logo

84 pages 2 hours read

Melissa Fleming

A Hope More Powerful Than the Sea

Nonfiction | Biography | Adult | Published in 2017

A modern alternative to SparkNotes and CliffsNotes, SuperSummary offers high-quality Study Guides with detailed chapter summaries and analysis of major themes, characters, and more. For select classroom titles, we also provide Teaching Guides with discussion and quiz questions to prompt student engagement.

Chapters 1-3Chapter Summaries & Analyses

Chapter 1 Summary: “A Childhood in Syria”

Adrift in a hostile sea, Doaa Al Zamel nearly drowns for the second time. Her husband already drowned. Doaa is cold, dehydrated, and so “overcome with grief” (6) that she remains alive only by the need to save the two baby girls she clings to her chest. There is no land in sight, only debris and bloated corpses.

Thirteen years earlier, Doaa had nearly drowned for the first time. A stubborn young girl, Doaa had always refused to learn how to swim. When she was six years old and on vacation with her family, her cousin picked her up and threw her in the water. She floundered, and a relative fished her out and took her to her mother. The six-year-old Doaa “had nothing in the world to fear” (6). She lives with her extended family in Daraa, the largest city in southwest Syria. Though noted for its bounteous harvests, the region will suffer a terrible drought in 2007 which lasts three years, laying the foundations of civil unrest which will uproot Doaa’s family. But in 2001, it is a peaceful city. The recent succession of Bashar al-Assad to the country’s leadership fills people with optimism; they hope that he is less oppressive that his father, Hafez. Bashar al-Assad, an Alawite Muslim, is married to Asma, a Sunni Muslim. The country considers this marriage a merger between demographics, and Bashar’s western education informs his more secular politics. For 48 years, Bashar’s father had used emergency government powers to run an oppressive, authoritarian regime. Hafez dealt with any challenges to this power in a brutal fashion.

The market in Daraa is a congregating point for locals and visitors, including many from across the nearby border with Jordan. Doaa’s family shares their home with aunts, uncles, and the extended family. They have a large courtyard and a rooftop terrace. Shokri, Doaa’s father, works long hours in his barbershop. He married Hanaa, Doaa’s mother, when they were both 17. Doaa has three older sisters; after four daughters, Shokri’s family worried Hanaa would never give him a son and advised him to remarry. He refused. From a very young age, a visiting relative marked Doaa as special and Shokri’s family soon learns to accept his decision. A shy girl, Doaa nevertheless enchants everyone she meets.

When Hanaa gives birth to two more girls, Shokri’s gossiping family begins to complain again. The house is becoming increasingly crowded by the large families, too big for the communal meals which had once brought them such joy. Eventually, the crowded living situation and the constant malicious gossip becomes too much for Hanaa. She tells Shokri to find them a new home. Shokri gives up his job as a barber and begins to transport goods across the Jordanian border in the family’s beat-up yellow Peugeot. He is gone all day, every day. But one day, he does not come home at all. Shokri gets arrested and thrown in jail in Jordan for breaking the import laws. The family cannot afford a lawyer, nor can they afford to live without Shokri. After four months, the family eventually manages to pay a lawyer in Jordan to help bribe the right officials. Finally, Shokri gains a pardon. He returns to his work as a barber. Eventually, they find a small apartment and leave the large communal home.

The family’s new apartment is in a poor neighborhood. They clean and repair what they can. But while the older family members love their newfound freedom, Doaa misses her cousins and old school. Her shyness returns. By 2004, however, she has grown accustomed to the new life. Furthermore, she has a new baby brother named Mohammad who is nicknamed Hamudi. When the owner of their apartment decides that they have to leave, they must move again. Though the new apartment is nicer, Doaa once again mourns the loss of her old home and her old friends. It takes her a long time to make new ones. Now a teenager, she soon realizes that “the life of a traditional Syrian girl [is] not going to be enough” (13). Her teachers raise her awareness of Syria’s formative feminist movement. For years, she has helped in her father’s barbershop and wants to support her family in a professional capacity. Her older sisters marry but Doaa has no interest in marriage. Much to her parents’ horror, Doaa decides to become a policewoman. A trip to Damascus only solidifies this dream. But in 2010, the family gathers around a small television to watch the news of a protest in Tunisia. It is the beginning of what will soon be known as the Arab Spring. Life in Syria is about to change forever. 

