logo

64 pages 2 hours read

Michael Harriot

Black AF History: The Un-Whitewashed Story of America

Nonfiction | Book | Adult | Published in 2023

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Chapters 7-10Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 7 Summary: “The Black Emancipation Proclamation”

Chapter 7 opens with an excerpt from an imagined Black Emancipation Proclamation, titled “The Unanimous Declaration of ‘These Hands’” by the Black Folks of America. This proclamation borrows the language of America’s original Emancipation Proclamation but centers on the Black experience, detailing the injustices visited on enslaved people and pointing out that democracy requires the consent of the governed, an institution undermined by the mere existence of slavery.

In 1935, W. E. B. Du Bois published Black Reconstruction in America, a work that challenged the traditional narrative of seeing the post-Civil War Reconstruction era as a failure. Among other arguments, Du Bois put forth that enslaved Black people won the war against enslavers by “removing themselves from the economy that funded their proposed white supremacist empire” (160). In his model, enslaved people freed America, instead of the other way around.

Pre-Civil War, the economic force of the enslaved class was enormous. Essential to the production of food and cotton, enslaved people also existed as assets, leveraged to secure mortgages on land and as surety on loans. Their combined worth was $3.5 billion, four times the total of all the money in America.

However, the existence of enslaved people was an international embarrassment as well as a national security risk. Any enemy of America could depend on millions of allies within the country if they offered freedom in exchange for their help. In 1828, during the discord that led to the Civil War, the enslaver states introduced a bill that proposed states’ ability to nullify federal laws altogether. The North’s rejection of this bill, among other factors, ultimately led to slave-owning states seceding from the union. Unacknowledged by traditional narratives, however, are the “Black revolutionaries who escalated the national discord” (163). Harriot defines the Underground Railroad, or enslaved people “stealing” themselves from the slave economy, as the most momentous Black uprising since the Haitian Revolution. John Brown, a white man, attacked the US Arsenal at Harper’s Ferry in 1859 with a crew of 20 insurgents in order to arm Black people and upend the power structure. Both Harriet Tubman and Frederick Douglass supported Brown by passing messages, giving intel, and donating money to his cause.

After the Civil War began, the Black rebellion against enslavers continued, even among the Black people conscripted as cooks and servants into the Confederate Army. Robert Smalls, an enslaved man conscripted as a naval helmsman, snuck his entire enslaved crew past Confederate waters and surrendered to the Union. Later, Smalls became one of the first Black men elected to Congress. Harriet Tubman teamed up with Union Major General David Hunter in 1861. Her experience in guiding enslaved people to freedom through the Underground Railroad made her a treasure trove of intel, as well as a priceless reconnaissance agent who could map out an area, gather intelligence from enslaved people, and return with fugitives from slavery to bolster the Union’s numbers. Tubman became the first woman to lead a US military operation, attacking and burning three huge plantations and escaping with more than 700 freed Black people.

Fugitives from slavery were held in contraband camps, legally seen as confiscated goods until the Emancipation Proclamation of 1862. This proclamation was an afterthought, however, since many enslaved people had already begun self-emancipating. These free Black people dealt the South “devastating financial losses” (172). Their intellectual property of farming skills was the entire basis for the billion-dollar agriculture industry in the South. Without enslaved people, the enslavers had no way to replicate their efforts, and without money, their secession quickly crumbled: “The people who were enslaved were the power and the might of the South” (173).

Supplement: “The Lost Cause, Explained”

This supplement involves the author explaining a difficult topic to a character named Racist Baby, a 5-year-old raised by racist parents. In typical humorous fashion, Harriot breaks down the racist myth of the “Lost Cause,” the idea that the Civil War was not about slavery and was in fact a noble fight for state’s rights against an overreaching government. In the process, Harriot introduces the Ku Klux Klan and the United Daughters of the Confederacy, two organizations that, through vastly different methods, idealized the antebellum South and downplayed the brutality of slavery.

