82 pages • 2 hours read
Jean ToomerA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.
“Nullo” is a short, single-stanza poem in free verse with just seven lines. The poem, written in the third person and past tense, describes pine needles falling onto a forest path. The rabbits do not know about them falling, and the pine needles do not cause a fire.
“Evening Song,” another poem, has three stanzas of four lines each (the first line of the final stanza is long and technically finishes on another line). The speaker is with Cloine, the woman the speaker loves. In the first stanza, Cloine is becoming sleepy, which the speaker recognizes by her loosely parted lips. Soon, Cloine is asleep, and the speaker also expects to join her in slumber. Cloine lies curled up against the speaker.
Set in a town in Georgia, “Esther” is divided into three parts, with subsections stating Esther’s age. The first subsection in part 1 is titled “Nine.” Esther is a very fair-skinned little girl with curly hair and high cheekbones. Her face is “prematurely serious,” the only thing keeping her from being more obviously “pretty.” One day when she is walking home, she passes by a dark-skinned man named King Barlo. He falls to his knees at the Spittoon and looks up to the sky in a religious trance. People are familiar with this and gather around to listen to him speak. They regard him as a prophet. He is silent and still for a while; then, he begins by explaining that Jesus has been “awhisperin strange words deep down […] in my ears” (28). As he speaks, the listeners respond affirmatively and holler. He describes a vision that he saw of a large Black man rising with his head in the clouds. In this vision, “little white-ant biddies” chain the man’s feet and take him as a slave across the sea. As Barlo pauses, his audience—Black and white alike—is emotionally moved. Disapproving preachers try to figure out how to get rid of him. Barlo rises to his feet as the sun sets and calls the people to turn to the Lord. For years to come, people recall hearing a thunderous voice then, and angels and demons “parad[ing] up and down the streets all night” (29). Barlo leaves town riding a bull but leaves a lasting impression on the town and Esther.
Part 2 begins with the subsection “Sixteen.” Esther daydreams that a nearby shop catches fire and the fire department must go and rescue a baby, which Esther claims as her own. She begins a new daydream where there is a fire again, but this time loiterers on the corner put it out by chewing and squirting tobacco juice onto it. Women lift their skirts and flee; Esther is left to take the baby. The baby is “ugly as sin” (30), but she holds the baby close and loves it.
In subsection “Twenty-two,” Esther now works at her father’s grocery store. Her father is the wealthiest Black man in town. Esther wonders why men are not interested in her. She recalls Barlo, romanticizing him and deciding she will tell him she loves him whenever he returns. Five years go by; her hair thins, and her face pales to gray. Part 3 begins with the subsection “Esther is twenty-seven.” One day while she is working in the store, King Barlo returns to town in a new car. He is wealthy now from cotton during “the war” (likely World War I). Esther wishes she were more “sharp” and “sporty” to attract Barlo. Flustered by the thought of the “loose women” and “easy-going men” who will possess him if she doesn’t, Esther closes the store and rushes home. At midnight, she sneaks out to Nat Bowle’s place, where Barlo is staying. As she ascends the stairs toward the voices of lounging people, the thick tobacco smoke makes her dizzy, and she passes out. She awakes to Barlo asking her why she has come. She says she has come for him, but he does not understand at first. Others in the room are surprised that this upper-class fair girl has come, and they laugh at her being so forward. Barlo is drunk, and when he grins at Esther, she finds him ugly. Now repulsed by Barlo, Esther turns around and leaves.
“Conversion” is a short, single-stanza poem in free verse with eight lines. It describes an “African Guardian of Souls” eating and drinking rum, met with new words from a “white-faced sardonic god.” The Guardian’s response is to grin and shout “hosanna.”
“Portrait in Georgia” is a seven-line, single-stanza poem in free verse. This poem offers a series of metaphors for the parts of an unnamed woman. Her hair, eyes, lips, breath, and body are likened to braided chestnut, a bundle of sticks, old scars, the scent of cane, and white ash, respectively.
“Blood-Burning Moon” is divided into three parts. The story begins at dusk with a rising full moon in an African American factory town (“a location of antebellum cotton mills”) (172). Louisa is singing as she walks back home to the town from her domestic work in a white family’s home. Bob Stone, the younger son of that white family, is in love with Louisa. Tom “Big Boy” Burwell, a Black field worker from Louisa’s town, also loves her. Louisa likes them both; she is planning to meet Bob in the canebrake later that day, and she also expects Tom to propose to her very soon.
Part 2 begins with a scene of sugar cane being processed in the factory town. As the men work and rest, they talk about women. Tom is there, and when someone mentions that Louisa is with Bob Stone, he gets defensive and starts a fight. Fed up, he leaves. He later finds Louisa and tries, with difficulty, to express his love for her. He confronts her about a relationship with Tom, and she denies it; he is satisfied, saying he would cut Tom if the rumors were true, as he had already cut the Black man who made the accusation. As they sit together, the whole town sings about a “blood-burning moon” and “sinner” (42).
