88 pages • 2 hours read
Alan GratzA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
Brandon wakes up on the watery floor. He cannot see and thinks he has gone blind. He calls for Richard, but no one answers. Brandon cries because he is all alone. He thinks that he is “better off dead” (234), but then he thinks about how he has survived and needs to keep going. When he gets up, he cuts his hand on a piece of glass. He calls for Richard again and hears a moan. He bandages his hand with a t-shirt and goes towards the person. He feels around in the dark and accidentally grabs something: the Wolverine claws he wanted to buy that morning. He believes he is alive because of the toy; he left the 107th floor to buy them and would have died otherwise. He finds the person moaning, but it is not Richard. The man, Pratik, says he cannot see, and they both realize that they are not blind, just in complete darkness. They hear a woman ask for help and pull her along with them. Another man groans, but he is injured beyond saving. Brandon keeps calling for Richard. He hears “This Land Is Your Land” and knows it must be him.
Reshmina wakes up. Her grandmother is singing the song “Momardene Afghane.” Reshmina finds her way to her grandmother, and soon so do other family members and neighbors. It is pitch black, and Reshmina tries to turn on the flashlight in her pocket. Taz can see a little bit of the light. Reshmina has a cut on her hand from the explosion. Taz gives her Kerlix, a kind of gauze. He says she may still get a scar and shows her the scar on his hand. He says, “‘It still aches every now and then, when it’s cold and gloomy outside […] But most of the time…’ Taz paused, as though what he was saying brought back a painful memory for him. ‘But most of the time you just forget it’s there,’ he finished” (244).
Part of the cave collapsed in the explosion, and Reshmina is worried that everyone in that part of the cave has been killed. She throws a rock at Taz and yells at him, blaming him and all Americans. She tells him to leave Afghanistan. Taz says that the Americans are trying to help and that if the United States does leave, the Taliban will rule the country again. She tells him that the United States has been in Afghanistan for 20 years and still cannot defeat the Taliban. She asks again why they are even there. Her little brother, Zahir, crawls away and finds a hole. Reshmina thinks they may be able to escape the cave.
Brandon and the two others pull Richard out of the debris. They all hold onto each other to move through the dark to find the exit. He smells bananas and pink grapefruit and tells the others that they are by the Body Shop and going the wrong way. He trips and picks up a stuffed animal. He feels the thing he tripped on and realizes it is Bugs Bunny and they are outside of the Warner Bros. Store, the right way to the exit. A cellphone rings repeatedly, but the owner never answers it. They pass the Sbarro, reach the stairs, and exit on Vesey Street. Their celebration does not last long because they quickly realize that “it looked like somebody had driven a tank through the city” (256), and there is no one around. The South Tower is gone.
Reshmina pushes herself through the hole and finds herself in another room. She is frightened by an Ancient Greek statue. There are other artifacts there from every time Afghanistan was occupied by another country. She hears Taz singing a song that repeats, “We’re here because we’re here” (259). He tells her that it is a song soldiers sang in World War I because they did not know why they were fighting in the war. He says, “I think we’re still in Afghanistan because we got in, and we don’t know how to get out” (260). Reshmina looks around at all the artifacts and thinks the room represents all the failed attempts to conquer and rule Afghanistan.
She sees a crack with a small amount of light coming through. She takes a Soviet mine from the artifacts to blow open the wall. She throws a statue of Lenin at the mine to set it off. She misses, but an explosion above loosens rocks that set off the mine. She is thrown by the blast.
Brandon stares at the place where the South Tower should be. He thinks the tower falling is what caused the blast in the basement. The North Tower is still consumed by smoke. There are people jumping out of it, away from the smoke and towards the ground. Brandon wants to try calling his dad again, but Richard says they should go to his house first. An EMT gives them masks and tells them that the dust they see covering everything is toxic. The EMT properly bandages Brandon’s wounded hand. In his other hand is the stuffed animal he grabbed in the mall, a Tasmanian Devil. Richard tells him it must be lucky and Brandon should keep it.
The top floors of the North Tower start to collapse. Richard tells Brandon to run. This is the scariest thing Brandon has experienced all day because “the thing that had killed his father was coming for him, chasing him like a giant monster through the streets of Manhattan” (270). The blast tosses and throws him. He calls for Richard and finds him unresponsive. Richard reaches his arm out for Brandon and they hold hands, weeping.
Reshmina awakes and asks what happened. Taz tells her that the mine blew a hole in the wall and people were able to escape the cave. He had to take off and leave his belt with Army equipment to fit through the hole, and Reshmina thinks how it is “[o]ne more artifact for the shrine to failed conquerors” (274). Taz tells her that his eyesight is starting to come back. There are American and Afghan soldiers helping the injured. Baba arrives, and Reshmina is thrilled to see that he is alive. He asks where Pasoon is, and Reshmina tells him.
