logo

56 pages 1 hour read

Stephanie Garber

Once Upon a Broken Heart

Fiction | Novel | YA | Published in 2021

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Part 3, Chapters 43-45Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 3, Chapter 43 Summary

Jacks insists Evangeline run and leave him, but she refuses to abandon him like this. They run through the night until they find a mausoleum covered in angel’s tears flowers, which should protect Evangeline from Jacks and the other hunting changelings. Inside, Jacks tells Evangeline to use her blood to open a locked gate, which works, surprising her. Jacks passes through and closes the gate, which relocks with a tiny click. Evangeline is painfully aware how flimsy the lock seems compared to Jacks’s strength, and Jacks stares at the lock like a thief who’s “contemplating all the ways he could break it” (318).

Part 3, Chapter 44 Summary

To distract Jacks from wanting to bite her, Evangeline asks him what happened with Princess Donatella. Reluctantly, Jacks explains that he wanted something from Donatella and kissed her to get it. He slowed Donatella’s heart so she wouldn’t die immediately, but Donatella still should have died but didn’t because Jacks’s heart started beating as a result of the kiss. Rather than being Jacks’s true love, Donatella fell in love with someone else and stabbed Jacks with his own knife. Even so, the thought of Jacks kissing someone else makes “something painful wrench inside of Evangeline” (321).

Evangeline tries to comfort Jacks with the idea of a different true love. Jacks mockingly asks if she wants to be that love, and heat floods her body. Instead of answering, Evangeline tells him about Luc and how she grew to love him quietly. Jacks doesn’t believe Luc would be well-suited to Evangeline. After Evangeline drank the poison at Luc and Marisol’s wedding, instructions to break her stone curse would have appeared on the cup, and Luc didn’t save Evangeline then. To cover her hurt, Evangeline lashes out at Jacks for being purposefully cruel. Jacks tosses her his dagger, telling her that, if she’s not jealous, she should use it, and then he snaps the gate’s lock in half.

Part 3, Chapter 45 Summary

In a flash, Jacks is pressed against her, removing the cape she wears and stroking her skin with his hands and lips. Evangeline fights the growing attraction inside her while she tries to push him away before he bites her. She reminds him about the Valory Arch, and Jacks stops trying to bite her but doesn’t release the embrace. After a while, Evangeline notices Jacks isn’t burning hot anymore and looks up to see the sun has risen, breaking the vampire venom’s hold on him.

Jacks detangles from her and retrieves her cape. He affects an indifferent air as he refastens it around her shoulders, but Evangeline feels “the soft brush of his fingertips lingering against her neck” (335). He stalks out of the mausoleum, leaving his dagger behind. Evangeline takes the blade, not knowing why she wants it.

Evangeline suggests they return to Apollo’s palace to find out if Marisol killed the prince. Jacks tries to argue but is overcome by unnatural exhaustion. He sags against a tree that’s covered with new wanted posters accusing Evangeline of murdering Apollo. Desperate to find a safe place, Evangeline drags a drooping Jacks back to town and staggers around lost until she hears an insistent bell ringing. Hoping the bell is trying to help her, Evangeline uses her blood to open the door beneath it before dragging Jacks inside. She comments how lucky he is that she’s there, to which Jacks says luck had nothing to do with it and drunkenly asks who Evangeline thought convinced the empress and princess to send her north.

Part 3, Chapters 43-45 Analysis

Evangeline uses her blood to open the gate in Chapter 43, which is the first time she realizes her blood has power. In Chapter 1, she pricked her finger trying to pry open the door to Jacks’s church. At the time, she thought she strong-armed it open, but it was her blood that unlocked the door. These incidences are more foreshadowing that she can open the Valory Arch, and they leave open questions about her parents and the magic in her blood.

The Prince of Hearts’s legend states that his heart will only beat again after he kisses his true love. Since Donatella fell in love with someone else, she is likely not Jacks’s true love, but it is never explained how she survived his kiss. Since Jacks’s heart started beating, it may be that his kiss is no longer poisonous. Jacks’s burning attraction to Evangeline suggests she is his true love. Even if the vampire venom is affecting him, he’s shown moments of tenderness and attraction toward her before, and the venom is likely only amplifying those feelings. After their intense embrace, the brush of his fingers against her neck shows he cares about her, even as he tries to hide it. It may also be that the angel’s tears blossoms kept Jacks from biting Evangeline.

Jacks’s revelations about Luc in Chapter 44 seem to be proof Luc never loved Evangeline. It may also be that Jacks uses cruelty to unsettle those around him so they’ll let down their guard and make mistakes. If Luc’s telling of events is true, he was still under a love spell even after he was turned to stone. He may have truly loved Evangeline, but the spell Marisol placed on him might have kept him from drinking the poison to rescue Evangeline.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text