72 pages • 2 hours read
P. Djèlí ClarkA modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more.
Fatma and Hadia get acquainted in a coffee shop. The 24-year-old Hadia spent two years teaching in America before coming to Cairo, to put her comparative alchemy degree to good use. Fatma has managed to avoid working with a partner thus far, despite agency pressure, but Hadia, the newest female recruit of four total in the ministry, requested the partnership specifically.
Hoping to win Fatma’s favor, Hadia produces a folder of sketches of the crime scene obtained via a cousin on the force. Fatma studies them eagerly. Hadia points out that a lone female victim appears to be an “idolator,” a worshipper of an ancient Egyptian religion, and therefore speculates that human sacrifice might be involved—Fatma cuts her off, snapping at her about the importance of evidence, then stands to leave, hoping for a reassignment in the morning.
When Fatma arrives home, she calls out to her cat, Ramses, only for a human voice to answer. A woman clad in black is already in her dark apartment. The woman explains that she climbed in through the window to avoid the nosy doorman. Fatma identifies the woman as Siti, a past lover, who she has not seen in over a month; the two kiss before going to bed together.
Early the next morning, Ramses claws at Siti’s shoulder, causing Siti to remark that half the cats in the city are probably disguised djinn. Though Fatma is pleased to see the woman she feared would be only a summer fling, she knows Siti had come to Cairo on business. Siti admits she has been sent by the temple of Hathor, one of the idolatrous ancient Egyptian gods, to deliver a message concerning the event at the Worthington estate. A priestess of Hathor wishes to meet with Fatma the next day.
Siti claims that she would have visited even if she had not been delivering a message, and the two fall asleep. Fatma wakes alone, a folded note left on the pillow.
The next morning, Fatma wakes refreshed despite only having slept a few hours. Per Siti’s invitation in the note, she heads to the small Nubian eatery run by Siti’s family to meet her. As Fatma waits, she chats with Madame Aziza, a sister of Siti’s grandmother; the old woman remarks that Siti has “[t]oo much of her father in her” (56). Fatma doesn’t reply, knowing that Siti never knew her father.
Siti and Fatma travel to Old Cairo, where Siti remarks that supposedly an angel exists—angels appeared shortly after the djinn but were more enigmatic. Fatma briefly recalls a case concerning an angel named Maker, but she doesn’t dwell on the thought. They find the priestess, Merira, along with an elemental djinn named Minya, in a fortune teller’s shop. Merira takes them through a hidden passage into the temple of Hathor, where they meet a man who introduces himself as Lord Sobek, the Egyptian crocodile-headed god; Merira introduces him instead as Ahmad, the high priest of the Cult of Sobek.
Two victims at the Worthington estate were clergy of the Egyptian gods, the priestess being Ahmad’s divine consort. Worthington’s secret society was founded in the late 1890s after Worthington brokered peace with the British; as the group consisted of mostly British members, he had trouble recruiting Muslims, Copts, and Soudanese. However, being outcasts themselves, the Egyptian cults were more willing to join. In return, however, the cults demanded that he contribute funding for a real temple; Siti’s travels were an effort to find a suitable location.
Merira wants to cooperate, hoping to mitigate damages when the public learns of the cults’ connection to Worthington; however, she doesn’t know much. When Fatma asks about the burns, Minya appears and voices her suspicion that her cousins, the Ifrit, had a hand in them. Powerful fire elementals, the Ifrit have kept to themselves for the past 40 years.
Outside, Fatma comments on Ahmad’s belief that he is Lord Sobek. Siti suggests he may be in direct communion with the entombed god. Fatma further comments that opening a public temple would be a bad idea, as Egyptians haven’t even adjusted to the djinn, let alone to the idea of entombed gods. Siti draws comparisons between hiding her religious beliefs and Fatma hiding their relationship.
The two acknowledge the fight and recover, agreeing to meet at The Spot later that night.
Fatma returns to the Ministry of Alchemy, Enchantments, and Supernatural Entities, housed in a living building built by djinn. Hamed, a fellow agent, asks about the case, assuming Fatma’s involvement implies something supernatural, but she tells him not to put stock in rumors. He mentions an office pool for betting on how long before Fatma runs off her new partner.
Suddenly remembering Hadia, Fatma heads to her office only to find a second desk. Fatma immediately goes to the director, Amir, who has been expecting her. Amir refuses to budge, arguing that the pair-up, however unpleasant Fatma finds it, is for her own good. Moreover, he reveals that with recent progress in women’s rights, including suffrage, the Ministry “can’t be seen lagging” (75) on recruitment of women—yet Hadia is only the fifth recruit they have. Fatma returns to her office and, realizing the few women in the department can’t be seen fighting, agrees to work with Hadia.
Hadia produces information on the fire victims that she obtained from the police. All the names on the list are English, but two victims remain unidentified. Fatma correctly guesses that the unidentified bodies include the woman and one other man, then explains to Hadia the information she learned from the idolators, although she leaves out names. Hadia is shocked at the potential involvement of Ifrit.
Finally, Fatma formally welcomes Hadia to the ministry.
The Role of Illusions and Expectations in Society continues to be a prominent theme. Clark’s role reversals in common tropes is part of that. Hadia fills a common trope in crime fiction, the eager and generally unwelcome (at least initially) partner to a lone-wolf detective. Traditionally, these roles would both be male characters. Fatma’s lover is also a woman. Upsetting these expectations in his foundational chapters lays groundwork for the theme throughout the rest of the novel.
In addition, all of the characters are wrestling with prejudices, trying to find their footing in society despite the expectations about them—or by using those expectations to their advantage. Compounding that, the main characters are not immune to making assumptions either. Hadia, based merely on what she “had heard,” suggests that the idolators could be behind the murders, even performing human sacrifice; in the moment, Fatma reacts coldly to this suggestion, but perhaps mainly because her relationship with Siti has disabused her of such stereotypes. Sure enough, Merira, an idolator priestess, reveals that the two idolators had joined Lord Worthington’s brotherhood only in an effort to gain funding for a temple. Prejudices, driven by expectations, are rampant, an integral part of this society. Yet the diversity of the main characters, while not making them flawless, does make them inclined toward empathy and a tendency to overcome their own assumptions. Hadia, for example, is immediately repentant and apologizes. Fatma, in turn, rethinks her harsh reaction to Hadia’s desk being in her originally private office: “[s]he gave Hadia a hard look, remembering her own arrival in the office. How might she have felt, to be rebuffed by the only woman agent here?” (76).
The gender politics at play in the Ministry also become more explicit, exhibiting a more mundane attempt at maintaining illusions. Amir matches two of only five women together as partners, a bit of misdirection to present an image of his department as supportive to women. In doing so, he draws Fatma into the situation, and the public perception of the Ministry in part rests on her standing in as symbolic of women in general. With the entire office waiting to see the two women fight, Fatma reflects on her own past experiences as a young female agent and resolves to shatter their expectations by cooperating with Hadia. Fatma’s decision not only strengthens the bond between partners, but also hints at Fatma’s working knowledge of illusions, foreshadowing the fact that she will be able to see through magical facades later in the book.
By P. Djèlí Clark
Appearance Versus Reality
View Collection
Black History Month Reads
View Collection
Challenging Authority
View Collection
Fantasy
View Collection
Historical Fiction
View Collection
LGBTQ Literature
View Collection
Mystery & Crime
View Collection
Power
View Collection
Science Fiction & Dystopian Fiction
View Collection
The Best of "Best Book" Lists
View Collection