logo

97 pages 3 hours read

Phillip Hoose

Claudette Colvin: Twice Toward Justice

Nonfiction | Biography | YA | Published in 2009

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Part 1, Chapters 7-8Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary: “Another Negro Woman Has Been Arrested”

Content Warning: Part 1, Chapter 7 Summary references the sexual assault and sexual exploitation of a minor.

The NAACP and other Black advocacy groups would finally have their ideal bus boycott icon in December 1955, when Rosa Parks was arrested for disturbing the peace after, like Claudette, refusing to give up her seat to a white woman. At the time of her arrest, Parks was 41, married, and well-known in both activist communities and the Montgomery population as a whole, since she worked as a seamstress at a popular downtown department store.

By the time Parks made her stand, the NAACP was primed for immediate action and the bus boycott began almost immediately. By the day after her arrest, a network of activists had distributed leaflets to almost every Black person in Montgomery, calling for them to avoid the buses that Monday. Almost everyone was on board with this plan; Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. drove around town on boycott day looking into bus windows, and only reported seeing eight Black people riding them, when usually there would have been hundreds. Although Claudette was happy that Parks’s arrest had finally sparked a boycott, she was disappointed that she was not asked to be part of the movement. Her name was even misspelled on the leaflet calling for the boycott. Jo Ann Robinson, who wrote the flyer, had called her “Claudette Colbert.” To add to her troubles, she realized she was pregnant by a much older married man whom she had met during her lonely, isolated summer. Due to her parents’ fear that the man’s wife would retaliate if she found out about Claudette, she was unable to explain that she had been taken advantage of.

Claudette tried to hide her pregnancy to stay in school, since pregnant girls were always expelled, but teachers and students began to catch, on and she was not allowed to return after Christmas break. Her mother arranged for her to finish school in Birmingham under her birth name, Claudette Austin. Meanwhile, the initial boycott had resulted in a rise of activism in Montgomery, with Rosa Parks and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. steadily becoming household names. Upon arriving in Birmingham and leaving the watchful eye of her mother, Claudette realized that she could not be away from Montgomery at that pivotal moment. She decided to take the GED (General Education Development) exam instead of finishing school. After just two weeks in Birmingham, she returned to Montgomery to play whatever part she could in the fight for civil rights.

Part 1, Chapter 8 Summary: “Second Front, Second Chance”

By the end of 1955, the bus boycott was in full swing in Montgomery, and Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. became famous across the country for his eloquent, impassioned speeches calling for nonviolent protest. The Black community had nearly abandoned the bus system, largely due to a grassroots transportation network organized by the Montgomery Improvement Association (MIA). The MIA organizers plotted out a series of stops around the city with the help of Black mail carriers, who knew the most efficient routes. A Black parking lot owner allowed them to use the lot as a central transportation hub, and hundreds of citizens volunteered their personal vehicles to be used as makeshift “buses.” The system was free, funded by donations solicited at “mass meetings,” the large public gatherings that formed the backbone of activism in Montgomery.

The system worked well, but many people ended up walking everywhere they needed to go. This became a symbol of resistance for many, with even the elderly and people with disabilities walking to show that they were part of the boycott. The MIA allowed many people who were concerned about the way the boycott would affect their lives to begin supporting the protest, and throughout 1956, the buses remained devoid of Black passengers. This had a dramatic effect on bus companies, who began to lay off drivers and cancel bus routes after just a month of protest.

Claudette and her family bought a used Plymouth so her mother could get to work and help neighbors who needed a ride (as she was not an official part of the MIA). Since her mother was often out of the house driving, Claudette took over many of the household chores and shopping. The family also bought a TV so they could keep up with the latest news about the protests. Claudette started attending mass meetings far from home, so people would not recognize her and discover she was pregnant. Although she went regularly, she always hid in the back, knowing that the leaders would not ask a pregnant, unmarried teenager to speak.

As the bus boycott began to affect bus companies’ profits, the activists were met with more and more pushback from white people. At the behest of the mayor, police began stopping Black drivers for minor infractions to interrogate them, including Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr. who spent a night in jail in late January for a minor speeding violation. Both Dr. King and E. D. Nixon had explosives thrown at their houses. Jo Ann Robinson was targeted twice by police officers, first with a rock thrown through her window and then with acid poured on her car, which caused extensive damage.

