72 pages • 2 hours read
Frank HerbertA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
In a prologue set centuries after the novel’s events, archaeologist Hadi Benotto reveals the discovery of original journals and audio recordings of the late God Emperor Leto Atreides II. The writings have been decrypted using the same Guild Key that deciphered The Stolen Journals, the classic text attributed to Leto and translated by the Spacing Guild centuries before. Leto was the last Emperor of the Imperium, and like his father, Paul Muad’Dib, he had the cognitive powers of a Kwisatz Haderach—a term used by the religious society known as the Bene Gesserit to denote a kind of messiah, one who possesses both universal prescience and ancestral memories. In the discovered writings, Leto describes his disorientating experiences of prescience and the acuity and magnitude of his awareness across space and time. He is both himself, the singular Leto, and all the threads of his ancestors’ memories. Although these memories are valuable, Leto wearies of their repetitious sameness and relegates these moments to “only the past” (5).
The central action in the novel takes place at the end of Leto’s millennia-long reign, roughly 3,500 years after the events of Children of Dune. Most chapters begin with an epigraph from The Stolen Journals followed by events documented in the excavated journals. Chapter 1 opens with an epigraph from The Stolen Journals where Leto describes his various incarnations and laments the loss of vigor in his present surroundings.
Siona is a descendant of the Atreides and the Fremen—a desert people of the planet Arrakis, long ago known as Dune. The Fremen of antiquity had worshipped Leto’s father as a messiah, but Siona and her compatriots view Leto II as a tyrant. Leto has reigned for 3,500 years and has terraformed the former desert planet into a verdant habitat. The sandworms that produce spice have died out, and Leto hoards what remains of the highly prized commodity to maintain his power. Siona’s rebels are thousands of years removed from their heritage as desert dwellers. However, they still retain Fremen traditions of loyalty and perseverance, which they learn from books and commodified versions of their culture proffered by “Museum Fremen” (6).
Siona and her team of rebels steal plans to Leto’s Citadel to uncover his stockpile of spice, also known as melange. Leto’s fortress is in The Last Desert of the Sareer, and along with the plans, the rebels steal two texts that will become known as The Stolen Journals. D-wolves, Leto’s monster guardians, attack and kill Siona’s last remaining companions, but she manages to escape. Siona remembers her companions who have died and vows to personally avenge their deaths and destroy Leto.
The chapter ends with two excerpts: one from the Benotto translation of the excavated journals, and the other a transcript of a dialogue between Siona and her father, Moneo.
In the excerpt from the excavated journals, Leto recalls his lineage and asserts that his rule brings peace and creates the conditions that will allow humanity to survive. This “Golden Path,” a course outlined in his prescient mind to prevent human extinction, required that he transform himself from a human into a sandworm to attain longevity and ultimate control over the production of spice, the sandworm’s byproduct. Leto initiated his transformation at the end of the third book, Children of Dune. At the beginning of God Emperor of Dune, he is in the “pre-worm” (19) stage of his metamorphosis. Leto’s lower limbs have atrophied, and he has silvery arms and hands below his face, the only remaining human skin exposed. At five tons and seven meters long, Leto is covered with interconnecting sandtrout, the larval stage of the sandworm’s life cycle. The sandtrout continue to merge with his body, eventually transforming him into the giant sandworm the Fremen call Shai-Hulud or “the God of the desert” (23).
Leto explains that his absolute rule has kept former competing powers in check for the past three millennia. The Spacing Guild, who rely on the spice for navigation, and the Bene Gesserit, a clandestine sisterhood who require the spice for the ritual that allows them to access ancestral consciousness, are both at Leto’s mercy. Leto also describes the Ixians, inhabitants of the planet Ix who are known for their technological innovations. Leto uses Ixian machines such as the dictate, a device that records his thoughts on paper, and the Royal Cart, a vehicle customized for his body. Although he has the power to foretell the future, Leto chooses to not predict when his final transformation into a giant sandworm will occur, comparing the impending change to death. Leto records that he witnessed Siona stealing his journals and refrained from interfering.
