All the Colors of the Dark

1. General Impressions

Gather initial thoughts and broad opinions about the book.

• Consider Patch’s various crimes and run-ins with the law. In your opinion, to what extent are his actions justified?
• The novel deals with the enduring impact of trauma. How accurately do you think Whitaker portrays these effects? 

2. Personal Reflection and Connection 

Connect the book’s themes and characters to personal experiences and perspectives.

• Consider a friendship where you grew apart over time or found yourself with different values and beliefs as adults. How does this experience inform your opinions about Saint’s struggle to balance her duties to the law with her desire to see her old friend? 
• All the Colors of the Dark draws on the specific setting of the Ozarks, but many of the dynamics there are common in small towns. Have you ever lived in a small community? How did your experience compare to the books’ characters?
• As with many thrillers, appearances can be deceiving in All the Colors of the Dark. Consider a situation in your life where someone turned out to be different than you thought—for better or for worse. How does that situation compare to the novel’s depictions of Patch or Jimmy?

3. Societal and Cultural Context 

Examine the book’s relevance to broader societal issues, cultural trends, and ethical dilemmas.

• Does Whitaker present an objective or a biased stance on the topic of abortion? In your response, consider Misty’s activism and Saint’s ambivalence on the issue, as well as the actions of Tooms and other male characters.
• Analyze Saint’s relationship with her grandmother, Norma. What role(s) does each character embody within the context of women’s struggle for autonomy?
• How does Saint both defy and conform to the pressures of misogyny that dominate the cultural fabric of her hometown?

4. Literary Analysis

Dive into the book’s structure, characters, themes, and use of narrative techniques.

• How does the meaning of the novel’s pirate imagery shift over the course of Patch’s life?
• How does Patch’s relationship with Misty progress, and what ultimately holds him back?
• While the novel is arguably a bildungsroman, Patch and Saint retain many of the emotions and regrets that they accumulated in the coming-of-age process. How do their adult selves mirror their original childish perceptions.
• Analyze the author’s use of foreshadowing, particularly when it comes to early descriptions of Aaron. What clues does Whitaker leave to indicate Aaron’s guilt?
• Consider Saint’s transition from childhood beekeeper to lifetime law enforcement officer. What compels her to change so drastically, and how does her compulsion to investigate alter the course of her life?

5. Creative Engagement

Encourage imaginative and creative connections to the book’s content and themes.

• If All the Colors of the Dark were to be adapted as a film, which scene or subplot would most likely be omitted? Why?
• Choose one character whose motives are less than clear and write a letter from their perspective, in which they explain their actions to someone important to them.

Need more inspiration for your next meeting? Browse all of our Book Club Resources.