’s to death by suicide by playing a particularly depressing ballad. Death by suicide, trauma, and substance abuse mark the lives of every SS officer in the novel. Keneally notes that “death hung over the passions of the SS” (240), suggesting that even the Nazis themselves are incapable of coping with their atrocities. Goeth’s frequent, lavish parties keep him and the other SS men of Płaszów liquored up as a guard against the atrocities they commit daily. Nazis like Goeth, unlike the people they persecute, don’t have a solid community and communal traditions to turn to in their time of need. This results in maladaptive ways of dealing with the atrocities they personally inflict daily, the two most common maladaptive mechanisms being death by suicide and substance use. Keneally’s focus on the Nazis’ self-destructive tendencies suggests that their vision of the world is incapable of overpowering the communal resilience of minority groups.
By Thomas Keneally
Books Made into Movies
View Collection
Books on Justice & Injustice
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Good & Evil
View Collection
Guilt
View Collection
Hate & Anger
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
Immigrants & Refugees
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
International Holocaust Remembrance Day
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
Politics & Government
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
School Book List Titles
View Collection
Sexual Harassment & Violence
View Collection
Sociology
View Collection
The Booker Prizes Awardees & Honorees
View Collection
War
View Collection
World War II
View Collection