43 pages • 1 hour read
AristotleA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Aristotle was born in Northern Greece in 384 BCE. His origin story began in Macedonia where his father was a doctor. His father and mother died when Aristotle was young, and the boy was raised by his older sister. Little is known about Aristotle’s early years. In 367 B.C., Aristotle arrived in Athens to study under Plato, the Greek philosopher who had been a student of Socrates. Plato ran a school called the Academy. There, Aristotle was introduced to an education on forms and was encouraged to apply inquiry to the world around him. Along with his predecessor, Aristotle developed a reputation as one of the greatest scientific and philosophical thinkers in the Western world. However, Aristotle was not always granted the same access as his peers.
While in Athens, Aristotle could not participate in political activity due to resentment against Macedonians. The philosopher considered political action as a vital component of achieving happiness, yet he was barred from engaging in politics while living in Athens. Plato had taught a theoretical approach to thinking about politics, but Aristotle’s ideas contrasted with his teacher’s. He viewed political knowledge as practical rather than theoretical, believing that politics provided a key to enacting virtue. Before composing the theories found in Politics, the philosopher traveled around Greece and gathered data from over 150 Greek cities. His observations influenced his theoretical framework. Aristotle’s type of data collection was an innovative approach to philosophy and theory.
Although Aristotle was not selected as Plato’s successor, the philosopher left an impression on everyone around him. After Plato’s death, Aristotle started his own school called the Lyceum. Aristotle was known for walking through the garden with his students, delivering lectures that combined science and philosophy. Aristotle tutored the son of King Philip II, who later became known as Alexander the Great.
Aristotle fled Greece in 323 BCE when anti-Macedonian sentiments put his life in danger. He died a year later and was buried next to his wife. Aristotle’s Politics is a continuation of his lectures detailed in Nicomachean Ethics. In both, the philosopher argues that the purpose of life is to achieve happiness through a virtuous life. He also suggests that moderation is imperative in both personal and political life, with virtue being the mean between two vices (sometimes referred to as “the golden mean”). Similarly, Aristotle argues that a political constitution should incorporate elements from other constitutions to ensure stability and permanence.
Aristotle’s theories about politics were in stark contrast to Plato’s, who emphasized communal politics and who favored theoretical principles over pragmatism. Aristotle developed a philosophy which sought to provide practical guidelines for how to develop a government that would present maximum benefit. His work discusses the theories and practical implications of those ideas, including ideal population numbers and how to conduct communal meals. Politics still resonates today, with the philosopher’s outline of political structures providing the foundation for modern political philosophy.
Plato was a philosopher who lived during the fourth century BCE in Greece. Plato was a student of Socrates, and Aristotle in turn was a student of Plato. Unlike Aristotle, Plato was a member of the Athenian aristocracy and enjoyed the full rights of free citizenship in Athens. Plato founded the Academy in Athens, an educational institution that provided the foundation for philosophy, science, theology, and many other fields of study. The Academy lasted for several hundred years and remains the ancient blueprint of modern-day universities.
Plato is well-known for introducing several famous concepts into philosophy, such as the ideal of the “Philosopher king” in the Republic and the allegory of the Cave, in which people prefer the shadows of their delusions to the light of reason and reality. His works use the “Socratic” dialogue style, in which characters engage in philosophical debate through a series of questions and answers on different themes, usually with the figure of Socrates at the center. When Aristotle refers to “Socrates” in Plato’s works, he is referring more to Plato’s depiction of Socrates in the dialogues than the historical figure. Plato’s philosophy also posits the existence of abstract objects which operate apart from the senses, including mathematical theories. Plato’s influence has endured for millennia since his own time; he is often hailed as the true founder of the Western philosophical tradition.
Although Aristotle studied at the Academy for many years, he ultimately diverged from Plato’s theoretical and abstract approaches, focusing instead on the practical side of philosophy. He also differed from Plato in terms of political philosophy, rejecting Plato’s support for communalism and greater gender equality in the Republic in favor of more conservative forms of government and social hierarchies.
Ernest Barker (1874-1960) was the Principal of King’s College London in 1920 and fulfilled the position of Professor of Political Science at Cambridge between 1928 and 1939. Barker provided the translation of Politics for the Oxford University Press edition that was republished in 2009. The British political scientist was born in Cheshire and was the first to hold the chair of Professor of Political Science at Cambridge. He served on the Liberal Party Council and had five children.
Barker contributed a mountain of important works to the study of political science, including his translations for The Republic of Plato and The Political Thought of Plato and Aristotle. Barker’s text Greek Political Theory: Plato and His Predecessors boasts 170 editions published between 1917 and 2010 and has been translated into five languages. His translation of Politics, which is used in this study guide, has been published in 37 editions between 1946 and 2020.
R. F. Stalley was the Frank Knox Memorial Fellow at Harvard and studied Classics and Philosophy at Oxford. Stalley was also an instructor of philosophy at the University of Glasgow. The writer presents the introduction which accompanies the Oxford University Press edition of Politics, translated by Ernest Barker. Stalley has also written An Introduction to Plato’s Laws.
By Aristotle