Chapter 7 Unit Review

This quiz asks about the causes of the Civil War, the best two-word description of the Confederacy, and what would have been the Confederate States of America’s largest export. The activity asks the reader to rank a list of hypothetical negative effects of the South winning the Civil War from “worst to worse-er” (186).

Chapter 8 Summary: “Construction”

This chapter covers the efforts of Black people to construct success for themselves after the Civil War. Although Reconstruction is often portrayed as a brief time of gains in liberty followed by victimization by racist white people, “Black America” used the Reconstruction era to redefine the South in ways that could not be erased.

After the Civil War started, many enslaved people emancipated themselves. In order to punish the traitor enslavers, President Lincoln gave their land to freed enslaved people through Brigadier General Rufus Saxton. He distributed confiscated land to formerly enslaved people in 40-acre allotments. However, after Lincoln’s assassination, Confederate sympathizer Andrew Johnson became president and gave the land back to the Confederate traitors in return for an oath of allegiance.

The now disenfranchised Black people turned to the Freedmen’s Bureau, a federal agency run by General Oliver Howard. Howard, unable to undo Johnson’s order, instead set a minimum wage for Black laborers and formalized contracts between those laborers and their employers. Now paid for their labor, the Black people could save to purchase their own land. The Freedmen’s Bureau also started more than 1,000 Black schools to educate and empower the next generation of free Black people. In 1868, two amendments to the Constitution were ratified, guaranteeing citizenship to formerly enslaved people and giving them the right to vote. Now Black people had political power, which they exercised enthusiastically. This led to violent backlash from what Harriot calls the “cowards” of white America. Violent mobs sought to terrorize the Black citizens of Southern states in order to reestablish the racist antebellum status quo. They also used legal technicalities to disenfranchise Black voters, creating vague laws that could jail a person for things like “rambling without a job” (204). Voter intimidation, fraud, and other forms of “cheating” pervaded state and federal elections, trying to disenfranchise Black voters. This culminated in a federal agreement to placate the white supremacists. Among other things, Southern states were given the “right to handle Black people as they wish” (205), a policy later called Jim Crow.

These racist policies did not erase the institutions of education, religion, and political power that Black people created in the Reconstruction era. These institutions would act as a framework for all civil rights victories moving forward.

Chapter 8 Unit Review

This quiz concerns the rewards for formerly enslaved people after the Civil War, the institutions that only existed after emancipation, and the desires of freedmen after emancipation. The activity asks the reader to write a letter from the perspective of an enslaver, trying to convince the people they formerly enslaved to keep working for them.

Chapter 9 Summary: “Something Else”

Chapter 9 delves deeper into the racial violence and white supremacy in the South in the 20th century. A racist backlash to the Reconstruction era saw many openly racist and violent lynching supporters elected to public office. They argued that since the North would not support their white supremacy, they had to resort to “something else” (212). That something else was an escalation in violence against Black people, in different yet equally horrific forms.

Sam Hose, an intelligent, self-educated freedman, who worked as a fieldhand to support his family, defended himself from his employer Alfred Cranford, who pointed a gun at him after Hose requested time off. Hose threw an ax at the man, killing him, then immediately fled, knowing that he had no chance at justice. After his capture, a mob of 500 people kidnapped Hose from deputies and gruesomely tortured him to death. They cut off his fingers, nose, and genitals, then skinned him and burned him alive.

Between 1889 and 1922, the NAACP recorded 3,436 lynchings, a rate of two per week. They defined lynching as an incident in which the victim dies, where three or more people took part in the killing, the execution was extrajudicial, though often facilitated by law enforcement, and there was some reason for the lynching, however trivial.

After a brutal lynching in Memphis, Ida B. Wells, the famous Black journalist, took up the cause to pursue justice. She encouraged Black citizens of Memphis to flee and those who couldn’t to save up until they could. She called out the oft-repeated myth that Black men raped white women whenever they could and remained unmoved by the threats she received for doing so. She quickly became the “undisputed leader of the anti-lynching movement” (220).