Chapter 2 Summary: “The War Begins”

By February 2011, the Syrian people have seen people across the Middle East rise up and overturn oppressive regimes. The uprising in Tunisia has “made it seem to ordinary Syrians that anything is possible” (15). After Tunisia came Egypt, Libya, and Yemen. Now 16 years old, Doaa watches the reports of the fall of the regime in Egypt with her sisters. Syrians cheer the victory as if it were their own. Even in Daraa, traditionally a reliable support base for the Assad regime, there are whispers of an uprising, even though all previous attempts have failed tragically.

Protest graffiti begins to appear. Officers arrest the boys who painted the slogans—some of whom are known to Doaa and her family—and take them to the detention centers run by the feared intelligence services. By the next months, protests have spread through the once-quiet streets of Daraa. They join wider peaceful protests springing up across the country. Doaa watches the protesters from her house, intrigued and excited by their energy. The police break apart the protests with tear gas and water cannons. As people scream and run away, Doaa flees back into her house. But the protests do not stop. The police open fire on a group of demonstrators and kill four people.

The deaths make the international news. The United Nations condemns the violence against the protestors. The Syrian government blames the protestors for the eruption of violence. The boys arrested for graffiti get released, but signs of torture are unmistakable: “wounds left by electric cables that the guards had used as whips” (18), missing fingernails, and cigarette burns on their faces. This only incites further rage among the protestors. The government tries to reason with the protestors but fails, eventually accusing them of trying to overthrow the state. The government blames outside agitators and sends the security forces into the cities.

On Mother’s Day, “Doaa’s world [is] changed forever” (18). Breaking with family tradition, Hanaa insists that they stay home that day. But Doaa insists. She loves the annual family gathering. Hanaa relents and takes her children to the big family house; she tries to flag a taxi, thinking it the safest option. But the only taxi that stops insists on an incredible fee, saying that it is a risk fee. Hanaa has no choice but to pay. The nervous driver tries to avoid the military roadblocks. They pass a burning police station and smoke covers the car. Protestors appear from nowhere, throwing missiles at the fleeing policemen. The driver demands that they leave his taxi, telling the family to “keep close to the walls or they will shoot you” (19). Hanaa leads her children through the chaos as Doaa feels guilty. It was her insistence that had forced the family to leave the house. They run, bullets flying through the air around them. Fleeing through the streets, they stop, hide, crawl, and keep close to the walls. After an hour, they arrive at the family house. As the family huddles together in the back of the building, as far away from the violence as possible, Doaa runs to the rooftop terrace, determined to see everything.

Doaa watches as the protestors and the security forces clash. She sees policemen gun down protestors. The tear gas chokes her, burning her eyes. On seeing the dead protestors, she realizes that “everything she’d grown up believing about her country was wrong” (21). They try to spend the day as normal but, when walking home, see bloodstains on the pavement. After this day, the protests only grow in size and scale. Soon, they begin to demand a regime change. More and more soldiers arrive as the death toll rises. Doaa feels an urge to join the protests. With friends and family, she attends demonstrations. She attends meetings, social events where young people share their hopes for the future. She invents slogans to shout and makes revolution-themed jewelry for protestors to wear. Hanaa, worried for her daughter’s safety, would beg Doaa to be careful. But Doaa refuses to do nothing. Deep down, her mother is proud of her daughter’s courage. Doaa loses her shyness and fear of change. Shokri, too, can do nothing to stop his determined daughter. Soon, protests are a part of life in the neighborhood. In parliament, Assad attempts to downplay the deaths as isolated incidents. He blames Israel, terrorists, and the international television channels. He decries footage of dead protestors as fake news. The parliament applauds. Doaa realizes that her country is being torn apart.

