logo

48 pages 1 hour read

James Ramsey Ullman

Banner In The Sky

Fiction | Novel | Middle Grade | Published in 1954

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.

Character Analysis

Rudi Matt

Rudi Matt is the 16-year-old protagonist of the novel. He is “small and slim” (11) but quick. He has delicate features and a “fair, pink-and-white complexion” (11), so boys tease him, calling him “angel face.” While this makes Rudi insecure at the beginning of the novel, he becomes more confident as he learns that his masculinity rests in his courage, not his appearance. Throughout his adventure, Rudi learns that Saxo, although he appears strong and powerful, is not honorable. On the other hand, while Franz and Winter might be less imposing, they are good leaders and have honor. Rudi still wrestles with selfishness when he leaves Winter and Franz to pursue Saxo. While he wants to leave Saxo to finish climbing, he knows that “two wrongs did not make a right” (267) and redeems his mistake by helping Saxo down the mountain.

Rudi’s strong sense of duty comes primarily from his father’s legacy. While Rudi never met his father, he clings to his legacy and what little he left behind—his shrine in the woods and his red flannel shirt. By advancing even farther than his father did and showing that he, too, is honorable, Rudi matures from a child to an adult.

Rudi is drawn to climbing despite his mother’s wishes. Although he doesn’t want to be disobedient, he can’t stay away from the mountains. Over the course of the novel, he learns when to take risks and make decisions for himself and when to follow the wisdom of others. For example, when Rudi initially disobeys his uncle and Winter while climbing, he learns from this mistake. Throughout the ascent of the Citadel, he follows the other climbers, asking to try climbing through the Needle only after the other climbers give up. While Rudi’s ambition creates conflicts, it is an essential ingredient to the story and makes climbing the Citadel possible.

Captain John Winter

Captain John Winter is an important character in Rudi’s journey. He is a famous English climber in his 30s who is “very tall and thin” (31) with a “hawklike nose and a strong jutting chin” (31). His face is tanned like Rudi wishes his could be. While Winter is the “foremost mountaineer of the breadth of the Alps” (32) and has made many famous ascents, he is not bulky or domineering like Saxo. He speaks softly and carries authority and calm with him.

Winter’s peace under pressure makes a strong impression on Rudi. When he is stuck in the crevasse, he calmly navigates the situation, and Rudi thinks that he is “a real man. A brave man” (27). Winter’s character demonstrates that masculinity doesn’t need to be domineering but can build up others. Winter is the first person to believe in Rudi and defend his desire to climb. When Franz and Saxo argue with Rudi for bringing his staff, Winter points out that he used it to save his life (187). The other men argue about which town is better than the other, but Winter manages to bring them together to a victorious climb. He is a true leader, insisting on risking himself before others. So much of Winter’s energy is devoted to leading the group that it exhausts him during the climb. While the captain is physically injured, Rudi thinks that his “expenditure of will and spirit that had made the climb possible” (228) drained him. Despite his weakness, Winter is inspired to help find Rudi, which drives him to the top of the mountain. Winter is a static character.

Old Teo

Old Teo is the cook who works at the hotel where Rudi is a dishwasher. He is introduced as an old man with a limp but was once a great mountaineer who climbed the Citadel with Josef Matt and Sir Edward Stephenson on the day of their accident. Despite his past, Teo still sees the beauty in mountain climbing and encourages Rudi, covering for him when he leaves. Instead of feeling burdened with extra work, “in his old heart he was glad” (12).

Teo is an essential part of Rudi’s development. While Winter is preparing and Franz is off on his own climbs, Teo takes time off work to train Rudi in climbing. He risks his own safety “without a murmur” (87). Had Rudi not practiced and trained with Teo, he might not have made it up the Citadel safely.

Teo not only believes in Rudi’s skill but also stands up for his need to be his own person. He scolds Franz for trying to “make him into something he is not” (175) and toasts Rudi’s courage. He reminds Rudi of the importance of patience and learning from others, even in the pursuit of his dreams. Old Teo is a static character who is loyal to Rudi’s development.

Franz Lerner

Franz Lerner is Rudi’s uncle, a famous Alpine guide. While Franz spends time in the mountains, he doesn’t dare trying to summit the Citadel, claiming that God is saving it for himself. Winter sees that while he is “full of old taboos and traditions” (135), Franz wants to conquer the Citadel in his heart. Not until he hears Saxo mock the people of Kurtal does Franz declare that he is going to climb the mountain.

Franz has an intense sense of duty and honor. When Rudi gets stuck on the Wunderhorn, Franz insists on getting him since he is “my responsibility” (169). He insists on staying with Winter when he is injured, telling Saxo that he does not “deserve to be called a guide” (232) if he climbs alone. Franz cares for Rudi like a father—he won’t leave the mountain without him. Franz is a dynamic character who slowly softens throughout the novel. While he initially tries to keep Rudi from climbing, he slowly allows him more freedom. He also humbles himself, allowing Saxo to take the lead, something Rudi “had never before seen” (207). While the journey up the Citadel is primarily about Rudi’s development, Franz also develops.

Frau Ilse Matt

Rudi’s mother, Ilse Matt, was widowed as a young woman. Although her “widowhood had faded her” (43), Ilse was one of the “beauties of Kurtal” and is still attractive. She has the same “fine features and light complexion as her son” (43). Ilse is a minor character but still changes during the novel. At the beginning of the story, she is frantic at the idea of Rudi climbing, hoping to protect him from her husband’s fate. Toward the end, she realizes that she was trying to make Rudi someone he isn’t. At the end of the novel, they share a special moment together. While they don’t speak, they reach a mutual understanding, and she respects Rudi and the courage he inherited from her husband.

Emil Saxo

Emil Saxo is a famous Alpine guide who lives in the neighboring, rival town of Broli. He has an impressive physique that aids his climbing. When Rudi first meets him, Saxo is described as a “giant” (101) and later as a “great tiger.” While Saxo proves his skill, he is immature and proud. He constantly mocks the Kurtalers as being “afraid of their own skins” (101), claiming they are “no mountaineers” (164). This prejudice blinds Saxo to the skill in front of him. Rudi makes it past the Fortress before anyone else and knows that the southeast ridge goes to the top—yet Saxo still doesn’t want to follow that route.

Saxo’s pride gets in the way of his honor. To him, being the first to reach the top of the Citadel is more important than anything else, which is why he is willing to abandon the others at camp to reach it. He demonstrates what Rudi could become if he continually gave in to his selfish impulses. In the end, Saxo is a dynamic character who is moved by Rudi’s sacrifice for him. On his last appearance in the novel, he salutes Rudi and shakes his hand, after having mocked him for not being “a grown man” (106) less than a week prior. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text