She also called out other, more moderate Black activists, like Booker T. Washington and W. E. B. Du Bois, for implying that Black people had to improve to be accepted by white people, as if the problem was Black people and not white violence. She also argued with white women like Frances Willard, a suffragist and friend of Wells, after Willard stated that Black people should not be allowed to drink alcohol or vote and should return to Africa. Wells published a scathing response to Willard’s arguments, and after Willard did not back down, Wells published a long pamphlet called The Red Record, a brutal and eloquent description of lynching culture that called out Willard by name for her harmful stereotypes.

Wells was denied the same kind of fame that Washington and Du Bois had, most likely because she refused to capitulate to white fragility, often criticizing her white benefactors. Her journalistic integrity, however, struck a crippling blow to the apologetics of lynching and race-based violence in general.

Chapter 9 Unit Review

This quiz asks about the causes of racial terrorism during Reconstruction, the biggest myths about lynching, and the parts of a lynch mob. The activity asks the reader to define a list of different incidents of actual racial violence as “lynching or nah” (227).

Supplement: “The Difference Between Soul Food and Southern Cuisine”

This supplement spells out the difference between soul food and Southern food, categories that are frequently confused. The identity of the cook, the type of seasoning, the method of cooking, the different ingredients, preparations, results, and appearance are all discussed in determining the difference.

Summary of Chapter 10: “Whites Gone Wild”

Chapter 10 introduces the character of Uncle Rob, the author’s erudite uncle who is well-known and beloved for his wide-ranging knowledge and turn of phrase. Uncle Rob “interrupts” Harriot to explain why a Black person should fear, above all else, “an American.”

Uncle Rob states that, though the political definition of an American has changed constantly, the most accurate definition is “not Black people” (235). He points out that the US Constitution defines a Black person as worth 60% of a white man and it also denied naturalization to all but white immigrants. It even denied American citizenship to the original inhabitants of America until 1924. Racial violence against Black people is perpetrated almost exclusively by white people who think of themselves as the “real Americans.” Uncle Rob argues that vigilante groups like the Ku Klux Klan reinforced white supremacy in the South. When the federal government sent troops down to defend Black Americans, the white supremacist groups only grew more radicalized, becoming trained paramilitary units.

Uncle Rob, however, warns against thinking that racism is only a Southern concern, stating that there’s no one more racist than a “Northerner who thinks they’re racism-free” (238). Though they did not institute slavery, the North was still segregated, the Union Army was separated into racial companies, and Black voters were regularly disenfranchised in different states. Uncle Rob contends that, in the Plessy v. Ferguson case of 1892, which concerned the segregation of railway cars, the Supreme Court ruled in favor of white supremacy. They argued that segregation was not inequality, and this decision freed many Southern states to enshrine racism into their state laws, such as racist voting acts that required a pre-voting literacy test for everyone except people entitled to vote before 1867 (i.e., white people). Uncle Rob points out that Black people were not eager to hang out in white spaces with white people. Their opposition to the Plessy v. Ferguson ruling was instead rooted in the fact that they simply wanted to be able to defend themselves against the objective oppression of their people by white people.

Because of his conciliatory principles, Booker T. Washington became a favorite of white elites and was even invited to dine at the White House. Other Black leaders criticized him for his “respectability politics.” Despite being criticized by Ida B. Wells for the same thing, Du Bois disagreed with Washington’s optimism. He believed that Black people’s ability to politically, culturally, and physically defend themselves from white supremacy and white violence was the only way to encourage a “growth of democracy” for Black people and for the South in general (251).

Chapter 10 Unit Review

The quiz covers the flaws in the “separate but equal” argument, the biggest myth about Jim Crow, and the most toxic traits of historical figures. The activity instructs the reader to construct a racially equitable education system, not on paper but in real life.