The protests continue for months. Assad’s attempts to institute changes are no longer enough; the protestors demand that he leave office. They quickly realize that Assad’s changes are discrete attempts to fortify his position, changing the laws under the pretext of fighting “terrorism.” On a day known as Great Friday, protests in 20 cities become violent. Doaa protests in Daraa. At one chaotic demonstration, she hides a loudspeaker and a drum under her long clothes and runs home. Forced to hide in an abandoned building, she’s spotted when she finally breaks cover. Chased through the streets, she hammers on an unknown door and begs for sanctuary. A woman rushes her inside and Doaa stays there until dark. She sneaks home and tells her worried family what happened. Shokri, furious and terrified, forbids her from attending any more protests. Reluctantly, Doaa agrees, even though “her heart remained with the revolution” (27). 

Chapter 3 Summary: “The Siege of Daraa”

While hanging laundry on the morning of 25 April 2011, Doaa hears the distant rumble of tanks. She spots them heading toward her street, accompanied by an entire army. With her parents out of the house, Doaa gathers her siblings, nephews, and nieces inside and tries to phone her mother. She dials again and again with no answer. Hanaa arrives home later, Shokri even later still. At night, the government cuts off the electricity and the water to the houses. As the soldiers settle in for a long stay, the family listens for news on a battery-powered radio: They learn that Daraa is now under siege, the army sent in “to root out the terrorists who are trying to destroy the city” (30).

Early in the morning, Doaa awakes and hears gunfire in the street. Outside, soldiers are smashing down doors and dragging people from their homes. They round up and march away men and boys accused of being terrorists. Locked up in their home, the family must ration what little food and water they have. When the candles run out, they stay up at night from the sound of gunfire and screaming. A week passes; their only contact with the outside world is when soldiers kick in their door as often as three times a day. The soldiers threaten the young girls and ransack the house. For all her fear of capture, Doaa cannot help but feel rage at the way the soldiers treat her family. Nighttime raids become common; Shokri encourages his daughters to sleep fully clothed and with a knife, worried that soldiers might abduct or rape them. Doaa and her sisters form a pact: If any soldiers try to rape one of them, they must be prepared to kill.

During one raid, Doaa can no longer remain silent. She talks defiantly to a solider, who points a gun in her face. When he finally relents and leaves, Hanaa accuses Doaa of putting the entire family in danger. Doaa, too shaken by the encounter, doesn’t defend herself. On the 11th day, when the food finally runs out, the city receives a curfew. Women can leave at set hours to shop for food but must agree to a search. Shokri is incredulous and furious. But they have no choice but to accept. Hanaa ventures out and sees soldiers eating large meals while the citizens starve. Eventually, she returns with six loaves of bread, assisted by a seemingly helpful soldier. As the siege wears on, a number of soldiers seem friendlier than the others. They help the family when they can. One day, a man knocks desperately at the door. He has a gun and a kaffiyeh (a checkered scarf) tied around his face. Begging for help, he claims to be with the Free Syrian Army, a group of demonstrators who have banded together into an armed opposition. Doaa ushers him inside and comes up with a plan: They disguise him as a piece of furniture. Inevitably, soldiers arrive to search their house. They find nothing and leave; the rebel thanks the family and escapes, and Doaa feels “a sense of triumph and satisfaction” (35).

The government eventually announces that the siege is over. But by this time, the world has taken notice. Hundreds have died, thousands arrested or missing. World leaders demand that Syria receive sanctions if they continue to kill protestors. Bodies rot in the streets, schools remain shut, and soldiers destroy buildings. Shokri has to return to work, desperate to make money. Every day, his family worries for him. His barbershop is in a bad neighborhood and battles unfold between the government and the opposition every day. Clients are scared to come to him.

Doaa sees the bullet casings in the street and wishes that she could do more. The bombing begins; the family watches artillery shells fall on the city each night. They cheer when they see the rebels fighting back. One day, while out buying bread with her sisters, a battle ensues. They return home, pale, shaking, and without food. An hour later, a friendly soldier brings them a bag with bread and tomatoes. Doaa joins in protests from her rooftops, shouting down slogans. A soldier notices and shoots at her. The bullet just misses and Doaa feels invigorated. As the weeks turn into months, the family does what it can to get by. In June 2012, missiles destroy Shokri’s barbershop. The loss sends him into a great depression. Doaa’s brother-in-law loses his own business to a bomb, so flees to Lebanon and sends for his wife and child shortly after. People begin to flee Daraa as the city becomes “a lottery of life and death” (39). The children bicker, argue, rarely sleep, rarely eat, and cling to one another for support.