She worries that all the villagers are dead because of her actions that day. Baba shows her that almost everyone did survive, and her actions saved them. Taz talks to another soldier, Carter, about how it is September 11. Reshmina says she has never heard of 9/11 or the World Trade Center. Taz and Carter are in disbelief. Taz says that 9/11 is why he and the rest of the Americans are in Afghanistan. He shows her a picture of the Twin Towers, but she does not recognize them. Her parents have also never heard of 9/11. No one in the village has. Taz gets irritated and tells her his dad died that day, along with 3,000 others. He says his dad’s name was Leo Chavez. Reshmina is confused because his uniform says Lowery, not Chavez. Brandon says Lowery is his adopted name; he was adopted by Richard Lowery.
Reshmina understands that the Americans are in Afghanistan for badal, revenge. She asks Taz if the Taliban were the ones who attacked the Unit States. He explains it was not them, it was al Qaeda, but the leader of al Qaeda, Osama bin Laden, lived in Afghanistan. The United States invaded to find him. Reshmina is angry because the United States has destroyed more buildings and lives than al Qaeda did, and al Qaeda was not even from Afghanistan. She is even angrier when she learns that bin Laden was captured and killed over 10 years ago. She says that America makes its “own rules” (281).
Carter gets a call on his radio, and he orders a helicopter to strike. The missile destroys a house, and then each house below it crumbles and is destroyed. The village is gone.
Brandon and Richard walk to Richard’s house. They walk across the Brooklyn Bridge with other distraught people leaving Manhattan. Holding hands, they finally reach Richard’s house, where his family greats them. He has a wife, a dog, and two kids. Richard tells his wife, Talisha, that Brandon saved his life. Talisha brings Brandon to the bathroom so he can take a shower. Brandon is uneasy now that he is not fighting for his survival and “didn’t know what to do with himself” (287). After his shower he puts on Richard’s too-big clothes. Brandon calls his apartment and listens to the recording of his dad and himself. He leaves a message for his dad, even though he knows his dad will never hear it. He tells his dad he is okay and can call him back. He tells him he loves him and goodbye.
Brandon cries in the bathroom and then watches TV with Richard’s family. They learn that the planes were hijacked by terrorists and that the place where the Twin Towers once stood is being called Ground Zero. There was a third plane that was flown into the Pentagon, and a fourth that the passengers crashed themselves into an open field in Pennsylvania, knowing terrorists had taken control of it. Richard tells Brandon that no one at his school will understand the way he does since he lived it. They listen to President Bush, and both want revenge against whoever did it. Brandon feels alone but thinks of all the people he helped and had been helped by that day. He decides that we all survive by doing things for each other.
Reshmina is digging through the remains of the village with Baba, saving anything useful they can find. Taz brings her blankets and food. He asks her if she will go to Pakistan like many of the other villagers have. She says they will stay and rebuild, but she thinks it is pointless because the Americans or another army will ruin it again. She asks if the Twin Towers were ever rebuilt, and Taz says yes, but as one big tower. He offers to stay and help rebuild. Reshmina angrily complains how America just gives them money after the Army has killed someone or destroyed something. She says money is worthless to them anyway because they cannot spend it anywhere. Reshmina says America should leave. Taz tells her that it should be “all of us, together. For each other” (299). Reshmina replies that no one can be “for” them if they are “rebuilding villages and destroying them at the same time” (299). Taz reflects on the aftermath of 9/11 and how he joined the Army wanting revenge. He wonders if he and America have become the type of bully his dad warned him about. He says he may leave the Army and invites Reshmina to join an interpreter program through the Army. She declines because she wants to follow her own path. Taz promises to return some day and gives Reshmina his stuffed animal.
Reshmina says goodbye to Taz and walks down a difficult path of debris with Baba. She sees Pasoon in the distance. She is happy he is alive but does not return the wave he gives her. She tells Baba she sees a new path.
These chapters depict the complicated political situation of the US occupation of Afghanistan. Through the lyrics “We’re here because we’re here,” and the argument between Reshmina, Brandon, and Carter, Gratz suggests that there is no real reason why the United States is in Afghanistan. Carter represents a cocky, militaristic attitude based on the belief that America is the exception and can do whatever it wants. Taz becomes doubtful that he is doing the right thing. As young Brandon, he concludes that we have to be “for each other” (294), but as Taz he does not feel that he is upholding that. He promises Reshmina that he will “come back and help” (302), showing that he wants to be a force for good.
Reshmina considers her village a “ground zero.” This phrase reflects the complete destruction of her village, the same way the World Trade Center was completely destroyed. However, the World Trade Center was rebuilt as “one new giant skyscraper” and did not remain as ground zero (297). There is some implication, then, that it is possible for Reshmina’s village to be rebuilt. The novel ends on a hopeful note with Reshmina saying she “found another path” (304). By rejecting violence and revenge, and focusing on rebuilding and the future, Reshmina has some hope.
By Alan Gratz
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Books that Teach Empathy
View Collection
Coping with Death
View Collection
Juvenile Literature
View Collection
Memorial Day Reads
View Collection
Military Reads
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (High School)
View Collection
Realistic Fiction (Middle Grade)
View Collection
Revenge
View Collection
September 11
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection
War
View Collection