Supplement: “Funny AF”

This supplement covers Charles Case, America’s first stand-up comedian. In an age of minstrel shows, in which white people wore blackface to perform cartoonish stereotypes of Black Americans, Case rose to prominence. Despite being mixed-race, he passed as white and was able to enter segregated beer halls and bars as he traveled. At first, he wore blackface and played the banjo. Later, however, he dispensed with all accompaniments and simply told stories on the stage to a riveted audience. He was a celebrated monologist of the vaudeville era. Harriot states that, though Mark Twain is often credited with being the first proto-comedian who performed stand-up, Charles Case is actually the first.

Chapters 7-10 Analysis

Chapters 7 through 10 shed light on Black history in America during and after the Civil War. From enslaved people stealing themselves from the slave economy in order to financially cripple the enslavers, to figures like Harriet Tubman and Robert Smalls committing historic acts of defiance against the Confederacy, the narrative showcases the relentless Creativity and Resilience in Black American Culture as Black people worked to secure their freedom and rights.

Enslaved individuals are shown to be active agents in their struggle for freedom, whether through acts of rebellion, self-emancipation, or collaboration with abolitionist movements. The narrative challenges traditional narratives that portray Black people as passive victims by highlighting their agency and resilience. The Erasure of Black Contributions to American Culture is a recurring theme in Black AF History, an erasure that clearly goes hand in hand with a whitewashed, sanitized version of history that minimizes slavery and violence and romanticizes an idealized fantasy of the antebellum South. In that vein, Harriot dedicates much analysis to The Effects of Systemic Racism, focusing on the pervasive influence of racism and white supremacy over the course of US history. From the institutionalized brutality of slavery to the violent backlash against Reconstruction and the rise of organizations like the Ku Klux Klan, the narrative exposes the deep-rooted nature of racial oppression in American society. It also examines the ways in which racism manifests in different forms, including legal discrimination, extrajudicial violence via lynching, and systemic injustice including voter disenfranchisement.

The text frequently employs the literary device of parallelism to draw comparisons between historical events and to highlight recurring patterns. For example, Harriot draws parallels between the resistance movements of enslaved people before and during the Civil War to underscore the continuity of struggle across different periods of history. The text makes extensive use of allusions to historical figures, events, and documents to provide context and enrich the narrative. References to individuals like Harriet Tubman, Frederick Douglass, and John Brown serve to contextualize the actions of key figures within broader historical movements. Harriot also employs irony to critique and subvert dominant narratives about American history. For instance, the irony of enslaved individuals being legally categorized by the Union Army as “contraband,” or confiscated goods, highlights the absurdity of their dehumanization within the legal system. In a similar vein, the Unit Reviews after each chapter serve to draw out the contradictions and logical gaps in racist and white supremacist ideology. The essay prompts, for instance, range from perplexing (e.g., write a letter pretending to be an enslaver who is trying to convince formerly enslaved people to return to slavery) to absurd (e.g., construct a racially equitable education system in the real world). The effect is that Harriot underscores the absurdity and illogic of white supremacy. The supplements also enhance the accessibility of the text by covering pop culture topics such as those related to food and entertainment. These supplements have the effect of undoing some of The Erasure of Black Contributions to American Culture by presenting concrete information about the contributions of Black people to American culture.

Land ownership recurs as a motif, symbolizing not only economic power but also freedom and self-determination. The distribution of confiscated land to formerly enslaved individuals during Reconstruction symbolizes a radical reconfiguration of power dynamics in the aftermath of emancipation. Education, symbolizing empowerment and liberation, also points to the changing power dynamics. The establishment of Black schools by organizations like the Freedmen’s Bureau represents Black creativity and resilience as Black people uplift and empower themselves in the face of continued legal persecution. By centering on the stories of individuals who defied oppression and fought for freedom, the text challenges dominant narratives that seek to erase or diminish the contributions of Black Americans to American history.

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text