Miss Hinch

Harrison spent many years as a journalist. In what ways does this experience inform the use of journalism in “Miss Hinch” and its characters? Use the text to support your assertion.

Harrison draws on gender stereotypes to misdirect the reader. In what ways do Jessie Dark and Miss Hinch subvert traditional women’s roles? How would their lives be different in a less gender constrictive society?

The old man in the train car asserts that “it is not professional pride that makes Jessie Dark so resolute to win. It’s sex jealousy, if you follow me—no offense, madam! Yes, sir! Women never have the slightest respect for each other’s abilities—not the slightest,” and further, “No mercy for each other, either! I tell you, Jessie Dark’d be ashamed to be beaten by another woman” (562). Do you agree with his judgment of Jessie’s motivation? Why or why not? Use the text to support your argument.

Harrison uses a third-person narrative to tell the story of Miss Hinch. How does this affect the exposition of the story? Upon a second reading of the story, what does characterization reveal about the motives and thoughts of the main characters in the early scenes of the story?

How does the setting of the subway train contribute to the story? Which plot elements would be different if the story occurred on the streets above?

Dark’s talent for catching women is due partly to her sympathy with and understanding of her quarry. Using textual examples, cite other traits or characteristics that contribute to her success as a detective.

Harrison creates an atmosphere of suspicion throughout the story, affecting the mood. Cite textual examples that show how Harrison establishes the mood of suspicion and paranoia.

Write a character analysis of Miss Hinch. How does your perception of her change as the narrative progresses?