42 pages • 1 hour read
Alicia ElliottA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Elliott’s 12th essay addresses the non-Native Canadian expectations of what a Native person is, and the harm of said Canadians gatekeeping what it means to be Indigenous. She dives into “literary colonialism” to illustrate the catch-22 of being Native in Canada, providing numerous examples of Native writers whose success is criticized as being too Native or not Native enough for the topics they address. Many non-Native Canadian “settlers” explain away Native writers’ successes as being based on white colonial guilt: a pity-prize rather than something earned. These colonial ideals and myths persist because non-Native Canadians refuse to face the falsehoods and harm of their national myths of pleasant assimilation. If they were to address these falsehoods, their national identity would start to fall apart. Elliott ends the chapter with a scathing critique of Canadian Prime Ministers, providing details on the ways they’ve failed Native Canadians and pandered to Indigenous communities without following through on their promises.
The 12th essay expands significantly on the theme of Canada’s social, systemic, and institutional failings when it comes to Indigenous Canadians. It does so by focusing mainly on two domains: Canada’s literary world and its politics. Elliott describes non-Native Canadians seeking to control who has access to the status of Indigeneity. She then transitions to how this is reflected in the wider Canadian literary scene, finishing with the unreliable commitments of the Canadian government. Elliott thus gives the reader a look at this theme on several scales, individually and collectively. This gradual scaling up as she nears the end of her essay collection has been paved by the background she builds in the beginning. After establishing this background, she zooms into her own life more intimately before opening wider than ever to provide a sense of the weight that her personal stories hold as representations of the struggles of so many other Indigenous people. As she is not at the end of the book yet, this essay balances the personal with the societal more equally than the following essay, and in doing so, provides additional depth to her theme of Indigenous oppression by state actors.
Canadian Literature
View Collection
Colonialism & Postcolonialism
View Collection
Colonialism Unit
View Collection
Contemporary Books on Social Justice
View Collection
Essays & Speeches
View Collection
Feminist Reads
View Collection
Indigenous People's Literature
View Collection
Mental Illness
View Collection
Popular Book Club Picks
View Collection