65 pages • 2 hours read
John Dudley BallA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Virgil visits Jess, the Black mechanic who loaned him a car. Virgil hopes the case will wrap up soon, and Jess invites him in for dinner. Virgil resists, but Jess wants Virgil to meet his 13-year-old son, Andy, who has never met a detective, let alone a Black one. At dinner, Andy watches Virgil intensely, fascinated. He asks about Virgil’s first case. Virgil helped catch heroin dealers in Pasadena by disguising himself as a shoeshine man. Andy is delighted that being Black helped Virgil catch the criminals: ‘“No one expected a Negro in a job like that to be a police officer.’ ‘So if’n you’d been white, you couldn’t of done it!’ the boy burst out” (113). Andy remains fixated on Virgil for the rest of dinner in awe.
Virgil walks to his car after dinner, mulling over the case. Suddenly, two men emerge from behind him and attack. One man tries to strike Virgil with a piece of wood, but Virgil blocks the attack and twists the man’s wrist; then he subdues the other man. Andy and Jess arrive to help, and they call the police and a doctor. Virgil wants to press charges, but the officers that arrive to the scene are confused that a Black man is trying to charge two white men with assault. At the station, Bill berates the attackers, but they aren’t worried; this city would never prosecute white men for attacking a Black man. Virgil leaves to resume his detective duties, but Bill stops him, worried Virgil might be killed if he stays in Wells. Virgil senses Bill is genuinely concerned, but refuses to leave town before the killer is apprehended.
Virgil visits the Purdys. Delores calls him a racist slur, but Virgil stands his ground: ‘“N*****s go to the back door,’ she snapped. ‘This one doesn’t,’ Tibbs said” (117-18). Mr. Purdy is likewise rude, but Virgil stays steadfast. He informs them of the medical tests Delores will need to prove her accusations against Sam. The Purdys are skeptical. Delores recounts her story again for Virgil and repeats that Sam statutorily raped her. Done with his questioning, Virgil leaves, moving at a frantic pace. He’s ready to present his evidence to Bill.
Duena becomes determined to help Sam clear his name. She convinces Mr. Endicott to take her to see the mayor. The mayor speaks bluntly about the fickle economy in the South and his hopes that the music festival will attract tourism. He confesses they hired Bill hoping he’d maintain the segregated traditions of the city, and that if the case doesn’t get resolved soon, the council will fire Bill. Unsatisfied, Duena goes to the police station. Meanwhile, Virgil visits Sam in his cell. Virgil promises he won’t leave town until he clears Sam’s name and catches the killer. Sam, while still prejudiced toward Black people, accepts that Virgil is an ally: “Then Sam reflected that at least the man whose race had created a barrier he had found almost impossible to climb was on his side. That was a comforting thought” (128). Virgil asks Sam clarifying questions about the night of the murder and heads to Bill’s office.
Duena, Mr. Endicott, and Virgil all arrive at Bill’s office at the same time. Bill dismisses Virgil, but Virgil pushes to stay, claiming he has important information everyone should hear. Bill angrily reacts when his authority is called into question: “Gillespie raised his fist to bang it on his desk. Backtalk he would not take from anyone, least of all a man who stood on the wrong side of the color line” (129). Mr. Endicott, however, insists that Virgil speak. Virgil asks that Sam be present, and then Virgil briefs everyone about his investigation into the charges against Sam. Delores is known to expose herself to men. When Delores became pregnant, she accused Sam, hoping he’d be forced to marry her because Sam has a good job and would be an enviable husband compared to the other men Delores has been with. Virgil’s logic is flawless. He just needs to prove it with tangible evidence.
Delores and Mr. Purdy arrive. Surrounded by everyone in Bill’s office, Delores admits that she made a mistake by accusing Sam—he didn’t do anything to her. She claims she dreamt up her encounter with Sam, sparked by him being single with a good job. She apologizes to Sam and leaves with her father. Before clearing Sam of all charges, Bill wants to know how Sam paid off his mortgage in cash. Virgil chimes in with an explanation. Sam paid with coins—money he’d been saving since joining the police force—proving he didn’t kill Enrico and use the stolen money. Sam is reinstated, and Virgil asks him to go on a patrol that same night. They’ll go together. If everything goes according to plan, they’ll catch the murderer.
Virgil has spent most of the novel calm and collected, despite how racist Wells is, demonstrating his deft detective skills, but revealing less about his character than the world around him. In Chapters 11-12, Virgil finally snaps, showing more of his personality. When Delores tries to make Virgil enter through the back of the house, Virgil demands respect and goes through the front. Inside, Mr. Purdy treats Virgil derogatorily, but Virgil puts the man in his place: ”‘I’ve had about all I’m going to take of ignorant back talk from you or anybody else. You came in and filed charges; I’m here to talk about them’” (118). Earlier in the story, Virgil often responded to racism quietly and passively, choosing to take the higher ground. The Purdys’ low socio-economic standing allows Virgil to react more naturally to their racist comments and behavior—he has leverage and power in this interaction.
The novel further develops several minor Black characters, giving a slightly fully picture of the Black community in Wells. We encounter the helpful and cooperative Reverend Whiteburn, a Black authority figure who acts as a foil for the obstructionist white council members and mayor. We also see the domestic life of Jess, a car mechanic who introduces his son Andy to Virgil in an attempt to give the boy a heroic, upstanding example of Black excellence. This family is functional, loving, and deeply empathetic, coming to Virgil’s aid when two white men attack him. As father and son, Jess and Andy provide a useful counterpart to the Purdys, the racist, dysfunctional family eager to entrap Sam into marriage. These two families also develop Ball’s commentary on class. Jess and his family are welcoming to Virgil. Despite not having much money or food, they’re hospitable and welcoming. The Purdys, another impoverished family, are bigoted, spiteful, and superstitious.
The novel is less nuanced in its treatment of women. There are only two somewhat substantial female characters—Delores and Duena—young women who almost literally fall into the virgin/whore dichotomy. Duena is pure, beautiful, and classy; Delores is slutty, conniving, and sexually tainted. Both function primarily to ensnare Sam in different ways, and have little of their own agency, inner life, or purpose outside of being a target for Sam’s appropriate or inappropriate sexual desire.
Ball continues utilizing dramatic chapter breaks to maintain the story’s momentum. Chapter 11 ends with Virgil heading toward the police station, ready to prove Sam is innocent, leaving the reader to start the next chapter to see if Virgil can pull it off. Chapter 12 ramps up the drama even more, ending with Virgil stating that they’ll catch the killer tonight: “Unless something radical happens, before morning Mr. Wood will arrest the murderer of Enrico Mantoli” (135). The closing lines of each chapter promise that, soon, the mystery will be solved.