The excerpt from Siona and her father’s conversation takes place when Siona was a young student at the Fish Speakers’ School, an institution that trains soldiers for Leto’s all-female armies. Moneo serves as a majordomo to Leto II and refutes his daughter's claim that Leto is a murderer. Moneo believes that the Worm part of Leto is God and has the authority to kill. In contrast, Siona believes that Leto is a false deity and refuses to regard his hybrid form as the true God of the Desert.
In an epigraph from The Stolen Journals, Leto watches a Fremen, a fifth-generation descendant of his father’s esteemed ally, Stilgar, and laments how the contemporary Fremen lack the perception and skills of their ancestors.
Leto meets with his Commander of the Royal Guard, Duncan Idaho. Duncan is a ghola, a duplicate regrown by the Tleilaxu from the remains of the original Idaho, who died serving House Atreides under Leto’s grandfather. Leto refers to each version as “the Duncan” and recounts how many of them have attempted to resist his absolute rule and assassinate him. Leto suspects the current Duncan plans to kill him and relishes the idea of being surprised. Duncan warns him that rebellions are dangerous and require suppression. Leto regards Duncan’s views as tedious, arguing that radicals are ordinary and simple-minded in their dichotomous views of good and evil. He views rebels as hypocrites who merely repeat old patterns of domination, asserting that even the promise of a benevolent messiah, such as his father, only ends in failure. As Leto suspects, Duncan attempts to kill him with a lasgun, and Leto leaps from his Royal Cart and crushes Duncan to death.
In an epigraph from The Stolen Journals, Leto describes his wonder at the people and landscapes he has encountered in his inward travels and the transience of human life.
In the City of Onn, Leto’s spy, Nayla, sends an encrypted message that reports on Siona’s activities. Nayla types the message on a hidden screen in a wall. She also has a device implanted in her head for direct communication with Leto. Although the decree known as the Great Convention has banned “thinking machines”—computers and other devices that mimic the human mind—since the ancient Butlerian Jihad period, Leto frequently uses Ixian tools that blur the definition of prohibited technology to his advantage. Leto has instructed Nayla to vow complete obedience to Siona. Siona reveals that she found a dried flower, a strand of hair, and an elegy for Ghanima, Leto’s twin sister, pressed between the pages of the journals. The items are evidence of Leto’s sentimentality, and the revelation serves as a strategic clue for Siona: Leto’s ability to love may be his ultimate weakness.
An epigraph from The Stolen Journals describes Leto’s joy in reliving the memories of his ancestors, noting that academic biographies on these individuals pale in comparison to his intimate knowledge.
Moneo Atreides, Siona’s father and Leto’s majordomo, disposes of Duncan’s body and dutifully prepares for his replacement. Leto has taken over the Bene Gesserit breeding program that produced his father, Paul Muad’Dib, the Kwisatz Haderach. Moneo and Siona are his creations, and Leto believes Siona may be the culmination of his efforts. He regards Siona as both his enemy and his greatest achievement—the “clean slate” (50) that will bring about great change. Siona’s new and unique attributes are that prescient minds cannot detect her, and she is not prescient herself. Leto explains to Moneo that he hopes to be the last in a long line of history’s aggrandized rulers, each of whom was nothing more than “a little Pharaoh” (55). He considers himself a “myth-killer” and is critical of the religious hero worship and weaponized technology that prop up authoritarian governments—including his own 35 centuries of rule (55). In Siona, Leto sees a way to end to his despotic rule while remaining on the Golden Path, and he vows to protect her.
The chapter opens with an inscription from the storehouse at Dar-es-Balat where Leto describes prescience and godhood as a “holy boredom” (58).
