37 pages • 1 hour read
Jonathan KozolA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Summary
Chapter Summaries & Analyses
Key Figures
Themes
Symbols & Motifs
Important Quotes
Essay Topics
Tools
In this chapter, Kozol profiles Ariella Patterson, a woman who was stronger than Vicky and Pietro and who had become homeless when her house had caught on fire. She started living in an Emergency Assistance Unit (EAU), a temporary shelter where people lived in undivided rooms, before she moved into the Martinique, which she describes as “a nightmare. It was hell on earth” (83).
She was eventually moved to Mott Haven in the Bronx in a relatively new building that was near the depressing complex of houses called the Diego-Beekman Houses. Funded by public money, these houses, run by a private company, were cited for numerous infractions. The owner, a man named Gerald Schuster from Boston, gave money to political candidates to clean up his image, which was tarnished by the death of a child named Bernardo who had fallen into the elevator shaft in one of his buildings.
Ariella was able to find a supervisory position for a chain of clothing stores, a position for which she earned $16,000 a year—twice the average income in Mott Haven. When she moved into the neighborhood, her older son, Silvio, was 12, and her younger son, Armando, was almost 9. On her days off, she took them to the museums and restaurants of Manhattan, trying to let them know that they weren’t defined by their neighborhood.
However, these escapes were episodic in nature, and the horrors Silvio had witnessed left an imprint on him. Silvio got into trouble at school, destroying property and smoking pot in the bathroom. When he was still in middle school, he started having sex and stealing things. He believed he was invincible and worshipped the character Scarface, from the film of the same name. Silvio’s mother put him in a group home, but he became more defiant and asked to return home. Another boy cut him with a boxcutter, and he needed sixty-seven stitches to reassemble his face. He regarded this scar as a badge of honor. Silvio was put in another group home but ran away. He ran out of his apartment and rode the trains with his friends. He climbed out on the roof of the train car, and, when he lifted his head to wave to his friends, he was hit by a steel girder and fell between the subway cars. He died at age 14.
Ariella struggled to care for her other son, Armando, and cut back on her hours working. Even after his brother’s death, Armando regarded Silvio as a hero. Armando began to take small amounts of money from the neighborhood drug dealers, who were cultivating him to enter the drug trade. Diagnosed with learning issues, he received no help at his failing public schools and dropped out before the end of ninth grade. He became a drug courier and then began selling drugs. He was arrested with a weapon but released into his mother’s custody, and he was then arrested for possession of heroin and cocaine. He served four-and-a-half years in jail and was addicted to heroin when he came out of jail. Because of parole violations, he went to Rikers Island seven times over the next four years. While in prison, he married a woman he had known since he was 13, and they had two kids. When he was taken back to jail, it was his daughter Inocencia’s birthday, and the police took him away while his daughter watched. He swore to his mother never to miss another of his children’s birthdays, and he changed at that moment. When he got out of jail, his wife began working and getting off welfare, while Armando took care of the kids.
Ariella had two younger children. She sent her son, Stephen, to a better school and for treatment for depression at Mount Sinai Hospital, something that she had not done with the two older boys. He began at a two-year college and worked as a tutor at St. Ann’s while preparing to return to school. Ariella’s youngest son was a serious student, and Ariella had become a devoted member of St. Ann’s and had organized an anti-gun campaign. Though she had renewed confidence, she lived with the memories of having lost her oldest son.
Alice Washington was 42 when she was diagnosed with intestinal cancer. Her husband began drinking heavily as a result, and when he began to abuse her physically and mentally, she left him. She had to stop working as a secretary and move with her two teenage girls and a boy of 12 to chaotic EAUs (Emergency Assistance Units). One shelter she was placed in did not have running water. She was then placed at the Martinique in a single room. She would live at the Martinique for four years.
Alice was a leader of the women at the shelter and had an irreverent wit. She could read the newspaper and figure out that the language bureaucrats used to speak about the homeless—figures of speech such as “overflow”—symbolized that they thought of the homeless as akin to refuse. She fought to be placed in better housing, but she was moved in the late 1980s to the South Bronx.
She and Kozol became friends over the years, and he enjoyed visiting her and hearing her conversations about food. She gave advice to him about how to handle his aging mother and father, the latter of whom was losing his memory. She continued to show an antic sense of humor about her misfortunes, such as the way her brother’s dead body was lost at the hospital, and about the peccadillos of the rich, whom she felt were judged far more leniently than the poor. She also spoke about a man she had tutored in reading, whom she felt was unfairly sent to prison.
Alice’s health problems began to affect her more and more. Right after being released from the Martinique, she was diagnosed with HIV. She shared with Kozol that the disease had progressed considerably in a short period. At that time, needle-sharing was prevalent in the South Bronx, and many people were infected with HIV. Alice believed she had contracted the virus from her husband. Nonetheless, Alice acted protective towards Kozol and did not let her health worries destroy her. She later told Kozol that cancer cells had been found in the pleura of her lungs. Despite her problems, she still worried over Kozol’s safety when he walked the streets of the Bronx, and she helped Pietro with his daughters.
Her cancer eventually metastasized, and she had to have her breast removed. Up until the end, even as she was in and out of hospitals, she kept up her cheer and her humorous talk about food. Her kids grew up to have stable lives, and she never perceived herself as a victim, even though she lived with HIV and died young.
In Chapters 4 and 5, Kozol profiles two women whom he considers survivors of the horrors of the Martinique. Ariella Patterson was a survivor because she emerged from her ordeals with the strength to work as an anti-gun crusader. Though her oldest son wound up troubled and died tragically while surfing the tops of subway cars, Ariella fought for her other three sons. Her second son also endured hardships but straightened himself out, and she learned from her oldest two son’s ordeals and was able to fight for better schools and for mental-health treatment for her other sons. She also devoted herself to improving the streets for other children by fighting for gun control.
Alice Washington was able to retain her irreverent sense of humor and her sense of the incongruities of life even while living at the Martinique. She immediately saw through the hypocrisy of the way in which the authorities treated the poor, and she was an acerbic and astute observer of society and politics. She and Kozol enjoyed a true friendship in which she worried about him as much as he worried about her. Their friendship was not a matter of pity or condescension but the union of two people who looked out and cared for each other.
Alice succumbed to the HIV/AIDS epidemic (though she died of cancer, she was weakened by HIV) that raged through New York in the 1980s. When she was at the Martinique and later living in the Bronx, the public awareness and public safety campaign around HIV had not yet come to be, and many people transmitted the disease unknowingly, through sexual contact or by sharing needles. The poor of the Bronx were devastated by this epidemic, and Alice suffered from the effects of HIV over time. However, Kozol is careful to point out her humor, her spirit, and her liveliness, and he states that she was far from being a victim. In this sense, like Ariella, Alice was a survivor, and she emerged from the horrors of the Martinique with her spirit intact.
By Jonathan Kozol