Part 3 begins with Bob Stone at home pondering his secret sexual relationship with Louisa. He sees this relationship as in keeping with white domination. He doesn’t quite understand Black people, refers to them using the n-word, and his love for Louisa is tempered by her Blackness. He has heard rumors about Louisa and Tom, and when he overhears some men talking about Tom’s threat to cut Bob, he goes to find Tom in a jealous rage. He finds Tom and Louisa sitting together, and the two men fight. Tom cuts Bob’s throat, and Bob staggers back toward his town, where he says it was Tom who cut him. Meanwhile, the Black people know trouble is coming, and all go inside, except for Louisa and Tom. A lynch mob of white men drive into factory town and take him to the factory, where they burn him alive. Meanwhile, Louisa sits distraught on her front steps. She considers the full moon an omen, and sings to it the same song the townsfolk sang earlier.
In the footnotes of the Penguin Classics edition of Cane, “Nullo” is defined as “‘A nought, a cipher,’ signifying nothing in itself but increasing or decreasing the value of other figures according to its position” (171). The title of this poem, then, implies a relative nothingness. It likely refers to the pine needles whose falling is inconsequential—they do not affect the wildlife (“Rabbits knew not of their falling”), and they do not affect much of the forest or the people who live nearby (“Nor did the forest catch aflame”) (25). While the poem focuses on the “nullo” effect of the falling pine needles, it curiously does not comment on the cause. There is no mention of who or what led to this “spray of pine-needles” falling onto the path (25). This reaction with no inciting action asks the reader to imagine the pine needles as agents themselves, falling helplessly to the ground, perhaps even evoking empathy from the reader, as they are ignored by everything around them, unable to even start a fire.
“Evening Song” uses moon and water metaphors to describe Cloine and the speaker’s love for her. When she sleeps, she is “curled like the sleep waters where the moon-waves start” (26). The speaker describes her as “radiant” and gleaming “resplendently,” not unlike the full moon. The speaker’s heart is described metaphorically as having “waters” above which a full moon rises. This represents the height of the speaker’s love for Cloine. Additionally, this poem progresses the theme in previous chapters of scenes at sunset and evening; now, in “Evening Song,” the moon is rising, leading the reader deeper into nighttime.
Toomer links “Esther” and the poem that follows it, “Conversion.” This unusual poem appears to reference the encounter in Nat Bowle’s place between Esther and King Barlo. Read in this way, King Barlo is the “African Guardian of Souls,” while Esther is the “white-faced sardonic god.” “Conversion” recasts the interaction between Esther and Barlo as a divine encounter, where they are both elevated spiritual beings in a more abstract setting. The poem also performs religious syncretism, where it draws from a Judeo-Christian tradition (“amen” and “hosanna”) as well as an unspecified polytheistic, spiritual tradition (“white-faced […] god” and “African Guardian of Souls”) (35). This reflects a similar syncretism in “Esther,” where King Barlo communes with God but also himself serves as an ambiguously African spiritual messiah who has visions about the trans-Atlantic slave trade and inspires a woman in town to draw “a portrait of a Black Madonna on the courthouse wall” (29).
While the subjects were mainly African American in previous chapters, chapters 11-16 feature a shift in focus to an interracial landscape. This is most obvious in “Esther,” where Toomer is explicit about the presence of white and Black people: “White and black men loafing on the corner” (27); “white and black preachers confer” (29); “It ruthlessly shoves black and white idlers to one side” (30); “Negro women, lean scrawny white women, pull their skirts up” (30). This expanded world in “Esther” sets the stage for Cane’s mood shift from a wistful, almost nostalgic appreciation for the Southern landscape to tense, horrifying attention to racial violence.
As the poem “Portrait in Georgia” follows, its metaphors—hair like a lyncher’s rope, lips like red blisters—directly reference the heightened racial violence in the early 20th-century post-Reconstruction era. “Portrait in Georgia” evokes this then-current crisis. Interestingly, the subject of the poem is characterized as a white-skinned woman (“her slim body, white as the ash of black flesh after flame”) (36), which could be interpreted in several ways. Toomer could simply mean this to be a fair-skinned Black woman, like Esther. However, Toomer could have also meant her to be a white woman, therefore critically reversing the image of Black corporeal violence and forcing that violence onto a white body instead. Or, Toomer might have meant that this woman is inhumanly white, the exact color of ash. She might, therefore, not be realistic but a literal Frankenstein’s monster composite of braided chestnut, sticks, blisters, cane, and ash. She would be, then, the embodiment of anti-Black violence.
The theme of anti-Black violence reaches its height in “Blood-Burning Moon,” where Tom Burwell (a Black man) kills Bob Stone (a white man) over Louisa (a Black woman), and a white mob burns Tom to death. The story begins and ends with a full moon, lending the story a circularity that communicates the repeated incidents of lynching in the American South and the seeming inescapability of the cycle of anti-Black violence.
Love is also a theme that appears in “Evening Song,” “Esther,” and “Blood-Burning Moon.” While in “Evening Song” the relationship between the speaker and the sleeping woman appears to be affectionate, reciprocated, and peaceful, the other two chapters offer a distorted vision of love and relationship. In “Esther,” the titular character cannot understand why men are not attracted to her. Desperate for love, she romanticizes the idea of King Barlo—a man she does not know personally—and offers herself to him. This offer is met with incredulity and laughter, and Esther has the rude awakening that she not only does not like Barlo, but she also finds him ugly in reality. In “Blood-Burning Moon,” Louisa is unfaithful as she carries on relationships with both Tom and Bob. While Bob claims to love her, he views her as his rightful property, looks down on her because she is Black, and ultimately attacks Tom more out of pride than love for Louisa. In this story, Louisa is reduced to an object that two men fight over; her love is something to be possessed.