The Tleilaxu, also known as “Face Dancers” who can change their appearances, revive the new Duncan from an axolotl tank. Duncan has memories of his original death on Arrakis, but no awareness of the previous gholas’ experiences. The Tleilaxu provide him with a history of the past 3,500 years and explain that Leto is a tyrant. They transport Duncan to the City of Onn, where two Fish Speakers prepare him to serve Leto as Commander. Duncan is incredulous that the Royal Guard is composed only of females and expresses discomfort that they refer to him as “his Duncan” (63). He is suspicious of the guards’ fanatical obedience to Leto, but he tempers his doubts by acknowledging his own unwavering loyalty to the Atreides.
In an epigraph from The Stolen Journal, Leto hopes that future generations will read his journals and understand that his behavior was based on the belief that enemies generate strength.
Siona meets with her fellow rebels in a hidden underground room. Her assistant, Topri, participates in a ritual called “Showing” (67), in which she brandishes a replica of the Fremen’s sacred weapon, the crysknife. Siona helped Topri purchase the knife on the black market from a Museum Fremen, and she regards the copy as an inauthentic, commodified relic of a once mighty culture. Iyo Kobat, the Ixian ambassador, informs the rebels that Leto has banished him for providing the lasgun used in the assassination attempt. He also tells them that Leto is aware of a conspiracy Ix has made with the Spacing Guild and the Bene Gesserit to create a navigation system that does not rely on spice. Rather than punish the Ixians, Leto requested that they continue their experiments and send him daily reports of their progress. Siona exposes Topri as one of Leto’s spies but remains ignorant of Nayla’s deception.
In an epigraph from The Stolen Journal, Leto emphasizes that his conscience is rooted in his ancestral memories, thereby making him holy.
This chapter is a transcript of the question-and-answer session between the Inquisitors of Ix and their new candidate for ambassador, Hwi Noree. In the interview, Hwi claims to have a fuller understanding of Leto’s motivations, arguing that his metamorphosis is a sacrificial act to prevent a catastrophic event. She believes, like all the Atreides before him, he is serving his people. Hwi bases much of her defense of Leto on the observations her Uncle Malky provided as a former ambassador. Malky regarded Leto as a civilized ruler who was justified in executing historians for lying about the past. Hwi believes her sympathies for Leto will dissuade the inquisitors from appointing her ambassador to Arrakis, but they do so anyway.
In an epigraph from The Stolen Journals, Leto attests that he was once human and that his ancestral memories of war haunt him.
As part of his breeding program, Leto intends to have the latest Duncan ghola mate with Siona. Leto believes an older human form like Duncan will help him produce humans who can make long-lasting decisions. He compares himself to a predator who will force humans to adapt and improve themselves. He explains that even though he kills people, he does not hate them. Leto plans to introduce Siona to Duncan after she passes a test that involves envisioning the Golden Path. Having undergone a similar test himself, Moneo fears for his daughter’s safety. Leto believes that the Atreides blood in Siona will convince her of her duty. Throughout their conversation, Moneo nervously stares at Leto’s body and hands for signs of his violent transformation into a giant sandworm.
In an epigraph from the Oral History, Lord Leto tells a repentant follower that rage and anger can silence one’s soul.
This chapter takes the form of a Bene Gesserit report on the state of the Empire during the 3,508th year of Leto’s reign. During Sister Chenoeh’s visit to Arrakis, Leto complained that the universe was too enclosed and lacked exploratory freedom. He made an obscure reference to Siona as an achievement and instructed Chenoeh to report back to her superiors that he planned to restore “outward spiritual freedom” (96). The remainder of the report provides exposition on the universe under Leto’s rule. The Great Houses, prestigious family lines, have lost their power, and only six remaining Houses Minor still exist. The poor have food, but family life has become homogenized throughout the universe. Leto gives the Spacing Guild meager allotments of spice, causing space travel to stagnate and producing sedentary lifestyles. The report notes theories about Leto’s vulnerability to water, his murder of several gholas, and his use of banned technology. However, due to Leto’s prescience, the Bene Gesserit have maintained a position of appeasement to his superior powers. The report also reveals suspicions that Hwi Noree and Malky were genetically designed and confirms that earlier in his reign, Leto burned nine historians at the stake for lying. The Museum Fremen no longer possess the magnificence of their ancestors and have become paid informants for the Bene Gesserit.
