Gideon’s Trumpet

Federalism becomes one of the most important discussions within the context of the case. How is this issue represented within the text?

In a text filled with lawyers, how are the various attorneys portrayed? Are they a cohesive body or is there divided opinion among their ranks? What is their role in shaping US law?

How does the portrayal of the Supreme Court itself affect the narrative, particularly in terms of imagery and aesthetics?

The text uses the metaphor of a release valve when discussing the role of the Court. Which issues are portrayed as being most contentious at the time of the decision?

The various justices of the Court are given brief flashes of personality. Which justices stand out among the rest and why? What does the varying makeup of the court suggest about US law?

Jacob plays a thankless role in the text. How does the lawyer on the losing side of the argument command the attention and the sympathy of the audience? Could there be a sector that accepts his side of the case? Why or why not?

What are the key differences between the Supreme Court and the legislative branches of government as portrayed in the text? How does this relationship serve or undermine US law?

What are the lasting implications of the decision in Gideon’s case? Do you believe that these changes will last?