49 pages • 1 hour read
Neela Vaswani, Silas HouseA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Meena Joshi is short and skinny, 12 years old, and her skin resembles the “color of tea in a cup” (37). She came to New York three years ago from her mountain hometown in Mussoorie, India. Meena is a hard worker, doing laundry for her family and for Mrs. Lau, and constantly cleaning up after her brother, Kiku. She loves nature and animals, and she misses the mountains in Mussoorie almost as much as she misses Dadi, her grandmother. Her love for reading and writing inspires her to be a poet, and later a teacher, in honor of Dadi’s high regard for teachers.
Meena spent the majority of her childhood separated from her parents, and when she finally came to the US, she didn’t even know who to look for at the airport because she didn’t know what her parents looked like. She struggles with feeling abandoned by her family, and feels left out when they talk about memories from living in America before she joined them. At the same time, she feels she abandoned Dadi by leaving for America, and wishes her entire family could be together.
Throughout her correspondence with River, Meena describes her inner conflict between staying true to her Indian upbringing and adapting to life in America. She feels like her heart is torn in both directions, and she struggles with the concept of giving up loyalty to India when she becomes an American citizen. She wonders if she is her mother’s Indian daughter or American daughter, because she feels connected to both cultures. In a conversation with Mai, the citizenship class instructor, she learns that she can keep “a lot in her heart at once” (262) and honor both her Indian ancestry and American surroundings.
River Justice has red hair, freckles, and loves to play basketball in his small hometown of Black Banks, Kentucky. Just like Meena, he is 12 years old, loves and appreciates nature, and has a close relationship with his grandmother, Mawmaw. He feels he can tell Meena about things he would not tell his friends, such as the books he is reading and his goal to be a news reporter in the future.
Living in a mostly white community, River isn’t used to interacting with people who are different from him, and he changes throughout the course of the novel to become more culturally aware and respectful. For example, when he first tells Meena about Dr. Patel and his wife Chandra, the only Indian people in his community, he says Dr. Patel has a “funny” accent (25) and openly stares at Chandra’s bindi. However, after discovering his many similarities with Meena and learning more about Indian culture from her, he gains the confidence to talk to Chandra and becomes friends with her. By the end of the book, River learns that people are alike, no matter what skin color they have.
River also struggles throughout his correspondence with Meena to know how to stand up for his beliefs in a mature and effective way. When Sam calls him a name and he fights back, he learns that violence is not the best way to go about standing up for one’s beliefs. Later, when a man makes rude comments about Obama, he can’t muster the bravery or think of anything to say in return to assert his own opinion. However, at the march on the capital, River finally knows what to do. He courageously follows his instincts and approaches the governor with a simple invitation, which leads to the protest gaining national attention. River learns the value of speaking up for one’s beliefs, and he learns to do so without violence or disrespect.
Mawmaw, or Nellie Justice, is River’s fiery grandmother who is passionate about her beliefs and always stands up for what she thinks is right. As an interim mother figure for River, she treats him as an adult, and in turn, he respects her and learns from her. Mawmaw is an activist. She works with an organization to fight mountaintop removal in Black Banks, leads the march on the capitol, and states her opinions even when they are controversial. Even though she has differing political views from the majority of the community and receives ridicule, she doesn’t back down from her opinions.
Mawmaw teaches River to bravely stand up for his beliefs without using violence or putting others down, and is proud of him for coming to the march and confronting the governor in a simple way. She acts as a voice of wisdom throughout River’s letters to Meena, as he constantly repeats what “Mawmaw says” about a variety of subjects. At a pivotal stage in River’s development of his own opinions and beliefs, Mawmaw teaches him how to have courage and to fight for what he believes in. She embodies both kindness and toughness in her quest for justice.
Meena’s 17-year-old brother Kiku has been in New York much longer than Meena, and he helps her adjust to American culture. He plays her American music, tells her his secrets, and teaches her to talk like an American. However, Meena finds out for herself that sometimes his ideas about other people are wrong, such as the stereotype that all Southerners are racist.
Despite his occasional flaws, Kiku is a sweet older brother to Meena. He lets Meena borrow his razor to shave her legs because he understands what it feels like to be made fun of. He also takes her all over the city as a birthday present, and he treats her as a friend rather than a little sister.
Kiku knows just what to do to help Meena release her anger after Dadi dies. When he finds her sitting in the closet because she wants to be alone, he takes her to the subway platform and teaches her to scream as the train arrives to let go of some of her pent up grief and anger. It’s clear that he’s done this before, which suggests that he has faced his own struggles during his time in New York.
Kiku’s sweet nature towards Meena reveals his maturity as well as his desire to help her navigate life in America. Their unusually close sibling relationship suggests that being far away from home and immersed in a foreign culture brought them closer than they would have been within their own cultural comfort zone.
Meena’s elderly neighbor, Mrs. Lau, emigrated from Hong Kong and has lived in America for the majority of her life. She is kind to Meena and her family, letting them live in her son’s rent-controlled apartment without charging them any more than the rent-controlled amount.
Similar to Mawmaw in her opinionated and fiery spirit, Mrs. Lau is a grandmother figure and voice of wisdom for Meena, just as Mawmaw is for River. However, some differences exist between the two women as well. While Mawmaw is able to make her voice heard and stand up for what she believes in, Mrs. Lau’s position as an immigrant makes her vulnerable to being taken advantage of by others. The landlord exerts power over her by refusing to make necessary repairs on her apartment, but Mrs. Lau doesn’t have a way to stand up to him, since he could take away her home. Mrs. Lau’s living situation shows the way immigrants often do not have a voice to speak up for their rights. In contrast, Mawmaw, as a white woman, is able to make her voice heard.
By these authors