The opening chapters establish the monotony and stagnation that characterize Leto’s reign. Leto’s powers of prescience and ancestral memories do not lead to any mystical ecstasy or enlightenment—rather, they reduce him to dire boredom. Leto repeatedly describes his existence as essentially dissatisfying. His inward journeys into his ancestors’ memories are repetitious, and his awareness of all possible futures leaves him craving surprises. Leto’s dissatisfaction is so firm that he inscribes on the walls of his storehouse: “Even to be thought of as a god, as I certainly was, can become ultimately boring” (58). Duncan’s reports and the Duncans themselves are tediously predictable, so much so that Leto falls asleep during his own assassination attempt. Having anticipated Duncan’s betrayal, Leto indulges in a reverie and only snaps back to attention when he realizes, “Great Gods below! He has caught me napping. He has the lasgun in his hand and it is pointed at my face” (38). The hyperbole of Leto’s boredom emphasizes that the Golden Path is not rooted in the greed and pleasure of innumerable powers. Leto’s predicament is not a Midas-styled fable of the man who gets everything he wants and regrets it. Rather, his weariness is rooted in a frustration that humanity has failed to learn from its past mistakes and requires a more drastic shock to the system if it hopes to survive.
The shock comes in the form of Leto’s imposing worm-man body and his near-immortality. Leto predicates his longevity on the Golden Path, a course that involves his direct hand in a breeding project that will save humanity. Additionally, his long reign allows him to conduct a form of human conditioning. By making himself the most oppressive and longest-ruling tyrant in human history, Leto aims to teach The Lessons of Tyranny that humankind has so far failed to learn. Leto strategically takes on the role of “the greatest predator ever known” (21), a force so threatening and absolute that it compels humanity to adapt and improve. By restricting the universe’s freedoms, as outlined in the Bene Gesserit’s state of the Empire report, Leto hopes to teach people to desire and fight for the very things he denies. He assures Moneo, “The predator improves the stock…The predator does not hate his prey” (89). Herbert reverses the connotations of predation from one of threat to one of long-term protection. To emphasize his good intentions, Leto compares himself to Moneo, who continuously worries about Siona’s safety. In this analogy, “all of humankind is [Leto’s] only child” (92). The disjunction between the suffering Leto’s tyranny inflicts and his benevolent purpose raises the question of whether the ends justify the means, especially as Siona and others note that Leto is not the first despot to claim that his despotism is saving humanity.
Leto premises his manner of rule on the widely-held view that antagonism breeds strength and conviction. In the opening of Chapter Six, he proclaims, “Enemies strengthen you” (67), and he has orchestrated an empire such that a God Emperor may signify an enemy of the people and instill a deep distrust in absolute authorities. Enemies, like predators, make one stronger, and the strongest evidence of Leto’s sincere belief in the Golden Path is that he places a high value on rebellion. The novel begins with Siona’s raid on the Citadel and the older Duncan’s attempted assassination—two acts of rebellion against Leto. These opening scenes of resistance foreshadow the novel’s ending, with Siona and Duncan committed to destroying Leto. Siona, Leto’s “ardent enemy” (49), and the latest Duncan, “swordmaster of the Atreides” (61), provide the novel’s suspense and only rising action and climax, as Leto’s postulations take up most of the novel’s narrative. Leto deliberately assists in their rebellion against him, as he allows Siona to steal his journals and continues to replace his ghola knowing that he will inevitably encounter “the subversion of the Duncans” (25)—the one who succeeds in killing the heir of the House of Atreides. Leto is a tyrant who undermines his own authority, and as the novel progresses, Siona and Duncan will continue to redefine what it means to be both rebellious and loyal. Duncan will question his service to an Atreides, and Siona will realign her commitments to a greater cause.
