47 pages • 1 hour read
Donnie EicharA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Content Warning: This section includes discussions of the violent deaths of nine people, including graphic descriptions of corpses.
Donnie Eichar is an American author and documentary filmmaker. He grew up in Florida but now lives in California. In 2010, a few months after hearing about the Dyatlov incident for the first time, Eichar traveled to Russia to learn more. He had no personal connection to the case and no mountaineering experience, but he was obsessed with learning the truth about what happened to the hikers. When his initial research proved less fruitful than he hoped, 39-year-old Eichar returned for a second visit to Russia in 2012, leaving behind a girlfriend, Julia Ortiz, and a one-year-old son, Dashiel. That visit forms the basis of most of Dead Mountain, as Eichar attempts to retrace the hikers’ steps to reconstruct the last few days of their lives at the site of the disaster in Holatchahl.
Despite his lack of personal involvement in the case and his lack of experience, Eichar was determined to recreate the hikers’ journey and to come up with a plausible explanation for their mysterious deaths. Like everyone, Eichar brings his own biases and expectations to his efforts. He is an outsider with a limited understanding of what life was like in the Soviet Union in 1959. He is also open about his desire to find a scientific explanation that does not rely on conspiracy theories or unverifiable speculation. Eventually, Eichar’s Perseverance and Determination pays off when he is able to put together a plausible sequence of events. While Eichar was not the first to propose infrasound as an explanation for the hikers’ behavior, he is responsible for popularizing the infrasound and Kármán vortex street theory.
Yuri Yudin (1937-2013) was the only member of the Dyatlov hiking group to survive. He came from a poor family and grew up in a small village called Emelyashevka, located to the northeast of Sverdlovsk. Like many people from his generation, he experienced severe rationing during World War II; in Dead Mountain, he tells Eichar that he was seven years old the first time he had sugar. Yudin had health issues for his entire life, including “rheumatism, a heart condition, and chronic knee and back pain” (39-40). He enjoyed hiking despite these challenges, describing it as his salvation. At the Ural Polytechnic Institute, he studied geology and befriended other avid hikers.
Yudin was determined to scale Otorten Mountain with the rest of the Dyatlov group so that he could earn his Grade III hiking certification, but back and leg pain forced him to turn back several days before the other hikers died. For the rest of his life, Yudin was plagued with questions about what happened to his friends and what might have happened to him if he had continued the journey with them. In the aftermath of the tragedy, Yudin had the unenviable job of identifying the owner of each of the belongings found in the tent and with the hikers’ bodies. He missed his friends’ funerals because of his role in the investigation.
In the years after the Dyatlov Pass incident, Yudin completed his education and worked in a factory. He kept hiking, enjoying its positive impact on his life even as he recognized that his friends all died while hiking in the wilderness. Near the end of his life, Yudin spoke with Eichar several times about his experiences. He provided valuable insight into his friends’ personalities and the details of the first few days of the hike. Yudin firmly believed that his friends were murdered by Soviet military personnel, a theory that Eichar rejected immediately. Eichar and Yudin also had political differences; Eichar could not understand why Yudin vocally supported Stalin while denouncing Lenin and Putin.
Yuri Kuntsevich was 12 years old when the Dyatlov hikers died. He happened to live across the street from the cemetery where the hikers were buried, and he joined the large crowd of mourners for the funeral of the first four bodies. He did not know the hikers, but he was curious about the outpouring of grief. He noted that the open-casket funeral displayed bodies with strangely darkened skin, leading him to speculate about their mysterious deaths. When he grew up, Kuntsevich became the leader of the Dyatlov Foundation in Yekaterinburg, dedicating much of his life to trying to solve the mystery. Eichar notes that instead of relying strictly on scientific explanations, Kuntsevich “relied on his gut instinct,” resulting in interpretations that were “tinged with hyperbole” (172). Kuntsevich believes that one day, the answers will be revealed in previously classified government documents. Eichar is doubtful.
Kuntsevich was Eichar’s primary contact in Russia, hosting Eichar in his apartment during both of his visits to Russia. Eichar speaks almost no Russian, and Kuntsevich’s English is limited. Sometimes, Eichar had interactions with Kuntsevich that he could not understand, like when Kuntsevich prevented him from taking a photograph in the train station but did not explain why. Despite this barrier, the two men developed a productive partnership as they investigated the case. Once Eichar gained Kuntsevich’s trust, Kuntsevich put him in touch with Yuri Yudin and facilitated his journey to Holatchahl. Unlike Eichar, Kuntsevich was cautious, warning that unpredictable weather could be extremely dangerous. He insisted that Eichar visit the site for only a few hours and that he travel there via snowmobile. In the end, Kuntsevich’s expertise paid off, as Eichar realized just how physically challenging a hike through deep snow in low temperatures could be.