The stress causes Doaa to develop a terrible sty on her eye. Hanaa leads her across the battleground but they cannot afford the medical treatment. The doctor lances the sty for free. With Doaa feeling the effects of the anesthetic, they struggle to return home. They go to Hanaa’s sister Iman’s home but men accost them along the way who become angered when the women ignore them. Hanaa and Doaa run, just making it to Iman’s door in time. The men leave, but Iman reveals that the men are kidnapping people and torturing them. That night, Hanaa and Doaa sneak home after the curfew. They need to fill Doaa’s antibiotics prescription. As they pass through the streets, they see fresh bodies and blood. While hiding in the shadows, they see a group of men throw a body in a dumpster. Eventually, they arrive home. That night, Hanaa and Shokri decide that it is time to leave Syria. He phones his son-in-law and asks for help. 

Chapters 1-3 Analysis

The opening chapters of the book function as an introduction to the lives of Doaa’s family and the rise of the Syrian civil war. One of the bloodiest conflicts of the 21st century, Fleming portrays the civil war from a ground level. Told from the perspective of one family—and, in particular, one teenage girl—the war is quick to develop and seemingly impossible to escape. It is all-encompassing. It quickly takes over the lives of everyone involved and ensures that there can be no way of returning to the peaceful existence that seemed to exist beforehand. The opening chapters of the book provide a contrast between life as it was in Syria and life during the war.

But that is not to say that life before the war was ideal. It is difficult for Doaa to understand the nature of her life before the protests begin. Growing up in Syria, life under the Assad regime is all she has ever known. Family gatherings, playing with her friends, and living with her loving mother, father, brothers, and sisters, are all de rigueur in Doaa’s life. To her, the scale of existence is incredibly local; she cannot comprehend the idea of a wider world or a different kind of life. To the young Doaa, life’s greatest challenges are moving to a new house or moving school. A shy young girl, she dreads the thought of having to make new friends or not being able to attend her family’s Mother’s Day traditions. This is the scale of the issues in her life. With so little understanding of the political reality of the Syria of her childhood, Doaa’s dream of joining the police force is almost sickeningly naïve. It is a short-lived dream, anyway. Soon, she witnesses the true nature of the government. Once the tanks arrive in Daraa, Doaa will struggle to understand how she ever thought the situation in Syria was good or how she could ever hope to be an instrument of a state she comes to despise.

Doaa’s development as a character over these three chapters unfurls from an increased awareness of the world around her. She sees news reports (from Tunisia, Egypt, and elsewhere in the world) and begins to realize that it is possible to fight back against an oppressive regime. Her shyness begins to evaporate as she becomes more involved in the protest movement. Attending demonstrations gives Doaa a purpose and transforms her character. Her life becomes defined by the forces she hates rather than those which she loves. The government is an institution against which she can rebel, and this rebellion gives her the purpose that she has sought her entire life. Doaa was never interested in marriage but had no idea what could satisfy her determination and ambition. The protests satisfy this craving, providing her with a purpose that she is yet to truly understand.

But there is nuance in the narrative. Though the actions of the regime are brutally violent, including the torture of young boys, there are those within the government forces who are more understanding. The soldiers who treat the family kindly are evidence of this; they give gifts of food when they can and take an understanding approach to the frequent raids on the family home. This has the effect of directing the novel’s ire against the institution and the regime rather than individual soldiers. Like many of the other residents of Daraa, the soldiers are struggling to get by. Though they commit brutal acts, the narrative takes a more sympathetic view of the individual soldiers than it does of Bashar al-Assad, the government figures, or the unified forces as a whole. This is a subtle difference, but it brings an added human tension to the story in a terrible war zone. 

blurred text
blurred text
blurred text
blurred text