While the boycotters began to worry about their movement’s future in the face of increasing violence, Fred Gray embarked on the “second front” of the boycott. He hoped to have bus segregation ruled unconstitutional, which would require a hearing in federal court, as the Alabama judicial system would inevitably rule against any case that might end Jim Crow laws. After a meeting with the NAACP in New York, Gray succeeded in securing a place before a panel of three federal judges to put forth a constitutional challenge to Alabama bus laws.

Claudette was seven months pregnant when Fred Gray called her house, asking her to testify in his case. After a meeting with her parents and Gray, Claudette agreed. She was justifiably afraid, knowing that having her name attached to a blatant challenge of Jim Crow laws was incredibly dangerous. However, she did not want to live a life of fear, and she wanted both white and Black people to know that she would not accept segregation. Claudette’s family and Revered Johnson supported her decision, despite knowing the potential harm that could come to them. Many of her neighbors began to shy away from her, fearful of backlash from the newly formed White Citizens Councils, who vowed to make any Black person associated with the movement lose their job.

Six weeks before the lawsuit hearing began, Claudette gave birth to her son Raymond. He had blonde hair and blue eyes, which made the hospital employees question the father’s race. Claudette continued to withhold any information about him. In the days before the trial, she sat awake with the infant, planning out what she would say to the panel of judges. She envisioned herself in the Colosseum, about to give her final plea to the Roman Senate before being thrown to the lions.

Part 1, Chapters 7-8 Analysis

In Chapters 7-8, Phillip Hoose discusses the circumstances that finally allowed the Montgomery bus boycotts to begin and continue for over a year. The boycott was not a spontaneous event—it was planned for months, led by people like Jo Ann Robinson, E. D. Nixon, Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr., and a huge group of trusted volunteers. Claudette said in an interview with the New York Times, “Young people think Rosa Parks just sat down on a bus and ended segregation, but that wasn‘t the case at all.” This quote refers to her own civil disobedience prior to Parks’s and the Browder v. Gayle trial, but also the immense effort that went into making the bus boycott a success on all fronts, an effort that is often overlooked in modern coverage of the early civil rights movement. By the time Parks was arrested, organizers were able to begin spreading word of the boycott the following day, and a few days, later there were almost no Black people on buses.

Unlike Claudette, Parks’s choice to stay seated on a bus was intended to put a larger plan, which she had a part in, into action. Hoose highlights the major distinctions between the two women‘s arrests, which further reveals the increased prejudice toward a dark-skinned teenager as opposed to a well-known, middle-aged, light-skinned, and straight-haired woman. Claudette was dragged violently off a bus, handcuffed, and forced to sit in the back of a police car with an officer, which she justifiably worried would end in her sexual assault. The police crudely mocked her all the way to jail, where she was locked up and only freed when a friend told her mother what was going on. Parks, on the other hand, was politely escorted to a police car, and allowed to ride uncuffed and alone in the back seat. She spent no time in jail and was charged with only one crime—disturbing the peace. While this lesser charge was better for her on a personal level, it also meant that her case could not be used to challenge the constitutional basis of segregation laws, as she had not been accused of breaking them. This would ultimately be a factor in lawyer Fred Gray’s decision to go ahead with the Browder v. Gayle trial.

Although Hoose focuses on larger themes in Chapters 8-9, he writes the story in a way that keeps Claudette as the central focus. As the bus boycott and the Black elites’ organizational efforts play out in the background, and provide important context, Claudette reverts from a confident, ambitious young woman to a lonely teenager who feels abandoned by the movement. She becomes even more awash when she realizes she is pregnant. When this happens, she realizes her fate as a footnote in the history of civil rights is probably sealed, and her dream of becoming a lawyer is no longer a reality. This is largely due to established biases against single mothers; once she has a child as a teenager, she is no longer a young person with a bright future, but a “fallen woman.” Her inability to tell the truth about the baby’s father is guided by her parents’ internalized fear of backlash from privileged people. Even as an adult, Claudette never revealed who Raymond’s father was, although speculation continues to exist, including theories that he was a white man. No matter the real story, it is clear that as a 15-year-old, she was unable to consent to a sexual encounter with a man 10 years her senior, no matter the circumstances. If she had been allowed to reveal this man’s identity and age, Claudette’s future may have played out differently.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text