54 pages • 1 hour read
Sutton E. GriggsA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This text contains racist language, including racial expletives, and violence, as well as depictions of oppression, enslavement, and death by suicide. This study guide quotes and obscures the author’s use of the n-word.
One motif of the text is the dangerous yet humorous situations that Belton gets into through his own choices, which are exacerbated by the institutionalized racism and injustice of the time. Two such examples—Belton getting caught in the chicken coop spying on the teachers and the dirty sock in his pocket at graduation—are brought about by actions that Belton takes, which could be considered foolish, giving them ironic humor, but which serve to explore themes and teach lessons to Belton, ultimately developing his character into a tragic hero.
In the first incident, Belton discovers that there is a Black teacher who is vice president, holding some power over the other teachers. In order to listen in on their meeting and see this for himself, he sneaks up to the window to watch. The incident is described in a humorous way, with the woman throwing “up her hands and scream[ing] loudly from fright,” and Belton turning to flee and “unthinkingly jump[ing] into the chicken house” (20). Despite the humorous way it is written, the situation is rather dangerous for Belton, as he is a young Black man outside a window at night, listening in on a meeting of mostly white women. Stressed by the narrator is the reaction of the teachers; instead of being afraid or angry, he writes that they “laughed heartily at their fright and resumed deliberations [and assume] a race that dreams of freedom, equality, and empire, far more than is imagined, is […] a race of chicken thieves” (21). In other words, this incident serves to not only provide comedic relief, but also to show the way in which educated white men see Black people. They are ignored to their desire for equality and their dreams, and instead treat them simply as “chicken thieves.”
In the next, Belton is set to give a graduation speech, but his jealous roommate decides to replace his handkerchief with a dirty sock. The boy from whom the roommate steals the sock is described as “noted for his immense height and for the size and scent of his feet,” which are “exceedingly offensive” (25). When the roommate goes to steal the socks, the situation is described in a humorous way, as the student takes off his socks in an effort to get the roommate to leave, and even pretends to snore loudly, but eventually gives up “the battle in disgust” (27), allowing the roommate to steal the sock. This situation, as well as the way that Belton is seen pulling a dirty sock from his coat to wipe his eyes, is humorous to the reader. However, it also serves a larger purpose, as he attributes the prank to his “revengeful act that he had perpetrated upon his first teacher […] com[ing] home to roost” (40). When the president comes to visit Belton, he stresses the importance of not seeking revenge and instead leaving it to God, an important lesson in the text that would again be used when Belton votes against Bernard’s plan in the Imperium.
The motif of Belton’s humorous missteps is used throughout the text, especially in these two incidents, to add comedic relief to the text but also to convey larger themes and lessons for Belton. In addition to these, other incidents—such as his efforts to help a white woman in church leading to his lynching or reading in the first class of a train only to be angrily thrown off by a group of white men—contain both humor and irony and work together to portray Belton as a tragic hero. No matter how intelligent, hardworking, or honorable he is, luck and happenstance, in addition to downright racism, regularly throw his life off course, yet he is determined to remain faithful to humanity and harmony among white and Black people.
Throughout the text, the motif of flags represents not only the idea of pride and nationhood, but also honor and dignity, as well as the absence of such things. For example, Belton writes of educated Black people that they “grew to hate a flag that would float in an undisturbed manner over such a condition of affairs” (47). In other words, educated Black men learned of the Constitution and the nation’s Founding Fathers and the equality that was promised to them, yet having been denied it through institutionalized racism, they began to detest the hypocrisy of the country, and therefore the flag and what it is supposed to represent. In another instance, after Belton believes his wife has committed adultery, he contemplates his feelings toward her and his country, noting that “he loved her still if anything, more passionately than ever. But ah! what were his feelings in those days toward the flag which he had loved so dearly, which had floated proudly and undisturbed, while color prejudice [is] upheld by it” (49). In comparing his feelings toward his wife and his country, he notes that both have done him wrong, his wife through adultery and the nation for not upholding his promise of equality, yet he still loves them both dearly.
Additionally, in the opening letter of the text from Berl Trout, he writes, “fifty feet from the well into which my body is lowered, a red flag is to be hoisted and kept floating there for time unending, warning all generations of men to come not near the air polluted by the rotting carcass of a vile traitor” (v). Because of his actions in revealing the Imperium, he will lose the honor of a nation’s flag at his grave, and instead will be marked by a red one. Conversely, in his closing letter, he writes that Belton was buried wrapped in an American flag. Unlike Berl, Belton’s decision to die honorably in leaving the Imperium instead of exposing it allowed him an honorable death with the nation’s flag.
These instances convey the importance of the American flag to Black people. For them, like all Americans, it represents liberty, freedom, and equality and deserves the love and respect of its people in return. However, throughout the novel, as racial prejudice is revealed and these men regularly fail to achieve its promised equality, they begin to question their devotion to the flag and their nation.
Mr. Leonard is a representation of corruption and the broken systems in the United States. Throughout high school, he torments Belton, largely because of the color of his skin. However, it is later revealed through Bernard’s father that his deeper motivation was to help Bernard. He takes the position as teacher at the all-Black school simply to protect his own secrets and the fact that he had traitorously murdered his commander during the Civil War. The system represented in the novel is so corrupt that even Bernard—an intelligent, lighter-skinned Black man who is valedictorian of Harvard—is unable to succeed of his own merit. Instead, he relies on Mr. Leonard, who is unafraid to use corruption in turn to beat the broken system. For example, when Bernard attempts to run for Congress, despite winning the vote in his district, he is still declared the winner. Through bribery of officials, Mr. Leonard can uncover this fact and overturn the election. It is only through other forms of lies, deception, and corruption that a corrupt system can be defeated, and Mr. Leonard is a representation of this fact in the text.