Part of Leto’s human conditioning is not only to foment controlled rebellions (his breeding program uses the Atreides bloodline) but to ensure that they do not co-opt and repeat old patterns of domination. To Leto, rebellions essentially recycle figures of authority rather than enacting true structural and institutional change. When the older Duncan claims that radicals are disruptive, Leto retorts, “That’s no radical. That’s a rival for leadership…There has never been a truly selfless rebel, just hypocrites—conscious hypocrites or unconscious hypocrites, it’s all the same” (37). Leto’s cynicism is rooted in his prescient observations and extensive experience of the past. He has witnessed countless insurrections where the only significant change was the title of rulership. He tells Moneo, “You cannot imagine what I have seen—caliphs and mjeeds, rakahs, rajas and bashars, kings and emperors, primitos and presidents—I’ve seen them all. Feudal chieftains, every one. Every one a little pharaoh” (55). The oxymoron of “little pharoah” functions as a critique of absolute authority. Leto understands that behind these aggrandized titles are mere humans—mortal, vulnerable, and violent. Implicit in Leto’s critique is the idea that followers view their leaders as superior beings and give up their autonomy, and detractors fear they are powerless against such a mighty force. Leto critiques these forms of power by enacting them in an extreme form—his regime is built on the very Institutional Corruption he decries. Leto calls himself a “myth-killer” (55), privately renouncing his title as God Emperor and foreshadowing the role he will play in his own death. In later chapters, he demystifies his divinity by exposing the social construction of his godhood and the performativity of power.
The opening chapters also introduce Moneo Atreides and Nayla, devotees of Leto who function as foils to Duncan and Siona. Moneo is Siona’s father and a former rebel turned sycophant. Before Moneo appears as an active character in the novel, he is introduced in a transcript excerpt defending the God Emperor’s right to kill. He rationalizes to Siona, “It is the Worm that kills. The Worm is God. Leto lives in the bosom of God, but he kills no one” (23). Moneo excuses Leto from responsibility for the murders of his opponents, and instead of arguing whether killing is right or wrong, he defers moral judgment to the unquestionable domain of God. Like Moneo, Nayla is an ardent believer in Leto as God. The communication implant in her head indicates the extremity of her devotion, and she signs her reports to him, “Your worshipful servant, Nayla” (42). Nayla is representative of the Fish Speakers’ subservient mentality. She is so willing to follow Leto’s orders that she promises to obey Siona only because he commands her to.
Moneo differs from his religious devotion fatigues him, whereas Nayla’s infuses her with vigor. Nayla operates as a spy, working with banned technology and enjoying the intrigues of her double life. Moneo, on the other hand, is the faithful servant whose weariness mirrors Leto’s boredom. He shuffles along the Citadel corridors and dutifully clears away yet another dead body of a Duncan ghola. Rather than feeling shock, horror, or urgency, “Moneo sighed and began the long walk through the echoing gloom. There was a body on the floor near the cart. No need for déjà vu. This was merely familiar” (48-49). Both Moneo and Leto exude a melancholic resignation in their duty to the Golden Path and their interdependence on each other. Moneo and Leto are the only two characters in the beginning of the novel who have seen the Golden Path, and because of this shared experience, Moneo is Leto’s closest confidant, though never his equal. Leto is not without a sense of humor in his awareness of Moneo’s devotion and their solitary existence. In an ironic comment about their roles as “myth-killers,” Leto states, “I may be the last of the lot, Moneo. Pray that this is so” (55). In another scene, Moneo has become so accustomed to his own passivity that at one point, Leto wonders if he is an Ixian machine. These opening encounters establish Moneo as more than a blind follower, as he also heightens the loneliness of Leto’s existence.
By Frank Herbert