Lev Nikitich Ivanov was the chief prosecutor in the Dyatlov case. His behavior, whether voluntary or coerced, contributed to the atmosphere of Political Repression in the investigation. When he first took over the case, he made some astute observations about the hikers’ deaths; for instance, he was the one who noted a third set of footprints near the bodies of Georgy and Doroshenko. Almost immediately, Ivanov started asking questions about how the hikers died. He suggested that the hikers would not have left their tent voluntarily and must have been murdered. Although he at first considered the orb or weapons test theory to be a likely answer, after a mysterious visit to Moscow, Ivanov stopped talking about both of these theories and insisted that other investigators follow his lead. Given that neither option is particularly likely, it is still uncertain why officials told Ivanov to drop his lines of questioning. Of course, there is also the possibility that Ivanov’s change of opinion was not externally imposed; like most parts of the Dyatlov case, his motives are subject to speculation.
When the hikers’ bodies were found, Ivanov was partially responsible for the bizarre way that the funerals were handled. Officials originally wanted the hikers to be buried near where they were found, and even when families successfully petitioned to bury their children at home, the funerals had to be quite discreet. Ivanov insisted that the last four hikers receive closed casket funerals, refusing to open the caskets to allow the families to see their children’s bodies. He only made an exception for Lyuda’s father, who fainted at the sight of her body. Eichar notes that in later years, Ivanov expressed regret about his actions, especially regarding the hikers’ funerals. In an article written decades after the event, Ivanov apologized “to the families of the hikers, especially that of [Lyuda] Dubinina, [Kolya] Thibault-Brignoles and [Sasha] Zolotaryov” (342).
Nine members of the same hiking party died on the night of February 1, 1959, on the slopes of Holatchahl in the Ural Mountains. Based on their journals, their photographs, and the testimony of family and friends, Eichar attempts to paint a picture of who these young people were. Igor Dyatlov (1936-1959) was the group’s leader. He had an authoritarian streak, often insisting that his fellow hikers do things his way and obstinately refusing to compromise. The area where the hikers died is known as Dyatlov Pass, and the hikers are collectively known as the Dyatlov group, because of Igor’s leadership. Dyatlov died of hypothermia while clinging to a birch tree. Rustem “Rustik” Slobodin (1936-1959) was a wealthy young man whom Eichar describes as “unpretentious and friendly” (41). Like Dyatlov, he died of hypothermia, and he was found alone, with a fractured skull. He was found wearing a hat, which cast doubts on the theory that the hikers were blown away from their tent by strong winds.
Zinaida “Zina” Kolmogorova (1937-1959) was highly organized. Eichar suggests that some of the other hikers may have had romantic feelings for her: Igor had a photograph of Zina in his notebook. Like Igor and Rustik, Zina died alone of hypothermia. She was probably trying to climb back to the tent after falling and breaking her nose. Yuri Doroshenko (1938-1959), one of the youngest members of the team, managed to start a small fire after leaving the tent, but he died of hypothermia soon thereafter. He was found alongside another member of the team, one of two hikers whose names Eichar gets wrong. Eichar lists Yuri “Georgy” Krivonishenko (1935-1959) as one of the hikers, but in fact, this hiker’s given name was Georgiy. Yuri, or Yura, was his nickname.
The last four hikers were all found in a ravine. Lyudmila “Lyuda” Dubinina (1938-1959) was the group’s youngest member and the one with the most severe injuries. She likely sustained major thoracic damage by falling into a ravine. Nikolai “Kolya” Thibault-Brignoles (1935-1959), whose name is sometimes spelled Thibeaux-Brignolles in other sources, probably died of brain hemorrhaging after falling into the ravine. The last two hikers were found embracing in a last-ditch attempt to stay warm. They were Alexander Kolevatov (1934-1959), who may have tried to bring his friends extra clothing after they fell into the ravine, and Sasha Zolotaryov (1921-1959), whose first name Eichar mistakenly says is Alexander, but was actually Semyon. Sasha was the oldest member of the group and the last one to join the expedition.
Action & Adventure
View Collection
Earth Day
View Collection
European History
View Collection
Grief
View Collection
Inspiring Biographies
View Collection
Memory
View Collection
Mortality & Death
View Collection
Nation & Nationalism
View Collection
New York Times Best Sellers
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection
Safety & Danger
View Collection
Teams & Gangs
View Collection
The Past
View Collection
True Crime & Legal
View Collection
Truth & Lies
View Collection